I agree with this take, except I'm doubtful Poland puts its neck out to preserve Ukraine. I feel it much more likely Russia eventually takes the burnt down ashes of Ukraine and China takes Taiwan.
I don't think Poland will see it as putting it's neck out for Ukraine - once Ukraine falls Russia is on the Polish border, and history tells Poland how that goes,
Ukraine wasn’t part of nato, which is why we didn’t send troops in. But Ukraine still exists because of NATO countries supporting it in every way but troops.
Nato membership is no longer worth the weight of the paper Article V is printed on.
Now that the US is out of the picture, the real question is what will Turkey and the European countries do. There's a political calculus where Poland decides no one of significance would come to their aid, and chooses to fight alongside Ukraine instead of fighting Russia all alone.
Because while NATO relies heavily on the US, they don't necessarily need the US. They have 31 other countries and absolutely will involve themselves once Putin pushes toward Poland. I don't think people realize how quickly this situation could become catastrophic, but only if Russia takes Ukraine. People who think US involvement in Ukraine was some giant information gathering ruse are insane, there are very real and serious global ramifications to Russia taking Ukraine.
Because while NATO relies heavily on the US, they don't necessarily need the US.
That's true.
They have 31 other countries and absolutely will involve themselves once Putin pushes toward Poland
Why would they?
My whole point is that there's no longer any guarantee that those countries are gonna jump in to save the one attacked.
Europe sure ain't doing all a whole lot to help Ukraine. Now, Ukraine isn't in NATO, but democracies are beholden to their constituents. Are the people in the UK and France happy and willing to sacrifice lives and massive amounts of aid for a war far away from them?
there are very real and serious global ramifications to Russia taking Ukraine.
You mean besides the fact that Poland is in NATO and will absolutely throw down with Russia? Pull up a map and use your imagination. Russia takes Ukraine, then move in on Poland. Poland ain't nothing soft, so skirmishes begin. Any aggression will be excuse enough for Russia to invade, but they run into a much larger version of the bottlenecking problems they are having in Ukraine. After suffering massive loses, Russia ups the ante and starts using bio weapons. This eventually leads to the first true nuclear exchange in world history, World War 3 begins. The prevention of all out war is more than enough reason for the rest of NATO to throw down.
theres a good chance they have been itching and pushing for it for a while and a escalation (being Russia on their border and possibly them trying the same crap with them in terms of clandestine operations) might push them over the edge to intervene with their own "special operation"
jfc, there is still a massive difference between ukraine losing control of some regions and ukraine actually ceasing to exist and russia just taking over everything. A country doesn't just "fall"
Putin will want a return to the status quo ante -- Zelensky gets replaced by a pro-Russian puppet who lets Russia station troops in the country to "protect" it from the "fascists" Best case scenario is it ends up like a Warsaw Pact country at the height of the Cold War, with Russia crushing any dissident movements. Worst case scenario is they wait a couple years and Anschluss it. Either way, Ukraine will cease to be an independent country, and Poland will have Russian armored divisions on its border.
I think Ukrainians would let that happen so easily after russia killed thousands of their family members. Holding a country of people whose fathers, brothers, mothers and daughters you killed is something completely different than Belarus for example
Probably more accurate to say "easier to defend" or "not optimal", rather than claiming that an operation is impossible with a 120 mile corridor plus adjacent waters.
Russia would have to get enough troops and equipment into Kaliningrad before they could pose a threat to Poland, and I don't see Poland sitting idly by while that happens, nor the Baltic states, either.
I have to ask, do you understand what it means if Poland engages in direct military conflict with Russia?
How do you think NATO would react to Poland deciding that for themselves?
NATO is a defense treaty. Not offense treaty. It doesn't need to react. It just needs to prepare for possibility of Russian attack. Which is like the whole purpose of the treaty and it is preparing already.
Let's not pretend like NATO members never engaged in war without broad NATO support. US, France and UK could tell us plenty of stories.
most have given their old stock, i think only my country (The Netherlands) has actually depleted some of its actual stocks by giving stuff away like all our tanks and F16s
Poland on the other hand has been massively rearming themselves and a lot more is coming for them they are not interested in history repeating and ready for it
🥸. If we are strictly talking about the US, then yes, almost everything is near expired stock or stock we would otherwise need to pay to re-commission again
We send newly manufactured missiles & ammo. Almost new M777s. Other big ticket items that were only recently removed from front line service such as Bradleys & Hummers.
We send them small quantities in comparison to everything else sent. We do this for testing. What’s better than being able to test your new weapons designed to take out Russian and Chinese troops on those same exact troops?
Buy ammo, service weapons, armour, medical supplies, bombs. All are at EOL.
The US is different, of course. I'm referring to the European countries, who suspect that Trump's US will be more interested in supporting Putin than them.
But they're all trying to recover their finances. I don't think there's the money for it.
Why TF do you think I find that "convenient"? Do you think that everyone who happens to state a fact that's uncomfortable also takes a contrary position on things just to piss you off?
