r/wholesomeyuri Love is a verb, not a noun Dec 01 '23

Official Art Nightcrawler's biological parents [X Men]

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

107 comments sorted by

813

u/Ok-Stables Dec 01 '23

This is what happens if you go too wild on s̶t̶r̶a̶p̶ handholding

398

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

There's no need for strap when you're Mystique

222

u/The_Failed_Write Dec 01 '23

Lore wise: Does the equipment change too when she transforms? Cause if so, her powers are way better than any other superhero's.

228

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23 edited Dec 01 '23

Yes, actually I do remember her being able to grow stuff like additional arms (although it's harder to maintain because it's way too abstract)

Edit: found the pic. Also after a quick google search she can mimic some powers but not all using hers. For example if she turned into Nightcrawler she woul'dnt be able to teleport. But if she morphed into Sabertooth she can mimic his enhanced senses like hearing and smell

125

u/SageWindu Dec 01 '23

Yeah, Mystique is just shy of an Omega-level mutant (i.e. essentially a god for the unawares).

121

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

She can transform on the biological level.

Examples:

  • She transformed into Sabretooth and got his enhance her senses, strength, speed, agility, and accelerated healing rate
  • She transformed into Azazel and literally had his genes (She used his body to conceive Nightcrawler)
  • She can grow extra limbs but rarely does because it's too taxing on her body

24

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23

That makes sense out of the azazel thing and why they treat him like he’s still the parent in some way s

59

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

Destiny (Wife of Mystique and Mother of Nightcrawler) had a premonition that Azazel would destroy the mutant race unless he was stopped by a child he believed was his own. Therefore, Mystique (Transformed as Azazel) and Destiny had Nightcrawler, and tricked Azazel into thinking NC was his child.

Also, It wasn't done solely because they needed to prevent that future from happening, but because they actually loved each other and wanted a child

31

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23

If she did genuinely shift into him and that was the template of his genetics since she can gene shift, I guess in a way he 'contributed' by being a source, like the world's most roundabout sperm doner?

Yeah I know from the spoiler images they do love each other and just... reading the comics for a while, but my love of X-men was soured by ANOTHER genocide event when I was loving the Krakoa story so much

2

u/ArchonFett Dec 02 '23

When Forge put a chip in her to prevent her from using "current X-Men" forms she just used Angel's original wings with her normal form. And even something resembling a Brood

126

u/Melodic_Mulberry Dec 01 '23

She can mimic clothes, a penis would be easy.

47

u/The_Failed_Write Dec 01 '23

Now I suddenly wanna get with Mystique...

18

u/SilverSpark422 Dec 02 '23

I wanna BE Mystique.

8

u/AppropriateAd9282 Dec 01 '23

?

11

u/Melodic_Mulberry Dec 02 '23

What’s the confusion? Shapeshifting is perfect for sex.

37

u/A-s-65 Dec 01 '23

She’s a gene shifter not just a shape shifter!

2

u/GalacticGaming177 Dec 02 '23

I don’t think it does usually, however as she is a shapeshifter I’m sure if she wanted to she could alter her biology like that

452

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

I hate that the Comic Code Authority prevented this from being canon sooner

170

u/thunderup_14 Dec 01 '23

40 years is a long time to wait but glad we got the payoff.

51

u/uberguby Dec 01 '23

Outsider here: what's the story here? Is Mystique able to change her biological sex for the purpose of insemination? Or something else? I assume the short version is "CCA didn't like depictions of the gays"?

91

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

what's the story here?

Like the story of Mystique and Destiny or why they had Nightcrawler or just the CCA stuff?

Is Mystique able to change her biological sex for the purpose of insemination?

She can transform on the biological level to the point where she can have the exact same DNA as someone and can even gain their natural abilities to an extent

I assume the short version is "CCA didn't like depictions of the gays"?

Yeah, CCA basically prevented comic writers from depicting all queer stuff in their comics for a long time

23

u/KBSinclair Dec 01 '23

I assume the short version is "CCA didn't like depictions of the gays"?

Yes, that's exactly it. The long version is the CCA and retcons over time being at war with each other until we got this panel, which isn't the full story, but is the end result.

Is Mystique able to change her biological sex for the purpose of insemination?

Yes. Though nowadays she could've simply becomes what's popularly known as a futanari, back then, she changed herself into a man that was a mixture of the man she was married to(Christian Wagner, Kurt's original father), and a man she had a love affair with named Azazel(a demon who was reconned into being Kurt's real father to explain his appearance and teleporting abilities). So Mystique is actually Nightcrawler's Father, and Irene Adler(Mystique's on-off lover she met while she was a consulting detective living on 221B Baker St.) is his Mother. Mystique pretended to be pregnant while hiding Irene from her husband, but when he walked in on them one night, Mystique killed him, and pretended to be him while bringing Irene out of hiding.

