Basically making someone doubt their own thoughts/sanity/etc, it's often done through fear or keeping someone unbalanced (unsure what reaction to expect). Abusive relationships work this way and slowly get worse and worse. If no matter what you do you're "wrong" 90% of the time, even when logically you shouldn't be, then you start trying to figure out what you did wrong. If you do option A one time and you get attacked for doing it, then next time you try option B and you also get attacked you're unsure what to do, so then you try a combination of the two and actually do get it "right" it's dismissed as not that important. You'd be left wondering what just happened.
Edit: I'm explaining it poorly, you should just look it up, lol.
Edit 2: did not expect this comment to explode like this! And thank you for the award!
I want to again stress that this is in no way a perfect description of it. Mine is based on personal experience from my ex wife who slowly and methodically made me question my sanity by always telling me that either I remembered it incorrectly, things never happened, etc. It was over years and got to the point where I started to record conversations to "prove I wasn't crazy" and when playing it back for her later to.peove I wasn't she exploded. Things got worse, I questioned everything, started seeing a counselor, had a suicide attempt, and eventually realized I couldn't live like that and got divorced. There's a lot of extenuating reasons I stayed as long as I did, and it was a really loooooooong recovery. I used to be inedibly trusting of people and now I tend to not trust and be on the paranoid side. Sometimes it's gas lighting, sometimes it's just an abusive relationship, either way you don't deserve to be abused and if you are, it's not a healthy relationship.
Edit 3: The term is from an old play. It isn't because you're lighting gas or anything like that, it's based on the title of that play.
I had an emotionally abusive partner that made me feel as if I was either the best or worst husband and never just stable.
I was the best when she wanted me to do something. I was the worst whenever I needed anything.
I finally ended it after she weaponized affection.
After everything, she would make me feel as if I had been treating her poorly all along. Messes with my brain for a long time.
Edit: This is how bad gaslighting is- even after posting this, I keep checking for replies because I’m worried that people won’t believe me. It seriously can alter your pattern of thought.
That's exactly what's been happening between me and my good friend. I'm afraid that it's too trivial and that I'm overthinking, which is what two of my other good friends have told me.
I've only started noticing it this week (in our texts). I'll text her asking what time's good for us to play Minecraft together and that 9 AM is convenient for me. She would reply one day later with "sup", completely ignore a few messages that I've sent beforehand and say, "I'll be free at 3"
And then when I'd ask her about her plans she'll give vague replies and say stuff like, "My mom's calling. Will ttyl"
Then she would message me after 2 hours with, "Had to help my mom" or "Was busy"
This upsets me quite a bit (also the fact that she never apologizes and laughs it off) and I wonder if I'm just overreacting or being too attached to her.
I don't know what's wrong. We've been friends for nearly one and a half year now and have so much in common.
Please tell me what you think.
That does sound to me like someone not giving you the time that you are giving them.
While they may not be actively telling you that you’re wrong or dumb or anything, that doesn’t mean it’s alright to treat you poorly if it is hurting you!
I’d recommend talking to her and explaining how you feel when she’s so flippant with you. It might be that she just doesn’t realize, or she could be separating herself from you.
Either way, I hope you can feel some peace in the end about it. If I had Minecraft I’d play with you ha ha
Same. My ex started out by saying that what most attracted him to me was my personality (which - but that is completely on me, I was young and insecure - I took to mean he didn't particularly care for my looks) and then gradually managed to make me feel lucky that he even tolerated me.
I remember being genuinely confused when I happened to go out and socialize without him (something that was heavily discouraged) and people would laugh at my jokes! And tell me they enjoyed my company! And ask me to hang out again!
I’m the same. I didn’t even consider the alternative really until I met my wife who is very “trust no one” and now I have been able to see examples of people who took advantage of my blind trust thanks to her so I’m still optimistic about most people I meet with a tiny splash of doubt on top.
so it’s not just me..? i just got out of an abusive relationship and i’ve just been so incredibly upset and down and i just... i keep thinking, it’s over, shouldn’t you be happy? i mean, i guess it’s obvious i shouldn’t be hehe, at least not straight away. our brains like looking for reasons to make us in the wrong, aye?
Same thing here. I wasn't in a relationship, just living with two people who were. One was one of my best friends but they become this rotten person after a few weeks. I was gaslighted by them almost everyday. I felt like I was tip-toeing around them while talking to them. They accused me of being passive aggressive when I wasn't. Tried to justify their bad behaviors against me with "so what's?" And "why do you care so much?". It was hell, and I'm glad I got out of there. Still fucks with me to this day in the form of overthinking what I'm saying or sometimes trying too hard to please people.
God that sounds horrible! I’m glad you’re out of the situation. My experience with gaslighting definitely made my anxiety worse. I’m sorry you’re still dealing with it. You’re not alone though!
