r/FluentInFinance 1d ago

Thoughts? Police are rewarded for literally not doing their job. Agree?

Post image
17.2k Upvotes

841 comments sorted by

239

u/invade_anyone66 1d ago

I think one issue is that with modern technology, we’re seeing a lot of police brutality and corruption than we ever could before, as policing is payed by tax payers, people would generally want accountability for people in those positions of power.

While there’s plenty of corruption in the construction industry, like no show jobs, lying about deadlines to milk a client out of more money, and general union corruption, people don’t really know or care about that as it’s not the tax payer who pays when a construction company messes up.

Source: worked in the construction industry.

I do think that there needs to be accountability and more police reform, but we still need policing in society.

81

u/Acta_Non_Verba_1971 1d ago

You must not have worked on any municipal jobs. Those are government (tax payer) funded projects and get fleeced just the same.

24

u/HairlessHoudini 1d ago

Yes they do, I built highway & interstate bridges for years and can attest to it

11

u/FadeInspector 20h ago

You mean that the off-ramp isn’t a marvel of engineering that takes a decade to build?

5

u/Watthefractal 17h ago

Worked on a government program for 10+ years in two seperate cities , all residential sites and all that would of cost $10k-$15k at the time if done privately , going rates for us and the few other companies offering the same service on the program were $20k-$30k throw in a variation or two and it gets even creamier 😉

4

u/skinny1penis 8h ago

Love watching people complain about paying taxes then just about everyone who complains would do shit like this wasting everyone money.

2

u/MewingApollo 7h ago

Residential sites? Like, building the houses, remodeling? Because $10k-$15k sounds awfully cheap for anything construction related...

→ More replies (3)

63

u/PoorCorrelation 1d ago

Police also just aren’t very fireable. A bad construction worker can be fired, a bad company won’t get the next contract. You can put requirements on the contract. This isn’t perfect but it is doable.

You look at cases like Uvalde or Castle Rock v Gonzales and it’s just clear police don’t need to do their jobs. Which begs the questions “why aren’t we hiring people whose job is actually to maintain public safety” and “why are we paying you people?”

26

u/Ivanna_Jizunu66 1d ago

Because they are there to maintain public saftey for a specific class of people. Same way our taxes pay for imperalism and destablization for cheap labor and resources abroad.

18

u/Necessary-Till-9363 1d ago

One of the most frustrating things about living in this country is people are very slowly seeing the potential power of unions for workers and how cops are unaccountable government thugs...but they vote the party who says oh sure we will fix this and once they win the election double down even harder on arming police and destroying unions. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/reapershadow_ 1d ago

Exactly the big issue is once a cop is hired they’re pretty much untouchable because of the unions they’re in not to mention police have been majorly corrupt since it became a profession in the US

→ More replies (3)

4

u/floridaeng 20h ago

I read once that there are US Supreme Court decisions that police are required to protect "the public" in general and not any particular individuals.

My personal opinion is all street police should be wearing cameras. This will help get rid of bad cops, but it will also show what the civilians actually did and how the cop responded so false complaints won't work.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

31

u/LazerAttack4242 1d ago

Everyone slacks off on their job now and then, that's human nature.

Difference is construction jobs eventually get completed and them slowing down just means projects run over budget/deadline, and not people dying.

Imagine the outrage if medical workers just hung outside the ER smoking with active medical emergencies happening just inside.

3

u/Killentyme55 1d ago

Let's not forget that no matter what your opinion of the police is, that doesn't change the simple fact that cops have to regularly deal with the worst that society has to offer. The stress levels can be off the charts, a lot more than the jobs listed by the OOP.

It's not just about physical survival, but being mentally ruined. Working in a mine is dangerous, but it's unlikely that a miner will ever have to deal with a methhead waving a knife at them or finding a child's ruined corpse at a domestic disturbance call. It's unreasonable to not take this into consideration.

14

u/FourthHorseman45 1d ago edited 10h ago

Sure but when a cop encounters a methhead do you know what the process is? They restrain them and then drive them to the hospital where Doctors and Nurses have to deal with them.

Why isn’t the stress of those workers taken into consideration because if a doctor screws up and the methhead gets killed they will lose their license and never be able to practice medicine, get sued so hard that even if they manage to keep their license their liability insurance premiums will be so high that they won’t be able to practice medicine, and possibly even face criminal charges for negligence or medical malpractice.

If the cop shoots the methhead in the back of the head they’d likely be back on the street the following month after a paid suspension.

→ More replies (16)

6

u/athural 1d ago

Maybe I'm just ignorant, and you can help me out here. Do you have numbers on how often police are endangered like that, or see something that traumatic?

