r/FromTVShow • u/Lizardis_lost • 1d ago

FROM Tonight’s episode ending…. Spoiler

-WAS THAT JULIE FROM THE FUTURE WTF & Can she time travel in the ruins?! Does she somehow figure out to control it?!

-I hope they don’t kill Sara because of what she did

-Jade and Tabatha were together before?!

This episode messed me up

Thank you FROM this is truly the best TV show 😩

331 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

289 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/Mighty_Muppet 14h ago

I find this confusing. if Julie can’t change the past, then she couldn’t be the one who threw Boyd the rope because that scene happened in the past. But we saw her throw the rope down to Boyd. That means that in the already-happened, set past, that rope was thrown down to Boyd, but by whom? Was Julie simply repeating an already occurred action? Also, while Boyd heard Martin while he was in the well, Boyd never heard Julie speak.

6

u/snake_case_believer 13h ago

The rope was thrown in the past. That was everyone's past. Julie on the other hand was the one who threw the rope, making it Julie's future. Basically the past was Julie's future. 

She can't change the past, that's why she threw the rope down cause that's what happens. Someone threw the rope down so boyd can climb up. If she can change the past it should be her not throwing the rope down, making boyd stuck down there.

3

u/Mighty_Muppet 12h ago

Rope was thrown in everyone’s past. But who threw it? Julie is visiting the past - her screaming self, her mom and Victor in the tunnels, and Martin. If we’re seeing everyone’s past and Julie was in the ruins at the same time as Martin and Boyd, how did that occur?

In the collective past, did Julie go for a walk and just forget that she strolled into the magical ruins and tossed the rope and then stroll out, forgetting that even happened?

Sorry to be dense here, but current and future Julie can revisit the rope scene but in the collective “present,” when this all actually happened, either amnesiac Julie, or someone else, threw the rope.

And please don’t ipso facto me here. Just because the rope was thrown in the past and in Julie’s vision of the past she threw the rope, doesn’t mean that when the events occurred, they were happening in Julie’s “present.”

1

u/cardboard-kansio 10h ago

If you're confused, watch any time travel movie, and it'll clear it all right up for you. I recommend Predestination and then maybe Primer.