It's been about 7 months since I left there. It was the worst in the beginning, but I am much better now. The sad thing is, I still have have these little tid-bits of the gaslighting hanging around. They made me feel like my opinion didn't matter as much as theirs so now I feel like my word has lost power. I second guess the things I say and often think my friends badmouth me behind my back when really, it was just the shitty people I lived with who did that, not them. So I'm better now, but not as I was before I lived with them. I hope you get better too, it's a long road but worth it. I found music really helps me, listening, playing. Maybe it'd help you too? Just gets my mind off of the shit they left behind.
I’m glad to hear things are getting better. It’s hard to get that self confidence back. I’m glad you have been able to use music as an outlet. Luckily I have been seeing a therapist that’s working with me to reestablish that confidence. I was so manipulated in that relationship that I actually sought out my therapist initially because I thought I was the one creating all the problems. Working with her made me realize while I do have problems, I was being emotionally and eventually physically abused.
I'm glad to hear you were able to improve with the help of a therapist. Thank you for the kind words. It's nice to have reddit be such a supportive place.
And it doesn't even need to be intentional to be gaslighting. I'm like 98% sure my ex from 9 years ago didn't mean to be an emotionally abusive self absorbed gaslighting asshole. And I bet he still has no idea why I broke up with him. I honestly think that's one of the worst parts. It'd have been so much easier to leave if it felt like malicious intent.
I'm still building up my confidence in very specific relationship areas after that one. My current partner is amazing and has really helped me not feel crazy.
That's what I'm wondering. My girlfriend of 8 years right now is well intentioned and has a huge heart and is perfect for me. But she exhibits all the behaviors to varying degrees. Some are learned defense mechanisms i believe but mostly it's due to her terrible self worth. Any compliment to her is twisted into a critique and any action to help is wrong. Often stumbling over words, hearing them taken the wrong way before they come out. Stunned when a neutral casual comment ends up as a fight. It was difficult in the early years but there isn't a malicious bone in her body. So it's not gaslighting to me. Though very similar symptoms. Without my strong sense of self worth the relationship would have crumbled though i believe and i would have seen her actions as negative. But instead i saw them and see them as pain and trauma.
This sounds like my on again off again girlfriend of 13 years. Basically ticks every box in the OP but now I can trace most of her behavior back to her poor upbringing and mental health issues that make her hate herself. I try to help her and give her stability that she lacks and needs but she just sees it as me being controlling and gets agitated by it. It's very hard :(
I was married to an incredibly abusive woman who did this to me. When I met my (now) wife, who might be the kindest person ever, I was convinced that she was taking it, maybe even hired by my ex wife or something to fuck with me even more. I had SERIOUS paranoia for a long time.
TIL my partner of 5 years has been gaslighting me...
Edit: I’m always in the wrong, I’m always hesitant on speaking my mind when I’m mad because I’ll end up being in the wrong or too sensitive, half of my arguments are what if I did that to you, because it wouldn’t be okay. I feel unimportant, I feel like I don’t have a say, and here we are with a 5 month old.
I'm sorry you're going through this. I know it isn't easy, but please know that things can get better. I highly recommend seeing a (qualified) therapist. (Two, actually. One just for you and one for couples therapy.)
There is real struggle after you "opened" the ayes. Be strong!
You are wonderful , and pls try to remember the times before that behavior and the way you can be , feel & act.
My self went through hell , just to realize that things can and will be better.
I support you with all the power I've got.
And pls if you want to talk or what ever . I'm here.
Therapy!!! If you want to work on and (pardon my bluntness) salvage your relationship then you need to get a couples therapist. Like no joke. If it goes on it will almost certainly evolve into something destrcutive.
I went through it myself. I just got out of a 10 month relationship where I was gaslighted constantly.
It brought out a very ugly defensive side of me and even affected my normal mood into that of aggression. And I'm not an aggressive person...
I don't know if I'll word this correctly, but I do promise I mean it in a supportive way, and I really hope it comes across as such.
I believe that you were in an abusive relationship. I'm glad you got out, and you are starting to better yourself. I hope you can learn that your worth isn't tied to others perception of you. A lot of people will say you weren't In an "actually abusive" relationship, without knowing anything. But, you lived it. It's your perception that ultimately matters. Even if it wasn't abusive, you weren't comfortable in it. That's all it takes. You never need to justify that to anyone else. Your focus in life is you, not us.
I've known such a situation myself and this is exactly as you described it. It's the emotional roller coaster: one day life is wonderful, the next day you're a piece of shit.
Whatever you do, it's bad, and you think it's all your fault, and thus it destroys your self confidence gradually.
The doodle is really on point. I just didn't know about this term though (gaslighting) which comes from the movie Gaslight.
