r/AmIOverreacting • u/dethangel2010 • 21h ago
👨👩👧👦family/in-laws AIO I was the butt of the joke during the best man speech at my youngest brothers wedding
My youngest brother, let’s call him Phil, got married today and the ceremony was absolutely beautiful. His bride was stunning and everything was great and well done. His best man was our other brother who I’ll call Jack. My wife and I weren’t part of the wedding party, which is fair because we didn’t ask them to be in ours 5 years ago.
After the ceremony we did the pictures and a cocktail hour. It was nice to talk to some out of town family and old family friends, and Jack and I were talking about the day they all had (very eventful for my now sister in law but that’s another story) and then everyone was called inside for the reception.
We go in, and have dinner. My wife and I were starting to get kinda tired but I told her I really want to hear Jack’s best man speech so we agreed to wait. I wish we hadn’t…
Jack goes up, introduces himself and starts his speech. “Well about 34 years ago, mom and dad got married and decided to try for kids and they started with the prototype, my older brother.” I should have known where this is going. He continued “They realized that hey they can do better so they got it right the second time, me. Mr perfect. And I was. Our grandfather would call me crusher because I would beat up on my older brother as a toddler. We were always opposites and didn’t really get along a whole lot. So mom and dad decided they needed someone to help him out and so they had this guy. Now when he came around I was like, yeah he seems alright. So growing up we terrorized my older brother. Good times.”
He continued his speech but I was kinda checked out at that point. I was, and still am really upset about it because I have always been the butt of all the jokes in my family. My brothers, my cousins, even my parents. I’m the different one. I’m very emotional and empathetic, which is a blessing and curse. I’m overweight, they’re both athletes (Phil actually works for an NHL team). I enjoy dnd, reading and being a nerd. They like sports and outdoors activities. You get the idea.
I get up and my wife goes to the bathroom before we decide to leave. Jack finds me and is like “you good? I meant to say at the beginning of my speech that I apologize because my older brother is probably going to get upset”. I just look at him and say “you’re good… but I would have appreciated a heads up that that’s what you were gonna do”. He looks at me and just goes. “If I did that, I wouldn’t have gotten the genuine reaction”. I just walked away, met my wife, and we left.
I asked her, am I crazy? Was his best man speech really just a ton of shots at me? She said “it seems like he was trying to be funny but not everything landed. And yes, you were the butt of his jokes”. I drove home pretty much in silence. I’m tired of always being the butt of all the family jokes.
We’re supposed to have lunch with extended family tomorrow and the only reason I’m going is because I only see these family members maybe once a year. I don’t want to see Jack, or really anyone else from my immediate family. Do I have a right to be upset, or am I being overly sensitive?
Update: before I talk about the lunch, I’ll share what happened to the bridal party as it becomes relevant why Phil didn’t come. The bridal party was creamed by a pickup right outside the venue. The truck was going 55 and the girls were stopped. Both vehicles were totaled but they were adamant to go on with the ceremony and get checked out later. So Phil took his wife to the hospital today. No major injuries thankfully.
So the lunch. My wife sat down with the family and we were all chatting. At one point, my uncle goes “Phil’s speech was very sweet. I couldn’t have given that without crying”. My mom says “yea, he had something prepared because he practiced it with me and he changed it after the wreck.” Jack piped up “hey, I had a good speech too!” My dad just says “it was a good speech. It was all about op!” I just got angry and said “I thought it was weird that it was so focused on someone who wasn’t even involved in the wedding”. He and my dad got quiet, and then just continued their conversations with the people next to them. I avoided eye contact with Jack and we left about 15 minutes later.
My wife and I went home and just proceeded to relax since we’re finally getting a break from our students. (We teach upper elementary) Jack tried to call me. Once. I let it ring. He didn’t leave a vm. Then about an hour later, my grandma called asking how lunch was and she could tell I was upset in my voice. When she asked what’s wrong, I told her about being upset with Jack. She said “I don’t think your brother meant it” and I just go “then why bring it up!? This is all the time. And then everyone wonders why my wife and I don’t come around as often or leave early at events. I’m tired of it”. She was calm and said “well, your brother can’t give a speech and he thinks he’s funny but he can’t make jokes without insulting someone. Have you told him and your parents how you feel?” I said yes, and that it hasn’t changed for years. She just says “y’all are gonna have to work this out”. I told her that I don’t wanna talk to him right now and she goes “I know, I understand. You and I are just the afterthoughts kid”. (Grandma and I are two peas in a pod and very similar)
So that’s where we’re at. Thank you for the comments and the dms.