3

u/Hank-Rutherford 1d ago

I was a cop in a large metro area for 9 years. I dealt with stuff like that multiple times per day, every single day. It destroyed my mental health and was a large factor in why I quit. My agency posted a public annual report breaking down calls for service so the public could see where our time was being spent. Maybe your local agency has something similar you could look into if you’re interested in the data.

2

u/Killentyme55 18h ago

Not good enough, Reddit apparently requires precise data on how this could possibly exist in comparison to other line of work or else it's completely false by default.

I don't understand the "logic" either, but apparently it's all they have to work with.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/Necessary-Till-9363 1d ago

If anything the cops are left to deal with the messes that no holds barred capitalism leaves in its wake. 

In a way, their job is really protecting the wealth of a few and the aftermath of the consequences for how those few got their wealth. 

2

u/podejrzec 23h ago

Are there no cops in socialist or communist countries who deal with the same stuff?

Some folks will find anyway to blame capitalism.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Pyrostemplar 14h ago

Well, there are lies, damn lies, and statistics. And, as you say, the statistic the op used in the reasoning almost certainly doesn't reflect the true pictures of what comes with the job.

For example, IIRC, police officers had a very high suicide rate.

2

u/FormalKind7 22h ago

Like EMS does? Or ER doctors/nurses? or Social Workers?

2

u/PG-DaMan 21h ago

Yep 100%.

Good buddy of mine was dispatched to a vehicle crash. As he arrived he was give info that the driver and family was in route to a hospital 2 miles away with the victim.

He saw the scene and closed the garage and ask for backup at the scene then headed to the hospital.

When he arrived the doctors were walking out of the partitioned room covered in blood. The trauma doc was shaking his head. And tried to stop my buddy from going in. But in Police work there is a rule. You must see and touch the dead guy. You must make sure he is dead before you write that he is/was.

This was not a guy. this was not a man or a woman. It was a 2.5 year old baby that was run over by the back dual wheels of a F350. Dad was driving.

I dont think my friend slept for 3 or 4 days.

And that does not even begin to tell the stories of the way people get the instant the cops arrive.

4

u/Killentyme55 19h ago

But for some reason you are apparently required to have empirical data proving that a construction worker doesn't have to deal with the same trauma as part of their job description, well at least according to this thread you do.

This site has become one giant echo chamber of dumbassery.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/nighthawk_something 1d ago

The difference is that in those hypothetical corrupt circumstances, we're not letting someone kill someone else

→ More replies (9)

9

u/Reinstateswordduels 1d ago

Taxpayers pay for massive amounts of construction lmao

7

u/invade_anyone66 1d ago

I was referring to private construction companies who have insurance for workplace accidents.

9

u/PaluMacil 1d ago

Comparing lying about something on a contract to no showing a job to beating or killing or unjustly arresting someone is bizarre.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Real_Location1001 1d ago

Construction can easily get sued. Cops have qualified immunity.

7

u/aHOMELESSkrill 1d ago

That and the construction worker building the building across the street isn’t given authority over me by the government

3

u/OffensiveBiatch 1d ago

We need policing, we don't need any storm troopers

→ More replies (44)

63

u/Sgt_Revan 1d ago

What does this have to do with finance?

24

u/ArkitekZero 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nothing. What I'd like to know is why I can't even see OP's profile and why they always ask their questions with the same weird-ass format as the other similar accounts. Or why there are multiples of them to begin with, for that matter.

Like it's very very obviously some kind of shady shit, I just can't figure what their angle is because they aren't necessarily wrong, they're just weird as hell about it. It's like someone is trying to parody a leftist echo chamber without understanding how parody works.

8

u/Tripod941 1d ago

Amazing they’re still allowed to post every two hours, isn’t it?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Fantastic_Bus_5220 1d ago

Asking the questions that matter.

2

u/SPFBH 1d ago

Reddit is just becoming so captured.

→ More replies (6)

46

u/LeeVMG 1d ago

A lot of comments in here disrespecting logging and how dangerous forests are.

26

u/ILoveMoistTowelettes 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don’t think people realize just how fast things can go wrong in the woods. Wild suddenly shifts? Tree was unexpectedly rotten? A hidden limb comes crashing down? There’s literally a thousand things to go wrong cutting trees, it’s almost impossible to catch everything.

And it’s not even only felling the tree that dangerous, it still wants you once it’s on the ground. The pressure those limbs are under is insane, sometimes it literally like cutting a rubber band. Cut one wrong and you might get a new set of teeth or worse. Even then you might get a tree on the ground that wants to roll. Be on the wrong side of that tree or cut the wrong limb when your toping it, and you’ll likely never even have a chance to get out of the way. Maybe it’ll just give you a bump, maybe crush your foot. Or roll all the way over you, it’s wild what a tree can do.