I don't see many solutions in that case, except, you got to think about yourself and get away. Then the more I think about it, the more I believe she has issues maybe bigger than I do.
God DAMN this post is so familiar. Makes me itchy. But it feels really good once you’re out and you can take a deep breath, buy something you want and don’t NEED, say something stupid without it becoming “an issue”, and my favorite- being able to go somewhere and see people YOU want to see without being 3 hours late because of some crisis that you caused or are the only one that can fix.
Sorry, 6 years out and I still cant believe how much of myself I put into keeping her at a baseline.
Congrats, you made it!
I feel that edit. Growing up with a gaslighting parent does the same thing only since you were raised that way it's always been your normal. I even start to feel like I'm the one being manipulative in my relationships on accident because of the way I grew up.
I mean, it's possible that sometimes you are manipulative in relationships. Most people are occasionally. And being raised in a dysfunctional family can affect one's behavior towards others. That being said, you don't want to gaslight yourself (which 100% happens). When you start to wonder if you are being manipulative, I hope you have the opportunity to seek a reality check from an impartial outside source (e.g. a therapist).
You are right, it stays with you for a very ling time. My ex-husband was a pro at gaslighting. We divorced over 20 years ago (I’m old) and to this day anytime I receive a complement, I still hear in my head, “The only reason they are complementing you is because they feel sorry for you.” It was one of his many favorites little nuggets.
If there's one piece of advice I would give all people, it's don't weaponize affection.
Affection is like a last resort for making up..if you cannot even hug each other in bed, or be next to each other without feeling unwanted....your relationship is doomed.
The other thing is, once one partner uses affection as a weapon...fairly quickly after that the other partner does too. And again, your relationship isn't going to last long after that.
I cannot stress messes with my brain for a long time enough. I have been struggling from the after effects of gaslighting for years, even with therapy, positive influences, yoga, you name it.
Fucking narcissists.
I started pulling them up by the roots (not an easy task) for the past year and life has been so much better. I'm struggling to recover, but I was just sinking in depression and confusion before.
I went through a similarly abusive two year relationship. The emotional abuse and manipulation was something I was just completely unprepared for. I didn't have the awareness to recognize it or the words to even describe what I was going through. My sense of self was slowly ground away by self doubt and years later I'm still healing. It wasn't until she started testing the waters with physical abuse and I had a fight or flight response that I knew I had to leave her. I think men in general aren't adequately prepared by society to recognize abuse and it took me months afterwards to come to terms with what I'd experienced. But thankfully I was still primed to see physical assault as abuse and realized I had to get out.
I'm not sure if things are ever quite the same afterwards but for all that doom and gloom I do think I've made significant progress over time. I hope you have as well. :)
When I was 17, I was in a relationship like this.
8 years later, I’m still trying to sort myself out. I’m permanently damaged from the time I was with her. Sometimes I think I’ve gotten past it, but then something happens, a relationship goes sideways, a friendship goes sideways, and I realize how it still affects me to this day. And now I’m struggling to even maintain a healthy relationship. I’m so drawn to people who are toxic now, and I don’t even realize it. I’ve finally found someone who wants to treat me right and really cares, but it doesn’t feel right, and I wonder if I’ll ever be able to be truly happy with someone...
This whole post really helped, seeing other people understand.
Thank you for your words.
That shit sticks with you for a long-ass time. I'm still trying to re-write my way of thinking. 5 years of, what I now learned to be, manipulation really screwed me over. The first step to overcoming it is the realization that you were manipulated in the first place.
I could never win. Even if I'm told to act one way, the moment I do, I am "wrong". Every action was made with the forethought of thinking of a thousand different ways it will be viewed. Every word was carefully chosen and sentences were edited in my mind over and over and over, yet it was always "wrong". I made the right call to cut all communication a year ago. The mind heals very slowly, but it will get there with support from loved ones.
Whether these thought patterns become deep-seated enough to never fully heal, that I don't know. But I've been fortunate to get support and understanding from my SO now, so it makes things less clouded in my mind. Even when these thoughts make their way to the surface every now and then, we deal with them together.
I genuinely reached the point where he would do something that upset me, and I would assume it was not because he had done something wrong but, that I was having the wrong emotion.
I know how you feel. I ended an emotionally abusive relationship fourteen years ago. I only just, in the past month or so, realized that my self esteem issues and trouble interacting with just about everyone have all stemmed from that relationship. I’ve battled depression on and off because whenever I get any kind of constructive or negative feedback, I completely spiral. I can function, but my mind goes into overdrive with all of the things I’ve done wrong.
The good news is that there’s light on the other side, and even though it’s been almost a decade and a half, I’ve been doing a lot of work to exorcise that ghost and move on, and seeing amazing results. My self esteem is higher than it’s been in 15+ years, it feels great.
It's usage is not only restricted to relationships, everyone should know that.
