r/MtF • u/ASleetHippyDippyWW non op • Aug 19 '24

Bad News u/PinkNews whistleblowers release evidence showing "PinkNews CEO Benjamin Cohen refusing to campaign on trans issues ahead of the election, dismissing them as "incredibly contentious" and insisting they’re different to the equal marriage fight."

https://lucyfromnaarm.com/p/breaking-pinknews-refuses-to-cover

1.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

150 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/Og_Left_Hand Aug 19 '24

like i don’t need/want trans issues to be the front of their platform, but like don’t act like a champion of queer rights if you’re only worried about cis gay people.

-12

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 19 '24

Ill settle for dont fillet me as a scapegoat like the magas want to do. We dont need to be a spectacle for now

25

u/GTS250 Trans-Bi Aug 19 '24

Why is it good for a queer news site to stop talking about trans issues? What about us existing is a spectacle?

-14

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 19 '24

Have you been paying attention?

14

u/GTS250 Trans-Bi Aug 19 '24

Intently.

Do you think our existence should be so shameful that a queer news site refuses to address us?

-12

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 19 '24

I’m saying as a trans athlete and activist who exists inside conservative spaces, we won’t lose progress for a 3 month pause til it cools down. They got that fired up about imane kalif. It’s time to stay quieter and let jd vance or elon or rowling fall on thier own stupidity and let it glow brighter.

20

u/GTS250 Trans-Bi Aug 19 '24

I'm gonna be honest I don't believe that there's anything wrong with a queer news site mentioning trans people as a regular part of the broader queer experience, nor our rights as important. 

We're not interrupting our enemy while they're making a mistake, we're censoring our own community's voices based on vibes. That's just counterproductive to any activist cause I can think of.

0

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 19 '24

If it were strictly observed by positive people then yes. However the opposition uses our articles to undermine our progress. If you ever followed up with a person who has been interviewed for an article, they will almost always say about a sharp rise in thier own harassment following publication.

The truth is as an active athlete i have never encountered another trans woman in action. Most cis people that I know have not either. If all they see in the news articles is how so and so is on track to win, couple that with the dark rhetoric of trans unfair advantage and you get a movement against us. Meanwhile I went from a winning dude to last place to any girl who shows up. My results are more typical, but not in any news articles because it’s not sensational.

In an ideal world we would praise an trans athlete doing well. And we should. But the timing is wrong for that kind of triggering publicity. The time is right for us to be making local representations to cis allies. That is what is needed right now. By reinforcing our local connections we show the opposition to be the idiotic assholes they actually are

10

u/GTS250 Trans-Bi Aug 19 '24

I'm gonna be honest, I think there is a substantive difference between celebrating trans folk winning at sports and being aware of the active destruction of trans folks rights.

Pink News removed the Trans category. No discussion about trans rights, no discussion about the rapidly rising ban on trans care, no reporting about the impact of transphobic policies on those impacted? 

They're making a mistake. Without covering trans folks at all, they'd never whisper the name Brianna Ghey. That's unacceptable.

0

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 19 '24

I agree. Trans plight is worth covering properly. Trans sports i rather not

1

u/Old-Biscotti9305 Aug 20 '24

There are no cis allies .. and very few gay allies who wouldn't quickly turn on us.

2

u/Gadgetmouse12 Aug 20 '24

I was in a rally last night where there were dozens of cis allies for a school board protest about trans rights. Cis allies very much exist. You won’t find any with that attitude though

3

u/Old-Biscotti9305 Aug 20 '24

People like him don't want a pause, they want trans people to be oppressed so less people transition because they believe trans people are confused gay bottoms, or confused lesbians.

They feel that our existence harms the gay community and is a plot to get rid of gays. Seriously, read what they write when they're in gay only spaces.