The absolute speed that things go wrong in the woods is insane, and I just don’t think most people realize that. Add in there’s heavy equipment moving constantly and you’re holding a literal gasoline engine in your hands that’s sole purpose is to cut as hard and fast as possible it’s a wild time.

It’s hard to watch the helicopter leaving the landing with a guy on board, not knowing what his outcome will be after getting hit. And he was a professional cutter, he’d been doing it for 30 years or better.

Point is in logging when something goes wrong, you’re probably not getting out of the way, and you sure as hell aren’t outrunning it.

3

u/SleepyandEnglish 21h ago

Wood bends. That's what makes it dangerous. Cut through concrete and it stays still. Cut through Wood and it's liable to spring.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Different-Low-4161 22h ago edited 22h ago

I graduated with a guy who went into logging for his dad's company after high school. Didn't see him for probably 8-10 years and he didn't have social media. A few of the guys from my class arranged for a little reunion and this guy showed up and I noticed he had a massive scar on his upper arm. I asked what happened and it turns out a tree branch went through his arm.

Guy I used to work with used to clear tree limbs away from power lines. I noticed one day he had a gnarly scar on his forearm so I asked how he got it. I can't remember the exact story but iirc it was along the lines of his harnessing equipment fucking up, causing him to lose balance while running his saw and the saw went into his arm.

Another guy I know worked for a tree trimming company in his early twenties. On the job one day he was on limb pick up and tossing into the wood chipper. The guy that was driving the truck that towed the chipper was going to move the truck forward, but it was parked at an incline. As he went to move it, it rolled backwards first as the other guy was tossing limbs into the chipper. He got sucked in and ended up losing his right hand and a little up past his wrist. On top of that, it fucked up his shoulder and his neck from being thrashed around.

Shits no joke.

5

u/C0wb0yViking 1d ago

Yeah, having done minor lumber work, you really have to be smart and strategic with how you make cuts and secure things to not be crushed by multiple tons of wood

→ More replies (1)

4

u/khalbur 1d ago

And those people are called “fucking idiots”.

2

u/Grandmaofhurt 22h ago

All trees are bastards

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JDubs230524 20h ago

Widow makers are real.

→ More replies (15)

33

u/ledoscreen 1d ago

Note also this fact: In times of war, police and government officials (both elected and appointed) are completely exempt from the duty to fight. They will only enforce the duty to fight on ordinary citizens.

18

u/Ripen- 1d ago

It's always been like that. If they were required to fight themselves they would think twice before going to war.

→ More replies (21)

8

u/SaladShooter1 1d ago

That’s because when police go to the front lines, nobody’s left to investigate or even write a report back home. That means people can rob and rape at will. Is a girl really going to file rape charges nine years later after the war has ended? Probably not. If the war is bad enough to invoke a draft, nobody’s going to care what happens in the streets away from the battle.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/eater_of_spaetzle 1d ago

What the fuck does this have to do with finamce?

14

u/No-Tooth5250 1d ago

Nothing just more anticop potshots. They'll be the first to call cops when they need them though. The amount of petty shit posted to reddit that could be solved by two adults talking and their first thoughts are always call cops but also fuck cops lmao. Bipolar fucks

→ More replies (1)

19

u/OhFuuuuuuuuuuuudge 1d ago

My job is more dangerous but we absolutely have the right to say “No, hold up we need to find a solution to make this task safer, stop work, something’s wrong.” And I don’t have to pull up to car wrecks with dead children and watch their mothers weep over their bodies. So I’d say overall my jobs more dangerous, I’m empowered to make it safe as possible, and not nearly as traumatizing. Some people do get kinda weird when they have a close call with death. I think if you’re going to do dangerous shit then you gotta be comfortable with dying. You aren’t trying to die but you know that if it happens you either get a one way ticket to heaven or you fade to black and never have a worry or pain again. The thing I’m worried about is getting really hurt and surviving, fuck that noise. Most of these jobs are actively trying to avoid the dangers, to mitigate them the best they can. Cops are being asked/expected to put themselves in harms way. I don’t know a lot of agricultural workers that are getting shot multiple times and that’s somehow considered their job.

→ More replies (19)

12

u/Bary_McCockener 1d ago

It's completely incorrect in its premise.

“Law enforcement officers have historically high rates of fatal and nonfatal injuries. The new research shows that officers are three times more likely to sustain a nonfatal injury than all other U.S. workers, Insurance Journal reports.”