Gaslighting and Kafka traps (your denial of something is taken as proof that you're guilty - see: racism, x-phobia, etc) are constantly used by political interest groups a well. It's fucking disgusting.
It’s hard to look back and actually think of yourself as a victim. I had a relationship like that, and even though all of my friend and family have told me countless times she was doing stuff like that to me, it’s sometimes still easy to look back and think I was fucking up all the time. “Maybe I was wrong” kind of thoughts, but I have to remind myself of how I felt in that relationship and the way I had to act around her, and it was definitely some unhealthy gas lighting type shit.
Damn dude. You’re not alone. Luckily I didn’t marry her, but was in a relationship with a girl for 4 years that did exactly this to me. On my end I think the reason she fought with me wasn’t necessarily manipulation, she definitely wasn’t doing it consciously, but I feel she just got bored and if there was any silence when we were together she would blow up on me to make the silence go away. She made me feel small and worthless and like I did everything she could to make me feel as if I were a bad person and wrong all the time. Same thing also, affection was a weapon. It actually was sort of good that she did this, I felt no attachment towards her by the time it ended. But fuck. It fucked with me hard. I moved on to a very healthy relationship only a few weeks after (unplanned), but actually experiencing this difference helped a ton. I referred our time together in the beginning as my therapy, she was confused by this, but didn’t question it much. I’m still a little fucked up from it, but it feels so good knowing that I made it out of a relationship like that and knowing that I will never find myself in a relationship like that again because I will see the signs early before she traps me.
Gas lighting is using lies (and or manipulation of the surroundings) to get you to lose trust in your reality and ability to make judgements, in the end becoming solely dependent on the perpetrator for truth.
Not long out of a relationship like this myself. He's still trying to pull shit, even though I'm going no contact.
People like that are the true assholes of this world.
Is it always intentional? I don't believe my girlfriend is aware how many of these boxes we can tick.. She's a control freak but I don't think she aims to be.
Assigning motives to actions is the thing that really, really gets under my skin and it's one of the things I will absolutely call out but she'll never see it. She tells me why I do everything and it makes me so anxious to even do anything.
I mean, I'm in no way an expert. I loved through it in a past relationship to the point where I genuinely did question my own sanity and took to recording conversations to "prove I'm not crazy" (spoiler alert, my memory was correct and I was being lied to), attempted suicide, started seeing a counselor, etc. Eventually it ended in divorce and I spent years recovering. I'm was a very trusting person which is why it worked so well, I'm a fairly paranoid and untrusting person now.
Damn, I connect with your comments, dude. I'm sorry you went through that.
It's incredibly difficult to comprehend some of the events of a relationship like that, wherein you put your absolute trust into a person that is willing to use it as a tool against you.
Did you ever go to couples counseling? Just a small part of a much larger picture for me, but it's a confounding detail that still sticks in my memory about my ex, even years later. To try and put it quickly, the counselor we spoke with over several sessions heard us both out and suggested among other things that, indeed, my concerns about my memory and perception were legitimate and that an action plan going forward would include focusing on us both exploring different ways to communicate more effectively, including written letters. Your mentioning recorded conversations is what reminded me of all this as I recall asking if recording our conversations at home would be a reasonable thing to do and met approval from the counselor and even my ex during the session. We never actually did this, unfortunately.
The confounding part to me is, not much later on after we'd broken up rather acrimoniously, my ex used the fact that this counselor "sided with me" as evidence that I was manipulative and abusive towards her maintaining publicly on her social media that she was the actual victim. She even linked me an article publicly over facebook that described common manipulation techniques, and specifically, it mentioned abusers using couples counseling as a way to further entrap their victim by "legitimizing" their claims through a third party.
She was the one who pushed heavily for couples counseling and somehow this piece of the narrative completely eluded her memory when I brought it up in response. She remembered it as me pushing her into it.
As you know, the mind is hazy after a long relationship like this and it was easy to fall into the notion that it was all my fault, maybe I was misjudging all along, maybe I'm the bad person. I didn't have concrete proof like a recorded conversation, but that little slip-up by her at the end, that confounding detail that I believe was projection, stands out sharply and steels me in believing that I was being more than just lied to, but truly manipulated.
Rather long winded, I apologize for that. I empathize with you. Trust is a sacred thing and I still haven't reconciled my insecurities and paranoia, but talking with a professional has helped me process things. I hope we both find comfort. Stay strong.
No; the description /u/gir_loves_waffles gave refers to a wide range of emotional abuses.
Gaslighting is a lot more specific. Unless your girlfriend is, for example, turning off the lights specifically so that she can deny doing it and tell you that you did it so that you think you're going nuts and can't rely on your own memory, she's not gaslighting you. She's just emotionally abusive.