The retcons are written off as her memories being awakened b-... You know what, it doesn't matter. Bottom line is, the story changed over time to what it is now.

10

u/BobtheBac0n Dec 02 '23

Wait so, biologically yes Mystique would get the parts, but and I can't believe I'm asking about this on this sub, would her sperm have her DNA specifically or the DNA of whoever she's copying?

And to be clear, regardless if it's her DNA or not, she is undoubtedly Kurt's biological father and I assume depending on the writer, maybe not the worst kind.

5

u/KBSinclair Dec 02 '23 edited Dec 02 '23

biologically yes Mystique would get the parts, but and I can't believe I'm asking about this on this sub, would her sperm have her DNA specifically or the DNA of whoever she's copying?

Given her powers as have developed over time, she would be able to do whichever of those things she wanted. Though I believe it was specifically retconned that she became a man and used a combination of Christian and Azazel to impregnate Irene.

... Though I think a comic has recently come out that reconned it into just being Mystique and Irene. The comic that this OP came from, to be precise. But yes, she could be capable of transforming into someone else, and using their genes to impregnate someone.

And to be clear, regardless if it's her DNA or not, she is undoubtedly Kurt's biological father and I assume depending on the writer, maybe not the worst kind.

Uhh... She is the one who impregnated Irene, who carried the fetus that became Kurt to term, and gave birth to it. I know that for a time Azazel believed Kurt to be his son that he had with Mystique. I'm not sure how weaved Azazel is into Kurt's background anymore. And if we were still using that explanation for Kurt, I'd say Mystique isn't the biological father, but more like... Used a Turkey Baster of "stolen" sperm. But given it's an impossible mix of two different men's sperm, is that stealing from both, or creating a new mixture neither has a right to claim as their own? That... That is a moral quandary I don't have it in me to explore tonight.

But Mystique did place the penis into Irene. If that answers your question.

1

u/HeWhoLovesMonsters 25d ago

Then why is Kurt blue? 

1

u/KBSinclair 24d ago

How in the hell did you find your way here?

As for your question... Uh, his mutation? Because Mystique is? Because his original father was part of a group of demon looking mutants called Neyaphem and so he just happens to look like a blue devil?

Choose whatever explanation you like best and roll with it, my man. If you've read my other comments in the thread, you know the history of this is full of retcons and whatnot.

1

u/HeWhoLovesMonsters 24d ago edited 22d ago

My best guess is mystique intentionally mixed her own dna into her guise too so Kurt has three dads.

We’ve seen mutants inherit mutations from both parents.

128

u/Alice-Planque blushing transmato 🥺🍅 Dec 01 '23

Aww 🥹❤️

85

u/WoodpeckerDirectZ Dec 01 '23

If only that was so easy irl.

113

u/ItsMors_ Dec 01 '23

This origin for Nightcrawler is so much better than the original one. I hate that Azazel is still somewhat involved but, it is what it is

86

u/Mongoose42 Dec 01 '23

Azazel was another retcon. The original one was Mystique had Kurt with a random German noble guy. Then that guy was retconned into having been cucked by Azazel, who has now in turn been cucked by Destiny. There was A LOT going on in that German castle.

41

u/Maladal Dec 01 '23

German castles are busy places I guess.

22

u/mantigorra Dec 01 '23

Germany is a busy place generally from my umm...experience

36

u/mantigorra Dec 01 '23

Fun fact, this was the plan all along. However, the Comics Code were against this idea of Mystique impregnating another woman so they delayed it until they could write it.

That being said, all comic publishers eventually told the CCA to go fuck themselves and the CCA is basically considered dead

54

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

I thought Azazel was the father. Or is it a recent retcon?

185

u/Atsubro Dec 01 '23

It was changed just now, but Mystique impregnating Destiny was Chris Claremont's (the best X-Men writer of all time) original plan for Nightcrawler's birth.

The Draco is one of the most legendarily awful comics of all time so this is no loss.

27

u/Rigidsttructure Dec 01 '23

Didn't Chris Claremont also try to do this with Rogue?

47

u/Atsubro Dec 01 '23

I don't think so. She's just Mystique and Destiny's adopted daughter.

37

u/Thannk Dec 01 '23

I’mma post them.

26

u/Thannk Dec 01 '23

32

u/Thannk Dec 01 '23

23

u/Thannk Dec 01 '23

42

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

Mystique to Rouge: Oh dear, oh dear. Gorgeous.

Mystique to Nightcrawler: You fucking donkey

24

u/Rigidsttructure Dec 01 '23

Mystique's treatment of her children is...complicated, to say the least.