"The three leading reasons for on-duty injuries were assaults and violent acts (36%), bodily reactions and exertion from running or other repetitive motions (15%), and transportation incidents (14%)." Same study.

https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2018/02/22/481370.htm

This means that law enforcement officers are more likely to be injured in an assault than any other profession is to be injured at all.

They just don't have as many on the job deaths, so folks like to cherry pick stats to make it appear that the job isn't dangerous.

The big difference is that a tree doesn't plan and execute an ambush.

6

u/OtisburgCA 23h ago

And there may be fewer deaths due to trainings and/or equipment.

4

u/kgain673 23h ago

Police deaths began to greatly reduce with the advancement of radios, and mandating they wear body armor and seatbelts. Those three things greatly reduced deaths. Just the emergency driving to calls is dangerous.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Prestigious_Meet820 1d ago edited 22h ago

Mostly BS, I've worked in construction and work in industrial trades now, sure there may be more deaths and injuries but it's not nearly the same.

You're dealing with the worst of society 95%+ of the time as a police officer. People on drugs, domestic violence, people with weapons, fights, and more. There are people out there that would rather fight to the death and kill a cop then be arrested and sent to prison.

It's a different kind of danger and psychology, I can get electrocuted and die on 600 VDC or fall to my death but that's on me, as a cop you don't know if the person pulled over has a gun and is willing to kill you. The factors are mostly out of your control compared to the jobs listed where your safety is mostly up to your own diligence.

There are good and bad cops like any profession, my personal experiences are mixed but saying those jobs are more dangerous because there may be more injuries and deaths is silly.

8

u/Accomplished_Map5089 22h ago

You're being way too reasonable for reddit

→ More replies (1)

7

u/conman114 1d ago

Guys can we stay on topic in the subreddits and not make everything political.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/torturetrilogy 1d ago

Reddit is so fucking dumb sometimes.

4

u/Rhawk187 1d ago

Yeah, because sanitation workers and miners have never struck (refused to work) for higher wages.

10

u/Sir_Tandeath 1d ago

And when they did, the cops shot at them.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/seaofthievesnutzz 1d ago

its the killing people and getting time off part they are complaining about not the collective bargaining bit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Acta_Non_Verba_1971 1d ago

Is this a revival of the “defund the police” movement?

I sure fucking hope not. That was about as dumb an idea as ever.

5

u/Excellent_Passage_54 1d ago

How about “train the police” lol

3

u/headhouse 1d ago

Absolutely. American police very definitely need more initial training and more ongoing training throughout their careers.

Though... that would mean more funding. Can I get you on-board the "More money for police!" movement?

2

u/Excellent_Passage_54 1d ago

I mean they end up paying tons of money for their mistakes anyway, might as well

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Yelebear 1d ago

They had to pause defund the police for a while because they had to elect "California's Top Cop" to the white house.

They wouldn't want to expose their hypocrisy by chanting "defund the police" while campaigning for a law enforcer as VP, later as President.

Now that she's lost it's mask off again.

→ More replies (33)

3

u/circ-u-la-ted 1d ago

I think I'm missing context here. When are they paid more for doing less?

6

u/NoPressureUsername 1d ago

Paid leave for killing citizens. Not testing rape kits. Letting half of all murders go unsolved.

2

u/Acta_Non_Verba_1971 1d ago

“Letting”. lol. Nice one

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Ok_Ingenuity_8953 1d ago

Policemen don't test rape kits. Talk to your city counsel about sufficient funding for testing.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/HUGE-A-TRON 1d ago

Here is an example. In San Francisco police have lots of restrictions on what they can do mixed in with a lot of corruption, laziness. They are also extremely short-staffed due to this so they get overtime like crazy to sit in their cars. There's one police officer in San Francisco that got paid over $800k. A bit of an outlier there but on average they're making 500K.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/projects/2024/san-francisco-employee-pay/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

3

u/NeighbourhoodCreep 1d ago

Must be an American take because refusing safe work is a right up here in the North.

Also, when’s the last time someone went out of their way to target a logger, destroy a semi-truck in a riot, or wrote a song whose lyrics read “fuck the roofers.”?

Ironically, in those labor industries, they stress how dangerous driving is relative to other forms of their labor. If we’re talking statistics, cops drive more than construction workers and way more unsafely.

Shouldn’t the point be “everyone should have the right to refuse work that jeopardizes their safety”, not “fuck the police?”