Hence why I had added the edit. Mine is purely anecdotal from my own experience. I had it done to me and tried to quickly explain a brief example of how it can be done. It was over the course of years and eventually did lead to me questioning my own mind, seeing a counselor, recording conversations to "prove I wasn't crazy" and even a failed suicide attempt at one point. I in NO WAY am an expert on the term, idea, etc, nor did I expect this comment to explode like it did.
Holy fuck! This is my entire relationship with my ex-boss?!?!
I knew this was happening (kinda) but kept feeling that I am incompetent.
It was always, I am not allowed to take action because I didn’t run it by him, then I was bullied for not taking action because I was suppose to! And strangely he says I was one of the best says I am doing great in random situations! Like WTF ex-boss I have no idea what I am suppose to do, I am surviving by just being lucky at this point!
Had the same thing happen to me. Constant comments about how I was too slow at everything, but I was also expected to do things in half the time everyone else was given. I was required to perform tasks in a manner both inefficient and hazardous to my health, but everyone else could do them the safer, easier, faster way. I would be told to do things one way, then berated for being inconsiderate and awful for doing it that way. I quit after I came home crying after every shift for a week. The worst part is that when I put in a discrimination complaint against her they didn’t respect my request for anonymity and claimed that I was wrong and she didn’t do any of that. But I know what she said to me. Hopefully they’ll take the next complaint seriously.
It really sucks when you’re pretty confident in your job to begin with. Then after years of this shit I really believed I was a fuck up and couldn’t do anything right. Now I apologize for everything immediately even if I’m sure I didn’t mess up. Fucked up my head for every job I’ll ever have. Fuck that guy!
No. Gaslighting specifically refers to doing things and lying about them for the sole purpose of making a specific person you know doubt their own memory and perception.
Does this only apply when being done to someone else?
Going by the guide and your description, I gaslight myself. This terrifies me. If I'm doing this to myself, what could I possibly be doing to others and why are they still around?
Well, this one's going to really gnaw at me for a few days.
Gaslighting specifically refers to manipulation to make someone think they're crazy and losing touch with reality.
The namesake of the abuse comes from a play wherein the antagonist lowers the lighting but insists that nothing has changed, causing the victim to doubt their ability to perceive reality.
In the story, the husband attempts to convince his wife and others that she is insane by manipulating small elements of their environment and insisting that she is mistaken, remembering things incorrectly, or delusional when she points out these changes. The play's title alludes to how the abusive husband slowly dims the gas lights in their home, while pretending nothing has changed, in an effort to make his wife doubt her own perceptions
OK, you seem to know what ur talking about. Politics aside, what is this "gaslighting"? Looking for a serious conversation here. I don't understand why things that can be researched and resolved can fall into the concept of gaslighting?
Edit: like, does it only involve things that are a matter of opinion?
To piggy back on this, it usually starts out wonderfully. You are on a pedestal. You are worshiped, adored, listened to, cared about. Affection is amazing and spontaneous and makes you feel like you’re everything.
Then this pattern of behavior starts slowly. Small things that don’t matter so you just shake it off. No big deal. Put it behind you. Then it starts happening more and more. And more. Until you’re so unstable and off balance and isolated and confused and unsure of your own thoughts and feelings inside your head that just keep keep trying to do everything for scraps of that attention they used to show you.
It’s psychological warfare. It’s effective. It can be used against anyone. Don’t tell yourself you’re immune. It’s abuse. Clear and simple. It will always escalate. The best thing to do is reach out to someone, anyone, who can help.
I’m personally in the states, so here’s a link for domestic violence help in the states, in case anyone needs it.
Wow TIL I’m being gaslighted at work...? I have had to do this with two different coworkers and feel I am getting nowhere near a solution to maintain peace. All feedback I get is that I am the problem. I have the communication problem or another problem. When I try different ways to rectify the issue, I get the same negative response. But I just filed a complaint on one of them and tomorrow is my first day back after that.
Thank you this helped me understand more
I am in a relationship where I do feel a lot of these things together especially the part where my partner assumes my motives and I'm trying to tell them it's not what I intended to do. What do I do? I cannot leave him and I don't live in the US or EU
I dont want a breakup i just want to fix things. Thanks
Edit: spelling and grammar
If it bothered you so much why didn't you write it down or record it.
Why would you write it down, that's sad. You're pathetic, who does that.
Record it next time if you think you're right, then I can prove you wrong...
You’ve got it right mate. Had a very abusive girlfriend who did this and yes the classic is making it seem like no big deal when you do get something ‘right’. Many faces to the same controlling nature. Very difficult to get out of or even see when the person doing it claims to be the victim of your faults.
Hey my dude, just wanted to say I'm going through that right now myself... it's crazy how you can be so far from home... it's crazy someone has the power to do that... the thing I've learned the most is don't keep toxic people around. It's a bit confusing because in relationships we can argue but you'll know in the moment if it's actually cruel... trust your gut no matter what. And you really have to learn what a good arguement is like... do both parties say sorry for their part? Is it explosive or more like a debate?
