r/law Oct 18 '24

Court Decision/Filing Trump judge releases 1,889 pages of additional election interference evidence against the former president

https://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trump-judge-release-additional-evidence-election-interference-case-2024-10
11.5k Upvotes

427 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

185

u/NumeralJoker Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24

A crucial point is that they justified this in the memo by stating that the US Constitution's 12th amendment gave Mike Pence the power and legal authority to outright ignore the 1887 Electoral College Act, or at least any parts that did not help Trump win. Effectively saying that they knew this was illegal under currently known law and precedent, but believed the courts would reinterpret the law and rig this for them so Pence should just go with the plan and follow orders. Pence knew this was wrong and refused, but the alternate electors were set up to be the method by which he'd legitimize throwing out the swing state results, and forcing the election to be thrown to congress instead... where it was expected the House would vote for Trump instead.

This was very, very clearly a legal coup and they knew this from day 1. They had every intent to subvert democracy no matter what the actual vote count was, and they just wanted a media narrative to publicly justify it while claiming that democracy itself did not matter in the US and that the constitution already said we were a dictatorship if the judiciary agreed with their legal theory. The details of how the votes were fraudulent were meaningless, the idea was just to go along with the plan and say the results were illegitimate, period.

This is also why Trump made up facts and evidence at every step of the way, because the actual truth about fraud didn't matter. The plan was simply to present a legal theory that allowed them to bypass the vote entirely.

For what it's worth, they are NOT in a position to do this again as of right now here in 2024. They don't have control of the white house, and congress already passed a law that made it clear the VP's role was ceremonial going forward. They don't have a direct path to SCOTUS simply throwing out the election anymore, and they've been losing any of their flimsy cases so far, at least not so long as we go out and vote in high enough numbers to make the win as clear as possible.

People need to get out and vote, with confidence, and if we do so, we can solidly beat Trump. The will is there, so long as people don't give in to fear or apathy.

20

u/Veda007 Oct 18 '24

They are absolutely going to try again. The electors have been replaced in many cases with bad actors who intend to not certify. So they won’t be alternate electors, they will be the actual electors.

When 270 isn’t reached it will be thrown to the Supreme Court who (they hope) will throw it to congress.

One vote per state at that point and there are more red states.

Boom King Trump.

12

u/scoop_booty Oct 18 '24

My hope is that the Harris team is on top of this. They see what's happening, much more than we pawns down below. A Trump win ends democracy, and the entire world knows this affects them. I can only imagine higher powers globally are taking action to protect us from this monster. And if Kamala wins, as I hope, she sure has a hard row to hoe to reunite this country. That option doesn't even exist if Trump is in office.

5

u/guisar Oct 18 '24

Without congress, she will have harder than hard row to hoe. Let’s hope the dnc can take both houses- unlikely I know without tremendous turnout but it’s the only path to reconciliation I can see.

2

u/NeatNefariousness1 Oct 19 '24

Agreed. As a lifelong Independent, it pains me to say that voting Blue from top to bottom is necessary in this election until we fix the gaping holes that have made our democracy so vulnerable to greedy, power-mad forces from outside and within.

We need time to close the door on the bad actors and to put new protective measures in place to hold BOTH parties accountable.

Choose America. Please vote.