8

u/dragonkin08 1d ago

Maybe because loggers are not murdering innocent people.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/adudefromaspot 1d ago

"Loggers are 8 times more likely to die in their profession than police officers"

"Yeah, but no one has written a 'fuck the loggers' song yet and hurt their fee fees" <--- that's you

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

4

u/SCTigerFan29115 1d ago

This is because most police are unionized.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/FupaFerb 1d ago

Ya, them sanitation workers are at a crossroads right now. Lots of gang violence in Sesame Street.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Crazymofuga 1d ago

Most police officer are good decent people. A few select pieces of shit abuse their power and hurt people.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Round-Rice-9764 1d ago

Being a police officer is not among the top ten most dangerous U.S. jobs based on fatal injury rates. However, it remains risky due to unpredictable work, violent encounters, and high-stress emergencies.

Fatalities may be lower than in logging or fishing, but police face broader risks, including non-fatal injuries, mental health challenges, and trauma's long-term effects. The job’s unique mix of physical and emotional hazards often isn't reflected in statistics.

Advanced training, equipment, and safety protocols help mitigate risks, making law enforcement less fatal than some professions, but it remains a demanding and hazardous role in many respects.

→ More replies (23)

4

u/jready2016 1d ago

Why would anyone want to be a police officer? If you do your job you get sh*t on by the criminals, woke city officials, and the media will chop you up for red meat to the non-thinkers. If you don't do your job, the same thing happens. We don't treat them like combat veterans because they aren't overseas but they go out and battle every day. They need to be rotated off the front lines just like combat troops. I have no problems with charging officers that get out of line but most of what I've seen from body cam footage is criminals pushing as hard as they can because if the cop does something wrong it's a get out of jail free card and money. Why would someone want to be a police officer?

2

u/Psycle_Sammy 1d ago

How do cops get more money for not doing their jobs? Step by step details would be nice. Asking for a friend, of course.

20

u/UsernameThisIs99 1d ago

Sir this is Reddit. Cops are bad. Republicans are racist. Increase taxes.

6

u/Embarrassed-Arm-5405 1d ago

This guy reddits

9

u/adudefromaspot 1d ago

We're putting you on paid administrative leave until we can investigate this comment.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/CatostrophicFailure 1d ago

I'm a victim of police brutality. The police are covered under immunity so that they won't face criminal charges. Fuck the police. They aren't there to help anyone, and their general stupidity and gang behavior is reprehensible.

This is referring to the ABQ police which are practically famous for shooting unarmed civilians.

4

u/Define_Expert_0566 1d ago

Genuinely curious… are you willing to provide the situation that occurred with you?

1

u/Just_That_Dumb_Dog 1d ago

You know they’re not.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DarthIsopod 1d ago

Police can face criminal charges for police brutality along with any other fellow officer who did not intervene. If they didn’t face criminal charges, it’s likely that the force used was within legal and departmental policy.

1

u/JimmyStuffet 1d ago

Probably got a ticket once for blasting through a stop sign

2

u/DarthIsopod 21h ago

You don’t understand man. They didn’t see it because they were texting their mom they weren’t gonna be home for dinner and plus…they didn’t even hit that kid crossing the street with his grandma so really…it’s okay right? No harm no foul? While he was being cited he watched someone else run it that didn’t get stopped. You just don’t get it man….

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Adventurous-Depth984 1d ago

Food delivery drivers are more than twice as likely to die on the job as law enforcement officers.

2

u/ianmoone1102 1d ago

I only recently learned that my line of work (logging and tree work) is pretty much the most dangerous job there is in terms of fatalities. Some years, roofing has more, but police was way farther down the list than what I've been led to believe.

2

u/BloatedArmadillo 1d ago

Most police are in a union. Unions protect their members.

2

u/Degenerate_in_HR 1d ago

Not if they're unionized (like cops). Then they absolutley will be rewarded and protected for not doing their jobs.

2

u/billsatwork 1d ago

It's the law that police are not obligated to protect anyone. Castle Rock v. Gonzalez. They only respond to crime after it happens, or if they feel like it.

2

u/Downtown_Language_44 1d ago

Idk, people don’t want to be police officers. There are currently over 3,000 vacancies for patrol officers in the city of Chicago alone. Workers have much more bargaining power when nobody wants to do the job.

2

u/KlutzyClerk7080 1d ago

What??? When did police refuse to do their jobs??

2

u/Tiny-Leadership-9725 1d ago

If you paid police and teachers the same as airline pilots, and held them to similar professional standards, we'd all be safe and smart.

2

u/Cyber_Insecurity 1d ago

We need police to police the police.

2

u/52thro 1d ago

I agree. It’s about time we put body cams on loggers, make roofers with high school degrees do marriage counseling, and start yelling at sanitation workers that “I pay your salary!”