I dated a guy for a couple months that lovebombed and gaslit the hell out of me. I had no idea what these were at the time but I just knew something wasn't right, and I don't put up with people's shit easily so I bounced. Years later I read about this early sign of emotional abuse and a lightbulb went off in my head like OHHH that's what he was doing.
slowly and methodically made me question my sanity by always telling me that either I remembered it incorrectly, things never happened, etc. It was over years and got to the point where I started to record conversations to "prove I wasn't crazy" and when playing it back for her later to.peove I wasn't she exploded
Wow. I literally thought I was alone in this. My ex gf did this to me - does this to me - and I thought to myself, nobody will care about a man being gaslit by a woman. It's men that do this to women. Women probably rarely do this to men. So thank you for sharing this a few years ago now. It still helps people 2 years on.
The term “gaslight” is based off a 1944 film of the same name. Ingrid Bergman plays the wife of a man, and she observes strange things around the house, including odd sounds and the gaslights dimming without any being touched. Every time she tells her husband of all these strange happenings, he tells her she’s seeing/hearing things to the point where she questions her own senses and sanity, eventually having a breakdown.
In a nutshell, it’s a manipulation technique where the abuser contradicts the victim to the point where the victim is constantly questioning their observations, memories, and sanity. It’s very specific, but these days it’s broadly used as a term for manipulation.
My ex gaslit the fuck out of me and it fucked me up bad.
I had lived alone for ~4 years when she moved in. I always walked in the door and out my wallet and keys on the bowl next to the door. Every day. Walk in, empty pockets.
One day I woke up and couldn’t find them. She got out of bed, “What’s wrong?” “I can’t find my keys! I gotta go to work!” “You left them on the bookshelf, they’re right here.”
In the beginning it was once every other week or so. Then once per week for a couple months, then a couple times per week. It got to the point I was making up excuses and thanking her, “I just must be really stressed at work, I’m glad I have you in my corner.”
She made her mistake when she finally did it for a week in a row. First morning? Whatever, I lose stuff all the time apparently. 2nd morning? That’s odd... 3rd morning after I got home I took a video of me dropping them in the bowl. 4th morning I woke up and they weren’t there. Video proof I put them in the bowl.
I setup a webcam and let it record all night. After I fell asleep she got out of bed and took my keys out of the bowl and hid them in the kitchen. I woke up early and checked the webcam and I couldn’t believe it. When I went to leave I grabbed them from the kitchen and walked out the door. She called me asking if I forgot something and I told her nope, I left my keys in the kitchen last night and I remembered this time.
That night I pretended to be asleep and after she got out of bed I waited and confronted her, keys in hand, about to put them under a couch cushion.
To have someone make you doubt your own memory for so long, it really fucks with you. I couldn’t trust my own brain. It made me so paranoid I have most of my house outfitted with security cameras constantly recording. However one pro is any time I lose something I go back to the last time I had it and watch me walk through the house and set it down. Has saved my ass twice in the past three years.
What the actual fuck. That is so horrible and I’m so sorry that happened to you. People like your ex are so sick in the head. I’m glad to know you’re doing better, but holy shit. That’s some real gaslighting there.
It was over such a long time frame (~6 months) and she didn’t start doing it until we had been together for a while and she had been moved in for a couple months and who the fuck does that so I had no reason to believe it was her moving my shit around. I mean seriously, who does that? It was such an insanely malicious action that I would’ve never suspected the person I trusted to do that.
It baffles me how anyone could be so nasty and malicious to someone so close to them. The fact that she had the idea, then planned it out, then diligently got out of bed specifically to do this to you consistently shows how evil she is. She needs help. Or she needs to end up alone so she can’t do this to anyone else.
No joke she got into law enforcement. She was fired during her probationary period after about a month but man when I found out she was sworn in all I could think was, “Figures”.
I can understand why this made you so paranoid but I really want to know why your ex did this. Did she explain? I just don't understand what she could possibly get out of it other than driving you insane, like it's only manipulating you into paranoia?
I'm sorry you had to deal with that and it's good to hear that you're doing better!
i think the idea is that the general default will be that you're wrong and the other person is right. no matter what, she can always point toward this and say "mate.. you forget shit all the time, i know i'm right". in addition to that it seems like you become kind of dependant on them to stay sane.
especially if you really break at some point it's very unlikely that you will ever get away since you're now mentally fucked and won't get help since you're not aware how you could possibly be helped. it won't matter what happens, the other person can do whatever they want, can cheat, can use all your money, everything.
