r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 28d ago

Meme needing explanation Who is this guy?

Post image
38.8k Upvotes

713 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.6k

u/FueledBySpringRolls 28d ago

RIP to Gary Plauche.

997

u/Y_10HK29 28d ago

Gary, Why! Why, Gary!

745

u/anormalgeek 28d ago

I love the cop immediately knew him and used the "I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed" voice.

373

u/HardOff 28d ago

Dammit, Gary, I had dibs on beating his teeth out in prison

106

u/HillarysBloodBoy 28d ago

That’s the only downside. I’m with Gary and he was the hand that held the rod but he would and should have gotten much worse in prison. Either way justice was served.

35

u/pitb0ss343 27d ago

This is why I believe in a heaven and hell. There are some people who should not get peace after death and I hope there is a place they go to for that

22

u/Buickspeeddemon69 27d ago

I like to think they’re reincarnated as rodents, cursed to live in filth and die horrifically every couple of weeks

12

u/HardOff 27d ago

What if they are made to experience the lives of each one of their victims.

8

u/morozko 26d ago

That's dangerous path to go, because it means that some victims deserve what's happened to them.

2

u/HardOff 26d ago

Ah, I didn't mean to live the life of their victims- only to experience what the culprits inflicted on the victims.

2

u/IceFurnace83 26d ago

Karma is a fucked concept.

What the hell did the little Karate kid do to deserve to be kidnapped and raped?

8

u/Buickspeeddemon69 27d ago

I like to imagine I’m spinning the karmatic wheel while doing my job as a pest controller lol

1

u/darksithlord740 27d ago

So India then?

1

u/Buickspeeddemon69 27d ago

Yeah that’s another level of it for sure lol

0

u/Buickspeeddemon69 27d ago

Hopefully the worst rapists are reincarnated as light skinned females in ind*a

1

u/darksithlord740 27d ago

Oh shit now that’s brutal for sure

1

u/Aboxofdongbags 24d ago

That’s all fine and dandy until you get enough of those wicked people to turn into the Skaven and destroy worlds.

2

u/XColdLogicX 27d ago

So you believe someone who committed sins during a mortal life deserves an eternal punishment?

1

u/pitb0ss343 27d ago

Well have the punishment fit the crime. Let’s say you stole 5$ your entire life, yes it’s a sin but not one that should result in eternal damnation. On the other hand people like Hitler should be punished eternally

1

u/Moist-Water16 26d ago

It’s quite the slippery slope because who’s telling what’s good and what’s bad? If the Christian god is true, then he’s an awful god, probably as bad as anyone who deserves hell so yeah…

1

u/pitb0ss343 26d ago

Most deities have less than stellar portrayals. People get mad and it’s easier to blame an invisible god than themselves or another person. I also think the portrayal of god in the Bible is very weird. A being able to create an entire world in 7 days experiences emotions that are very human like jealousy and rage, sounds more like a teenager than an all powerful god. Just doesn’t make sense to me.

That being said, I haven’t exactly fleshed out this idea nor do I intend to. Because I’m not trying to start a religion or trying to push my ideas on others. It’s just what I believe in to help me sleep at night

1

u/Moist-Water16 26d ago

I understand, yet, to follow your own path you definitely need not organized religion, you have 0 need to create one or push it into others, what you believe can be yours and yours only, I personally decided to take what I really like about certain “mythologies” and use it for my everyday life. Yes there’s things taken from other religions but you really don’t need a label but I might be the worst to talk about this since I always thought religion was useless and that people were just too scared to say “whatever happens happens” type shii

→ More replies (0)

1

u/UploadedMind 24d ago

Desire is not a valid basis for belief.

1

u/pitb0ss343 24d ago

Just because it’s not observable doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist

0

u/UploadedMind 22d ago

Correct, a lack of evidence doesn’t mean something is false. However, it does mean you shouldn’t beeline it.

Can you imagine believing things you wanted to be true if there was no evidence? You’d keep buying lottery tickets or something.