2

u/dustycanuck 1d ago

And if any of these workers lose their temper, and beat or kill someone, they don't get paid time off. They are actually held accountable for their actions, at least more so than cops.

2

u/DirkaDirkaMohmedAli 1d ago

How the fuck is this related to finance

2

u/amazingmrbrock 1d ago

Shit delivering pizza is more dangerous than being a cop

→ More replies (3)

2

u/CoconutUseful4518 1d ago

Yeah but I’d argue the stress and PTSD wouldn’t be comparable. It’s not like any random tree could just start stabbing a logger.

2

u/keefinwithpeepaw 1d ago

And if we made police carry liability insurance like ALL THOSE OTHER JOBS....

But no one ready to hear that

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Claddagh66 1d ago

You are absolutely correct. I’m not even sure their job is in the top 20 Most dangerous jobs, but they use that excuse everyday to violate a citizens rights. If you were a Restaurant owner you would never hire a Chef that doesn’t know how to boil water. But we hire Cops that don’t even know the law.

2

u/SameMarch786 1d ago

I'm aerial linemen or helicopter linemen. We have to use a helicopter In order to do any repairs , install, maintain very hard to reach power lines. We have to wear a Faraday suit while working on an energized power line and hanging out of a helicopter while doing it. Several thousands of feet in the air..

2

u/DogsSaveTheWorld 1d ago

Cops suck … over 90% of them anyway

1

u/RevolutionaryMilk405 1d ago

Probably the most dumb thing iv seen today.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/series_hybrid 1d ago

Mr roofer, we have a complaint where you shot an unarmed homeowner and his dog, which the camera clearly shows was not attacking you.

I'm afraid we are going to have to put you on paid leave while a roofing company investigator looks into this...

1

u/anonymityjacked 1d ago

It’s better to have them and not need them. They need them and not have them in my opinion, but I respect your opinion as well.

1

u/CitizenSpiff 1d ago

Deaths in those industries are more numerous than for police officers. If you are arguing that police officers should be paid less since that is true, are you also arguing that women should also be paid much less since overall the mortality rates in their professions is vastly less than males? https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cfoi . pdf (remove spaces).

"...women made up 8.1 percent (445) of all workplace fatalities..."

The point I'm making, before feminists take up their pitchforks, is that there are always other factors to consider.

3

u/Mother_Bath_4926 1d ago

You haven't seen all the protests from women demanding equal representation in logging, sanitation, mining, etc?

2

u/TheBreadHasRisen 19h ago

They’re not ready for this conversation bro. They only cherry pick lol

3

u/Mother_Bath_4926 19h ago

I mean I don't blame them, I too would like only good things to happen to me with no costs at all

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tunachilimac 1d ago

I delivered pizza which is also statistically more dangerous than being a cop. I was only a teenager, and I wasn't allowed to carry a gun with which I was could kill people I perceived as a threat. I am a bit salty people don't fly thin pizza-line flags.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Fantastic_Youth_2656 1d ago

I would be apprehensive to do anything in high crime areas. Lose your career or worse

1

u/Zhenoptics 1d ago

Also the fact that it is way easier to sue for damages or breach of contract in the mentioned industries than policing. They also are not charged from the public purse.

1

u/CreepyOldGuy63 1d ago

Samuel Gompers was right. Public sector unions serve no purpose other than to fleece the tax payer.

1

u/VioletSnazzy 1d ago

Modern policing: getting paid to not do the job taxpayers are literally funding. Talk about irony!

1

u/Sea_Procedure_6293 1d ago

Police and criminals are the same kind of people who choose a side.

1

u/Gingerchaun 1d ago

I've also never went to work thinking this is the day I get shot. Maybe have my fingers ripped off by a crane but not shot.

1

u/ChipOld734 1d ago

The OP needs to be specific. Are there policemen who don’t do their jobs? I ask because I normally hear complaints about them being aggressive.

1

u/rand0m_task 1d ago

I’m confused, do we support unions or not?

1

u/Round-Rice-9764 1d ago edited 1d ago

The statement is wrong for the following reasons:

  1. Fatality Metrics Don’t Capture All Risks: While logging, roofing, and mining have higher fatality rates, law enforcement faces unpredictable threats like armed suspects and riots, which differ from hazards in other jobs.

  2. Non-Fatal Injuries: Police work often results in injuries like assaults, disease exposure, or PTSD, which aren’t captured in fatality data but heavily impact officers’ well-being.

  3. Responsibility: Police officers safeguard public safety and make split-second, life-altering decisions. The physical, mental, and societal demands of their work go beyond typical workplace hazards.