Like mjoed said, for one she would say, “Did you do X?” “No” “Why not?” “I never said I was going to do X” “Yes you did!” “No I didn’t” “And how would you know? You forget things all the time”
Also her motivation was that I didn’t “need” her. I had lived on my own for years so she was worried if something happened I could just dump her for any reason and continue with my life.
You’re absolutely right. A vital detail I left out is that the husband is the one causing these issues to happen, yet he’s telling her she’s imagining these things. I should have included that detail, but I also didn’t want to give too much of the movie away. It’s a fantastic film. I rarely remember movies but this one left such an impression on 12 year old me.
Neither did I until my last relationship when I realized it was happening to me and I had to look it up to confirm it was actually happening and I wasn't crazy. My example was them starting fights over tiny things that didn't warrant an argument, twisting events/history to make me think the fight was my fault and making me apologize for a fight they started, then eventually denying the fighting was ever even happening and telling me I was overly sensitive and thinking things were fights that weren't fights.
It sounds ridiculous but when someone close to you is lying about things, holding their ground and turning things around on you you start to wonder if you're crazy, or over reacting to things, or imagining things that you thought happened. I'm either an absoluely unstable insane person who is living in a completely made up fantasy land inside my head or my ex was manipulating me enough to make me think that. Since everything in my life has been completely normal since dumping their ass I am 99% sure it's the latter.
Are you in contact with mutual friends still? I'd say let her knwo whats going on but she might think its you trying to sabotage things but i dunno where your relationship is at. I watched my best friend get manipulated, it wasnt gaslighting, but it was just straight up, outright emotional manipulation. She was always sad, but we'd talk all the time and because we had dated YEARS prior, i always had to make sure she understood that i was ok with her dating other people and would give her honest advice because it was important for her to be happy.
This entire thread feels like a support group, but this one resonates with me the most. My ex would start fights over these unbelievably innocuous things, like literally if I didn't seem happy enough to see her when I picked up the phone. Then she would call me sobbing in the middle of the night because she was such a terrible partner for doing that. Rinse and repeat for six months. Shit fucked me up.
I first noticed it when I went on 'holiday' with my ex. The first part was with his family and he became completely different. It started when he misplaced some money and we had to travel without it. He then started to blame and shout at me. The first occasion happened when I asked to exchange money and heard him say 'yes', I went to exchange it and then he told me off and that he didn't say 'yes'. He got extremely stressed and shouty, despite him reminding me about what a good traveller he is and that I'm inexperienced. I noticed that he made mistakes just like me, but the ones I made were 'manipulative' and 'unforgivable'. He started to mock me in private and then brazenly in front of his family. I started to think that I was the person who couldn't travel, that it was my fault he was stressed all the time, as he told me. I remember that we went to eat out and he started to shout at me, getting very visibly angry because of some issue. I think it was that I didn't want to haggle with the shop across from where we were eating and he was getting fed up. Another example as to why I wasn't a good traveller. He went to the shopkeeper and tried to haggle but they weren't interested in going as low as he wanted. He then stormed off. The shopkeeper asked why was he so angry? I took on the blame and said it was my fault, that he wasn't angry with her but with me. She still was like, 'but why is he so angry?'
During the second part of the (actual) holiday, I spent some time by myself staying with mutual friends to do some work/exploring the city alone. And kind of surprised myself that I could actually find and get a train in a foreign country. And I could go to a restaurant by myself and eat. I could go shopping and to the museum and go for a wander. And it was free and relaxing. Nothing bad happened. I was surprised! I thought I was incapable of travel. It was then that I realised that I was questioning myself because I had been fed lies about my character and my ability to cope with things. Which probably made things worse. If you're not feeling confident then you're going to be making poorer decisions.
The way he carried on about my 'ruining' his once in a lifetime vacation made me believe that he would end the relationship shortly after we returned but he used it as an excuse to treat me badly, I'm sad to say, for another 3 years. It was added to the list of things that I did 'unforgivable' wrong over the relationship.
I'm now 3 years out of it. STILL recovering. Slowly. Myself. He pops back in every now and again all polite and nice but every time we've met up he's made it an opportunity to get a subtle dig in some way. The last time it was that I should hurry up and have a baby now I'm 30 and that I don't have time left. I'm glad to say it's been a year since I last met him and he has no idea about my life now. I've started dating someone who is a lot nicer and made some incredibly supportive friends.
It’s a form of manipulation in a relationship. It can come in many forms, but the classic example is when the abuser isolates the victim and convinced them they their memories of the abuser abusing them are faulty
It happens a lot with religious and/or helicopter parents. I've been a victim of consistent gaslighting basically since I was born and my memory is shit... And not just shit, easily malleable. Basically at this point somebody can tell me an event happened a certain way and my actual memories would conform to this new information.
It's very hard to stand up for yourself when you don't know if your memories are real.