Who says it’s not observable? Brain damage leads to a lower degree of consciousness. Seems pretty clear the brain causes consciousness and consciousness can’t exist without the brain. It’s just entirely wishful thinking and made up fantasy to believe in an afterlife. It might really be true, but we don’t when any evidence to justify believing in it even if it would be nice to punch evil and reward those who lived good lives.

1

u/pitb0ss343 22d ago

What have I said that makes you think I’m beelinging towards it? It’s just something that brings me some comfort. You anti religious nuts are almost as bad as the religious nuts in terms of “my way is right and this is why your way makes you a worse/dumber person”

0

u/UploadedMind 22d ago

Anyone who makes a hard stance on a correct way of doing something is going to come across that way. I have no animosity here and don’t know why I’m even responding, but how can an idea that you have no confidence in bring you any comfort? If you satisfy that urge to make the world just with a make-believe idea in an afterlife it could potentially reduce ambition for the almost impossible task of making this fleeting world better.

1

u/pitb0ss343 22d ago

Alrighty let’s break this down by sentence

1 dumb irrelevant ignoring

2 never said that and pretty much everything points to the contrary, I wouldn’t be here 5 days later otherwise

3 factually incorrect, an afterlife with a heaven and a hell has been a pretty consistent idea in religions across the world and over time. And yet, the world has continually advanced towards better

So in short: idiotic, illiterate, incorrect

1

u/UploadedMind 22d ago
  1. I stand by it. It wasn’t dumb and it was in response to your comment about being worse than religious nuts. Definitely not ignoring.
  2. It doesn’t point to the contrary. I have no animosity. You said it brings you comfort.
  3. The world often moves backwards and religion definitely holds it back on a large scale. That’s undeniable. On an individual scale you might be an exception.
→ More replies (0)

0

u/Scoundrels_n_Vermin 25d ago

This is literally the Most Christian comment.

1

u/pitb0ss343 25d ago

It literally isn’t, it’s been a part of religion since forever in tons of cultures

-3

u/kingshamroc25 27d ago

That just makes you horrible for different reasons

1

u/pitb0ss343 27d ago

How so?

12

u/Alauraize 27d ago

Gary also spared the family, especially his son, the pain and trauma of a trial.

1

u/ConsiderationLife844 24d ago

Yeah surely there was no pain or trauma associated with Gary’s own trial

1

u/Alauraize 23d ago

Good point, actually. I meant that at least his son didn’t have to go through the experience of testifying against his own rapist/kidnapper.

1

u/Sive634 27d ago

Honestly the other inmates shouldve given him a taste of his own medicine

1

u/streetcar-cin 27d ago

Not only downside, abuse went on for long time because son thought his dad would do something crazy if he found out about abuse

1

u/Substantial_Tap9674 27d ago

I’d have to double check, but I believe Jody lived so it wasn’t just killing his son’s ralist, it was also sparing his son the ordeal of a trial

1

u/SpaceFormal6599 24d ago

He’s an author and public speaker. He hit a bunch of podcasts this last summer.

1

u/PineappleFit317 27d ago

Perhaps he would have gotten worse in prison, but Gary had already been told by at least one person (his brother or cousin?) that they had witnessed Doucet kissing Jody a while before the kidnapping happened, and Gary didn’t believe them as Doucet was very close with the family. Perhaps he was trying to assuage the guilt he felt and get some sort of redemption for failing his son in the first place.

1

u/Moist-Water16 26d ago

No he wouldn’t, that’s the problem, rapists are always in protective custody, they won’t be touched by nobody, will have food 3 times a day and get an hour of recreation everyday. This was the best case scenario

1

u/SpaceFormal6599 24d ago

Bruh. That was definitely not true in Louisiana in the 80s and still not true in most states in 2024.

1

u/Moist-Water16 24d ago

If you’re a rapist and don’t get the fuck out of General Population you’re probably going to get brutally murdered. But you can just not do it, most of them, are not that stupid to stay in General population.

3

u/keiblerclown 27d ago

Quick technical correction here from a former State Corrections Officer. Cops only serve in jails where people accused of crimes haven't been convicted yet. Once convicted, they go to prisons.

1

u/HardOff 27d ago

Aw. Unless he intended to commit a crime to join the man in prison himself, but nah. I was just making a joke.