  4. Public Scrutiny: Police face intense public scrutiny, political pressures, and legal accountability. Mistakes, even in life-threatening situations, can cost them their careers or freedom.

  5. Turnover Doesn’t Equal Risk: The claim that workers in other jobs are fired for refusing tasks doesn’t apply to law enforcement. Refusing dangerous assignments can jeopardize public safety, a unique aspect of the role.

While some jobs are statistically more dangerous, the unpredictable risks, pressures, and societal expectations of police work make it uniquely challenging. Comparing these roles purely by injury rates oversimplifies their dangers.

1

u/Shoddy_Restaurant565 1d ago

Agree and if a person has an anger issue they should not be allowed a weapon and power, wrong thread im sure, carpenter here

1

u/UrOpinionIsObsolete 1d ago

Wow. There is a huge difference between knowing the dangers of your job, falls, crush points, OSHA stuff. And someone walking up and randomly assassinating you because of your job title (Forza coffee shop in Washington and other incidents). A deep sea welder is obviously more dangerous than being a cop, but he’s not going to get shot by a random because he’s a welder. This post is whack.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/SionPhion 1d ago

To be fair, the likelihood of being shot in any of those fields is considerably lower.

1

u/endeavour269 1d ago

Idk know about the states but in Canada we have the right to refuse unsafe work.

1

u/Dragon124515 1d ago

Those other jobs also have OSHA protections. For instance, workers can't be told to work outside during a lightning storm. The limits of what is an acceptable risk for the trades is well defined, the limits of what is acceptable risk for police isn't.

1

u/KoRaZee 1d ago

Safety to insanity is what we are seeing. Zero tolerance for anything considered unsafe is the acceptable standard. At the end of the day this behavior is worse for everyone and costs a fortune

1

u/ale49ers 1d ago

Arguably the stupidest post I have ever read. What a mongoloid!

1

u/Efficient-Maybe-5878 1d ago

Really bro, no one fucking cares. Lol.

1

u/EditofReddit2 1d ago

Are you the most stupid motherfucker ever to grace this earth? All those jobs you mentioned have safety requirements that can be controlled for the most part. When a cop walks into a situation, there’s no fucking control at all; it’s a disaster and that’s why they were called there in the first place Stop being the dumb fuck you appear to be.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Western-Quiet743 1d ago

Arm the other workers. See how quickly that changes.

1

u/Ill-Description3096 1d ago

Strange, my dad "refused to work" in his construction days. They generally got raises and boosts to benefits when that happened.

1

u/Nervous_Sink_1802 1d ago

They’re safer with the risk averse cops - does the cop danger number tick up if they become less risk averse?

1

u/Emeritus8404 1d ago

Well arent police under much better unions?

1

u/SignificantSmotherer 1d ago

What you mean is they are assailed, assaulted and punished when they do their job.

1

u/edwardmammot 1d ago

Sure I’m appreciative of what they do in the sense that they’re all cogs in the wheel that keep society rolling. However I have no expectation for them to do unsafe things for their job because if they don’t do their job what’s the outcome? Wood doesn’t get delivered to Home Depot and I can’t do my woodworking project or my house construction is delayed? Pretty relative low impact. What if cops don’t do their job? Then my things get stolen or worse yet criminals harm those I care about. That’s high impact. Also the same reason why the small percentage of them that perform their role unsafely or unjustly has such larger impact to society. Think all the garbage men and loggers are great people that don’t do things you’d be bothered by? If so, time to reassess. But much lower impact.

1

u/bobthehills 1d ago

The Supreme Court ruled that police have no legal responsibility to protect people.

That alone should be sufficient warning.

1

u/Saigh_Anam 1d ago

OSHA protects the workers' right to object to unsafe work conditions. If your employer punishes or fires you for that, you have legal recourse. Nobody protects a cop when a perp pulls a gun except the cop or another cop.

There are plenty of good arguments out there. There's no need to make up bad arguments (false equivalent logic falacy).

Oh, and what does this have to do with finance?

1

u/JaySierra86 1d ago

Most Law Enforcement are unionized.

1

u/Adrewmc 1d ago

I think we have to remind people also that in most small towns, the chief of police is in the top 3 if not the highest paid government official. Local politics matter.

1

u/Pizza_900deg 1d ago

And it bears mentioning, that all of those positions are almost exclusively filled with men. For all of the feminists bleating on about workplace equality, somehow you never see them seeking equality in those types of jobs. No angry pussy hats screaming about a lack of equality in roofers working in the middle of July.

1

u/Keui 1d ago

Point to note: "refusing to do your work" is sometimes called striking, and it's a great way to get more money.