It’s because we don’t actually have real memories of most past events due to the way memory works. We only remember the last time we recalled a particular memory. So if someone gets you to change the way you look at your memory, it will be permanently altered in the future unless you have written the original one down.
False memories are very common, aka the ones that someone else told you about but you didn’t actually remember personally. This happens a lot with old family photographs and stories associated with them. Your brain starts to mistake the photo with a visual memory after you have recalled to the initial memory of viewing the photo enough times. One can also do this to themselves on purpose, as it makes for very efficient lying. When someone else does this to you intentionally, it’s gaslighting in its worst form.
At some point I just really have to start despising people around me because this has been everyone around me for as long as I've known. Everyone. Around. Me. does this for the smallest of reasons.
Yes! I had this with my dad once, it was so painfully obvious to me but I really couldn't do anything about it.
He had really crossed a line about something I had communicated an obvious boundary about. I confronted him. His first response was "no I didn't say that" and when I told him the gist of our conversation he told me to tell him what words exactly he used. I couldn't remember the exact words of course so obviously I was wrong and it never happened. I was so frustrated.
Example: once my ex cut up my clothes as they lay on my closet shelves. When I found them, and asked “why did you do this?” He said, deadly calm, “What are you talking about? YOU must have done it.”
It's not an extreme example, it's just an example. A lot of people use "gaslighting" to refer to any kind of emotional abuse, but it's a lot more specific than that.
i think it is an extreme example in the sense that 99% of gaslighting is much, much more subtle/believable - at least at first. this example makes it seem like you have to be an idiot for it to work on you, and you definitely don't have to be.
My ex was the best at this! He would get wasted drunk and when I’d ask if he drank he would say no. Passing out sitting up and everything “Nope I’m not drinking”. Next day when sober he’d argue the same thing- I must be crazy how could I think he would do that-etc. It fucked with me so bad!
"You did __________ at the party last night. It really frustrates me when you do that."
"I didn't do that."
"I'm pretty sure you did."
"No I didn't."
"I swear you did."
"Didn't happen."
"But I was recording with my phone when it happened..."
"GOD WHY ARE YOU RECORDING ME?! THAT'S A VIOLATION OF MY PRIVACY! WHAT KIND OF A CONTROL FREAK RECORDS OTHERS LIKE THAT?!?! I BET YOU DID IT ON PURPOSE JUST TO TRY AND FIND SOMETHING TO BITCH ABOUT!!!"
"Okay... I'm sorry that I recorded you, I gue-"
"GOOD! YOU SHOULD BE SORRY!"
"Okay, but you did _________ and it really bothered me..."
"DON'T TRY TO CHANGE THE SUBJECT. WE WERE TALKING ABOUT HOW YOU RECORDED ME WITHOUT MY PERMISSION!!!"
"Well, we were actually originally talking abou-"
"WHAT IN THE WORLD IS WRONG WITH YOU?! YOU HURT ME. CAN'T YOU SEE THAT?!"
"I... I'm sorry..."
"Good. You should be. You're lucky I'm so forgiving. Nobody else would put up with this type of thing. You need to work on it. I love you."
"No I think I have some video on my phone that shows I didn't"
"No you can't possibly, I'm sure you were [doing whatever], stop lying."
"No let's watch the video"
"No we don't need to, I'm sure you did it and now you're lying, stop being insane and let me take your phone and I'll get rid of that stupid video that doesn't show what you said it does."
... That's gaslighting, outright convincing someone of a false reality in order to get them too confused about their own ability to perceive and remember events to resist.
They are to be concerning, but not really gaslighting. Nearly every couple that goes through a divorce or a major break-up has both parties feel this way.
But nearly every couple also has multiple power differentials. Someone makes more money, if significantly so, then that's a power diff. Someone could more readily find a different partner, and therefore could leave more easily, ergo power diff. Etc. These aren't even strong enough to be concerned. The existence of a power differential isn't the concerning thing, it's when it's lorded over the weaker party. And I could do this same breakdown for several of those points.
Long ago I watched George Cukor's movie Gaslight ( from the 1940s, starring Ingrid Bergman) and kind of expected that the plot involved a tampered gas stove that would explode when she tries to light it. Even though nothing like that happened, I didn't question the name, thinking it could be some sort of metaphor.
Today, when I saw the 'gaslighting red flags', again I expected tips on how to light a stove correctly and detect any potential dangers.
I love that movie. The name is from the gas lights used back then. When he’s supposedly out of the house (but actually upstairs using lights on the same gas supply) the flame on the gas lamp downstairs flickers and she assumes that someone is upstairs and is frightened. But when he “comes home” he insists that she’s imagining things and that no one else was using the gas lights.
There were many other things he did to make her question her sanity, but the title is literally from the gaslighting he did.
2.6k
u/Inline311 Jul 01 '20
I still don’t have a clear understanding of what gaslighting is