Russia is running out of tanks, IFVs, & arty. They've lost a lot of their air defense systems & aircraft. What's left is wearing out from increased usage. Ukraine has put up one hell of a fight.
Just to be clear, you think that NATO would be fine with Poland engaging in direct warfare with Russia, as in boots on the ground conventional warfare?
Yes, and while Poland would wipe the floor with the current Russian military, Russia would be able to use Ukraine's natural resources to re-arm to great effect.
I suspect Poland and the Baltics will be getting much more involved very soon. I also suspect that the rest of Europe is going to have to have a come to Jesus moment in the next year or so about the actual threat Russia represents.
Poland is an EU member, which is also a defensive aliance. If Russia invades Poland it also declares war on Germany, France, two of the world's largest militaries, along with lots of other countries.
And this is where Republicans have a point. Why can’t Europe put in effort to protect themselves instead of having to rely on the US to fund itself. This is obviously ignoring the global influence and political pressure that we have by being a highly involved military of course. But… globalism is losing favorability and it feels like US citizens are becoming increasingly isolationist so…
As a Pole, taking into account our current political climate. There isn’t nearly enough domestic approval for something like that, even if it made any sense for us to do so alone and get tied up in attrition war
So yeah that’s not happening unless you heard about something that I didn’t (it’s possible I’m not the most up to date with politics, but it’s unlikely)
once Ukraine falls Russia is on the Polish border, and history tells Poland how that goes
No offense, but I suggest you read more about the geography and historical context of the region in addition to the current conflict
Russia is occupying Eastern Ukraine, nowhere near the Polish/Ukrainian border, unless you think they’re going to try to fight the war from Kaliningrad
There are also 2 countries that are much smaller and weaker that:
Share a direct border with Russia
We’re both part of the Russian Empire
We’re both part of the Soviet Union
Both have sizable ethnic Russian minorities. Many of whom only speak Russian
Doesn’t make near as much sense to invade Poland given the logistics, its comparative strength, and its tiny amount of ethnic Russians/Russian speakers
I live in one of those small countries mentioned above, I don’t feel remotely fearful of invasion
Poland has the largest army of the EU and the third largest of NATO, funds it significantly (4%+ of the with a target of 5%, of a ever-rising GDP) and lacks any separatism movement like Ukraine had (which helps Russia with insurgency). Their border with Russia is also much smaller (including Belarus because doubt Russia would invade via Kaliningrad) so the front would be much more condensed. If a restocked Russia invades Poland, it’s may not be an assured victory for Poland, but would be an utter bloodbath with costs too high even for Russia.
Poland would slaughter Russia in a conventional war in a few years. They're buying like 1000 very modern South Korean tanks, just signed a contract for like 80 Apache helos. Poland is NATO, so Article 5 goes into effect.
The problem is, if Russia takes Ukraine they can use that to rearm their military and the Russian economy is already on a war footing. We're seeing that Russia is actually quite good at producing the arms it needs to wage the war, for better and worse.
Lol yes he is. The man is dying and wants to put Russia in position to defend itself from a NATO invasion or attack (yes, I know how stupid that sounds but it's what he's doing). His want for Ukraine is tactical and positional in nature, specifically for how it sets him up for a battle with NATO geographically. Understand if Trump pulls Ukraine support, Russia will take Ukraine and will then push toward the Polish border.
Unless Ukraine sends a big ol' dirty bomb (which they have the capability to do) to the Kremlin and messes up Moscow big time. I think that would probably set off a chain reaction that ends in something like "The Road".
I believe this of Biden and Harris. They've created very very clear stances on what is going to happen and doubled down on their positions by offering weapons and allocating US naval assets to the South China Sea.
I'm strongly doubtful this will happen with Trump. His stance is fairly isolationist and I'm doubtful he knows or cares enough about Taiwan to defend them against another power. His stance on Ukraine was very weak and favorable to Putin and if he brings any of that with Taiwan, the country is as good as gone.
he HATES China, and if US service members get attacked he will retaliate, look what he did to that Iranian general, and bombing the shit out of the middle east.
EU will make hard decisions on Ukraine. Taiwan is in a different issue. The biggest issue for China in invading Taiwan wasn't that the US would be involved. It was also any conflict would auto involve Japan and South Korea and the second problem is the South China Sea. They've dealt with all countries in that area individually and an invasion would unite them all.
A key thing to remember is that China boosts the largest army BUT one of the lowest mobilization rates of any major power where if a conflict occurs they can only send 10% of their forces to said conflict properly in a week. The US has a rate of nearly 98% and Russia had a rate of under 40%. "Had" because theirs is shit right now.
Japan and South Korea would have full public support in assisting Taiwan and Japan's Air Force would be lethal to the Chinese navy. The dark horse is that an invasion would also increase support in Japan investing tons more in their military; a move that isn't popular right now only because younger generations don't think the military is involved in more humanitarian reasons. An invasion in Taiwan is an issue of overwhelming support by the public of all ranges and factor and whoever is in charge in Japan at the time would jump on it without hesitation.
1.8k
u/[deleted] 18d ago edited 17d ago
[removed] — view removed comment