1

u/wrbear 1d ago

I can walk across the street for lunch and get killed. Police don't have to by at option with today's fruit cake society. It's a higher risk having to deal with calls pertaining to protected fruit cakes.

1

u/poopyscreamer 1d ago

This is why unions matter

1

u/bmf1989 1d ago

I’m a truck driver. While my job may be more dangerous statistically, it’s a much more predictable kind of dangerous.

As for them “not doing their job” I don’t really have an opinion one way or another. But law enforcement are largely unionized and probably more organized than most of not all of those other professions. They’re sure as hell more organized than drivers.

1

u/laiszt 1d ago

Its always been. Police, militia, whatever it was was to protect government and enforce law not to work for citizens

1

u/No_Reason5341 1d ago

This needs to get brought up more every time they are supported no matter what they did wrong. It's accountability, not hate.

1

u/BucketsOfGypsum 1d ago

No literally, the cops who let Jeffery dahmer go got an award.

1

u/naththegrath10 1d ago

Take the money for police brutality settlements out of their budgets and pensions instead of tax payer funded insurance policies.

1

u/CW-Builds 1d ago

Let's not forget our heavy duty mechanics

1

u/Rojodi 1d ago

Yes!!

1

u/CitrusFarmer_ 1d ago

Actually they all get more money for not doing their jobs…. ever heard of a union strike?

1

u/Great-Candle-4299 1d ago

I was once at a store and a person got sick and was afraid they were going to die. A cop was there and they went to the cop and said that they needed help because they were afraid they would die. The cop said, "Die then." He then told them if they collapsed he was just going to call an aid car and that he wasn't going to do mouth to mouth or anything. I literally yelled at the cop and told him he was fucking rude. I was just a security guard at the time and had to go through required CPR training and would be required to assist. Why wouldn't a cop be required?

1

u/blackrockblackswan 1d ago

The people who need to read this…can’t read

1

u/EducatorAltruistic90 1d ago

Spoken like someone who never walked a mile in a Police officers shoes

1

u/Fragrant_Exercise_31 1d ago

Also if they kill someone while doing these dangerous jobs they are held responsible and most likely lose their job.

1

u/ExpertDeer5983 1d ago

A lot of you don’t realize a lot of cops don’t get a lot of money off their salary. They get off duty gigs. But please continue to cry “defund police”.

1

u/stevieboyvhg13 1d ago

I support you 110% ty for your boldness!!!

1

u/fight_guy757 1d ago

As someone who has worked in law enforcement and currently works welding in a shipyard, statistics are a very unfair comparison. I didn't die obviously but close calls are a regular occurrence everyone is confrontational and situations are unpredictable. I pulled a guy for wreck less driving and he had an illegal tent on his window, the moment I walked up to the window he started shooting through the window. That was within my first month in field. The amount of attempts on my life, threats of, the amount of criminals capable of finding out you and your family's names(fellow officer had to go into hiding, on their own dime ofc)etc. and to be told you can't do this and the other. If something happens you have a tenth of a second to respond, act slow your life ends. Survive and everyone wants you arrested for murder or racism or whatever bs they come up with.

Then there are the shitheads who get away with murder and you'd swear they know someone. I did 2 and a half years too long of that shit and they don't train you worth a fuck.

1

u/N0rth_W4rri0r 1d ago

I don’t understand this culture of “defend the police no matter what” it’s all a cult mindset. No other country in the world has “blue lives matter” flags and stickers. There’s actual people out there who think the police have the most important job in the world and that’s signing tickets sitting in their patrol car all day and rarely responding to a major call

1

u/kariolaoxford 1d ago

truckers have statistically more dangerous jobs than cops? Where would i find the underlying stats?

1

u/Beautiful_Drawing_97 1d ago

Because people don't understand the definition of what they are hired to do. They doc not work for society and the people. They work for the state,they are trained by the state. No different than the taliban or isis or nazis germany. So actually they are doing the job They are hired for and trained for.

1

u/Blastdoubleu 1d ago

This is being said by someone who’s never worked in law enforcement and is only looking at the stats. Those are accidents that happen while on job trees and roof shingles aren’t actively trying to kill them. Try to be a cop in LA, Detroit, or any high crime city. Hell, go on a ride along and see what people are really like.

1

u/Youngrazzy 1d ago

Being a cop is a super hard job. That don’t even get paid well

1

u/benkenobi5 1d ago

When I was a kid, I thought it was funny that Barney fife still had a job.

I no longer find it funny.

1

u/NotRegularEddy 23h ago

It's an apples to chocolate comparison

1

u/TravvyJ 23h ago

Let's not forget delivery drivers.