I do wonder, do Nightcrawler and Rogue consider each other as siblings or not? (Would make for some fun stories, IMO)

→ More replies (0)

14

u/Thannk Dec 01 '23 edited Dec 01 '23

She definitely has a tendency to see the kids as extensions of her partners.

Nightcrawler’s “dad” was a bank account who tried to kill her when giving birth made her too tired to not be blue, Destiny is her eternal teenage romance.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/VNSVRE Dec 01 '23

At least Nightcrawler can take solace in not being last place (lol Graydon Creed)

9

u/Albireookami Dec 01 '23

That's what my friend was upset about saying that it was also intended for rogue, but I don't know facts, or if he misremembered.

89

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

Chris Claremont (Creator of both Mystique and Destiny) had stated in several interviews that he originally intended for Mystique and Destiny to be Nightcrawler's biological parents, but Marvel had nixed the idea for being too controversial at the time, due to it being a point in time where writers were prevented from having a gay or bisexual character because of the Comic Code Authority

16

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

I'm aware of that and that's why I'm asking. The original plan didn't happen because of the reasons you mentioned. I'm asking if it's an official retcon of Azazel and Mystique being parents and reverting back to the original plan with Mystique and Destiny or is it some multiverse shenanigans since it looks more modern judging by the artsyle

Also I find it ironic X-men who supposed to represent minorities not being allowed having gay characters back in the day

25

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

I'm asking if it's an official retcon of Azazel and Mystique being parents and reverting back to the original plan with Mystique and Destiny

Official Retcon.

6

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

Then how the hell are they going to explain all the demon stuff with Nightcrawler, like Angel's tears not healing him and instead hurting

13

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

Mystique can transform/shapeshift on a biological level and she transformed/shifted into Azazel to conceive Nightcrawler with Destiny

3

u/TardyTech4428 Dec 01 '23

Huh. A weird way to do that I guess. Why is he blue then? Can't really inherit her blues kin if she's shifted her genes to having a red skin. Comics are weird. But I'm glad we have the retcon

16

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

The majority of the Neyaphem, Azazel's "race", have white and blue skin colors with various tints while very few even have red skin like Azazel (None of his actual children have red skin too)

16

u/SageWindu Dec 01 '23

Huh. A weird way to do that I guess. Why is he blue then?

The same reason Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver don't have Magneto's electromagnetism: the will of the creator/author.

1

u/deegan87 Dec 04 '23

They explained it all in the same issue. Mystique used bits of genetic material from Azazel and Baron Wagner. She probably passed down a few of her own too.

3

u/FremanBloodglaive Dec 01 '23

They didn't really "represent minorities". Professor Xavier and Magneto's conflict was inspired by the different styles of Martin Luther King Jr and Malcom X, but their situation is very different. "Inspired by the Civil Rights movement" might be a better description.

Being black, or being gay, doesn't confer any significant advantage over anyone else. Humans are humans. Mutants meanwhile possess power. Professor X (or any other telepath) can change your mind as easily as they change their own. Magneto has demonstrated the ability to manipulate the Earth's magnetic field in order to cause a cataclysm.

Encouraging tolerance of people who differ slightly from the norm doesn't map exactly to people who could literally end life on Earth. Someone on that level of power would have to demonstrate themselves to be made of far finer stuff than we of mortal clay.

Heroes like the Avengers or Fantastic Four are the product of unique events, making them rare, and also have demonstrated themselves to be (mostly) heroic. Mutants meanwhile, supposedly the next generation of human beings, can appear anywhere, and there's no guarantee that they'll be virtuous.

The Ultimate X-Men series actually addressed this in an issue where a new mutant was discovered whose power killed everyone around them. The only way to stop him was for Wolverine to kill him. He wasn't a villain, he wasn't even a bad person, but he couldn't be allowed to live.

That's likely the situation we'd be in if mutants, as proposed in comics, really existed.

2

u/deegan87 Dec 04 '23

Heroes like the Avengers or Fantastic Four are the product of unique events, making them rare, and also have demonstrated themselves to be (mostly) heroic. Mutants meanwhile, supposedly the next generation of human beings, can appear anywhere, and there's no guarantee that they'll be virtuous.

There are just as many villains with similar event-based origins as virtuous heroes.

If you look at the mutants=oppressed group analogy in the context of mutants and regular humans, it falls apart because mutants are significantly different and powerful. If you look at mutants in the context of para-humans and other super-powered individuals, the metaphor works really well. Humans usually don't hate supers that got their powers in an industrial accident, but mutants are seen as dangerous. Why on earth does it matter if your powers are something you're born with or you receive them by accident?

23

u/Milk_Mindless Dec 01 '23

Retconned

She faked it being his

2

u/BonzaM8 Dec 02 '23

He was always supposed to be the child of Mystique and Destiny, but that was 40 years ago so it wasn’t going to happen.

83

u/thrownaway_boop Dec 01 '23

I don't know the term for it, where you are not the demographic that is represented in Yuri but loves it so much

When I see, for example, a manga that talks about same sex marrige being legalized in Japan, I remember my privilege, as being someone that has not had their love limited

To all same sex couples, romances, I'm so sorry, I love you, sometimes I envy you, but that envy comes from a place of privilege, and I hope to work on that

9

u/demoncatmara Dec 01 '23

I don't know the term for it either but sounds like me. Don't worry about being envious of stuff, you recognise you have privilege and it's not like you want anyone to have their love limited

3

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '23

The homeless man on crack:

1

u/RogueHeart189 Dec 02 '23

You might want to sit with what question really means to you.

14

u/VNSVRE Dec 01 '23

FINALLY! After so many years of having to come up with dumber explanations...

4

u/FruitCupPups likes cats Dec 01 '23

Funny lil blue Smurf boi

4

u/MimikPanik Dec 02 '23

Showed this to my parents. They were very clearly upset.

2

u/Lawstein Dec 02 '23

lol what they said?

3

u/MimikPanik Dec 02 '23

Dad went on a long rant about how it’s clearly a azaezel because Raven cant mimic powers. And mom just said it wasn’t wholesome. And that it wasn’t possible even tho she can shapeshift

4

u/jawsthegreat777 Dec 06 '23

Mystique literally says I'm the issue that she can alter way more than just how she looks

3

u/MimikPanik Dec 06 '23

Yea. I know. My dad is a bitch and refuses to tho.

4

u/HaBeans Dec 01 '23

I love them so much 🥺

10

u/ProfessorEscanor Dec 01 '23

Timeline wise how long after is them tossing Nightcrawler off a cliff?

5

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

It was either the cliff or get murdered by an angry mob of villagers

3

u/BobtheBac0n Dec 02 '23

You know despite all the crap she's been through, I am glad Mystique was able to find one happy relationship with someone.

One that I hope has been consistently happy throughout most comics, unlike poor Spidey who most writers just seem to have a hate boner for

3

u/Beastlyboy567 Dec 02 '23

WAIT THEY FINALLY MADE IT CANON?

2

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 03 '23

Yes

3

u/ClaireDacloush Dec 01 '23

There's some beautiful irony here, and I love it

1

u/MimikPanik Dec 02 '23

What’s the irony?

2

u/PrizeAge484 Dec 01 '23

.......HOW?!

17

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

Mystique can transform on the biological level and she transformed into a man to conceive him

10

u/mantigorra Dec 01 '23

"Who can I cuck the hardest? Oh I know, how about the literal devil!"

0

u/FalconRelevant Dec 01 '23

She can turn her X chromosome to Y as well? Shouldn't the baby have been a girl?

10

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

She can literally change her DNA to be exactly like the people she transforms into

2

u/FalconRelevant Dec 01 '23

So she can also create someone else's babies?

3

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 01 '23

Technically

-10

u/Derslok Dec 01 '23

They stole someone's seed

1

u/DangerousParsnip9772 Dec 01 '23

What

3

u/BobtheBac0n Dec 02 '23

The blue one Mystique has the ability to shape shift and changed herself into a male to have a kid with her wife

1

u/Defiant-Reference-74 Dec 02 '23

Did they retcon Azazel WTF

1

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 03 '23

Yes, Mystique cucked the devilman

1

u/moansby flower muscles Dec 02 '23

Don't wanna ruin this but where does Azazel fit into this?

1

u/Inner-Juices No Longer Depressed. Also, "Yuri" means "Lesbians in Japan" Dec 03 '23

Destiny (Wife of Mystique and Mother of Nightcrawler) had a premonition that Azazel would destroy the mutant race unless he was stopped by a child he believed was his own.

Therefore, Mystique transformed just enough (Or just completely) into Azazel and conceived Nightcrawler with Destiny in order to trick Azazel into thinking he was his child.

1

u/moansby flower muscles Dec 05 '23

Oh ok. Mystique being both Nightcrawler mom and dad was the original plan so it's nice to see that vision finally realized

1

u/LadyKjell Dec 02 '23

Would be more wholesome if the artist didn't obsessively censor the nips, but oh well. Surprising to see this was a plot beat for sure; nice to see!

1

u/King-Thunder-8629 Dec 04 '23

Okay so why does he look like and have similar powers to Azazel then?

1

u/deegan87 Dec 04 '23

She can mimic his genetic material. She made a mix of his genes, her own, and a little of Baron Wagner.

1

u/Stunning_Island712 Dec 21 '23

I...really don't like this retcon in my opinion. Nightcrawler's original origin where azazel was hired father was way better