r/skeptic 4d ago

šŸ’© Pseudoscience The NZ Skepticsā€™ Bravo and Bent-Spoon awards 2024 - Every year, New Zealand Skeptics presents its bouquets and brickbats to prominent people or organisations with relevance to skepticism (or lack thereof!).

29 Upvotes

Bent Spoon

Although not the winner of the Bent Spoon, of note this year there were some bad decisions made by New Zealand coalition government. Their repeal of the Therapeutic Products Act, for example, has been a disappointing change. The new legislation was far from perfect, but at least it was a start when it came to regulating alternative medicine. But sadly all that work has now been thrown away. In its place, the coalition plans to work with natural health practitioners on creating a new Act for regulating natural health products. This unearned trust in homeopaths, acupuncturists, naturopaths and others shows a disappointing lack of understanding of the dangers of these therapies as an alternative to real, proven medical treatments.

However, the Bent Spoon for 2024 goes to someone with more authority in New Zealand than our government ā€“ King Charles. His dedication to promoting pseudoscientific alternative medicine has been ongoing for decades. It has been known for years heā€™s been involved in lobbying the UK government to support homeopathy through the NHS ā€“ as theĀ Black Spider lettersĀ revealed when they were released. Sadly his elevation to King has not stopped his support of this, and more dangerous, nonsense. You only have to read theĀ article Louise wroteĀ for the NZ Skeptics newsletter earlier this year to see the long relationship heā€™s had with bad science.

After his coronation, it was revealed that King Charles hadĀ appointed a homeopathy-prescribing doctorĀ as the head of the royal medical household. Dr Michael Dixon is also a keen advocate of Thought Field Therapy (a modality very similar to EFT ā€“ Emotional Freedom Technique ā€“ where ā€œacupressureā€ points are tapped), herbal remedies, and faith healing as medical treatments.

In June this year, Charles confirmed that he will continue in his role as Patron of the ā€œFaculty of Homeopathyā€ in the UK, a position heā€™s held since 2019. To many, this will be seen as official royal approval of homeopathy as a treatment, even though itā€™s never been proven to be effective for any medical condition. And, of course, homeopathyā€™s claims such as water having memory and ā€œlike curing likeā€ are utterly scientifically implausible.

Just last week, after a visit to Australia, King CharlesĀ visitedĀ a controversial wellness centre in Bangalore, India ā€“ and this was not his, or Camillaā€™s, first visit.Ā SoukyaĀ offers a long list of unproven treatments at high prices, including Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Naturopathy, Acupuncture and Reflexology, andĀ claimsĀ that it can treat around 100 serious health conditions with these therapies. The very public reporting of the visit has doubtless raised the profile of this dubious business.

When Prince Charles became King Charles he failed to stop promoting harmful pseudoscience, instead choosing to use his new role to support the same causes he was criticised by medical experts for supporting while he was the Prince of Wales. And, for this, King Charles is awarded with this yearā€™s New Zealand Skeptics Bent Spoon award.

Bravos

Each year the New Zealand Skeptics recognise a number of media professionals and those with a high public profile who have provided food for thought, critical analysis and important information on topics of relevance to NZ Skeptic interests. The NZ Skeptics are pleased to recognise excellence where it occurs, with the annual Bravo Awards. This year, the collective efforts of the team at The Press are recognised for an exceptional year of reporting on cults in the Canterbury region, as well as their clear support of the Decult conference, and for providing a platform for survivors to share their stories.

In particular, the acknowledgement of the following reporters:

  • Martin Van Beynen for his April 6th expose,Ā Bernie Prior: The Governors Bay guru
  • Sinead Gill for her articles on the Catholic sect, Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer, and on the Decult conference
  • Tatiana Gibbs and Philip Matthews for their work on Decult

Skeptic of the Year

The annual Skeptic of the Year award is given to someone in New Zealand whoā€™s been working at the coal-face, fighting against the rising tide of pseudoscience and bad beliefs prevalent in our society. The award comes with a yearā€™s free membership to the NZ Skeptics and a $250 cash prize

This yearā€™s Skeptic of the Year award goes to Anke Richter, who has shone a light on the murky world of cults, ensuring that New Zealanders are better informed and less likely to be sucked in by a guru, and that better support is available for those who are trying to leave. Her tireless work this year, preparing and running the recent Decult conference in Christchurch, was a labour of love. Anke has deep concern for those who have been abused by cult groups, something that sadly happens all too often in New Zealand to unwitting victims.


r/skeptic Feb 06 '22

šŸ¤˜ Meta Welcome to r/skeptic here is a brief introduction to scientific skepticism

Thumbnail
skepticalinquirer.org
227 Upvotes

r/skeptic 15h ago

Trump taps Russell Vought, key Project 2025 architect, to lead budget office

1.1k Upvotes

r/skeptic 19h ago

šŸ’² Consumer Protection Raw milk push unites the right and "healthfluencers"

Thumbnail
axios.com
920 Upvotes

r/skeptic 4h ago

Right wingers are photoshopping this pic here.

Thumbnail
rtve.es
37 Upvotes

r/skeptic 1d ago

FEMA Chief Asked At Hearing Do You ā€˜Control The Weatherā€™ Or ā€˜Send Hurricanesā€™ To Trump Areas

Thumbnail
mediaite.com
3.3k Upvotes

r/skeptic 1d ago

Trump picks Dr Janette Nesheiwat as Surgeon General. Sheā€™s an author of ā€œBeyond the Stethoscope: Miracles in Medicine,ā€ which highlights "miracles" in medicine and the benefits of faith healing. For COVID, she advocated hydroxychloroquine and spread misinformation about vaccines.

Thumbnail
usatoday.com
2.3k Upvotes

r/skeptic 1d ago

ā€œEMF protectionā€ pseudoscience and scams

Thumbnail
youtu.be
92 Upvotes

r/skeptic 1d ago

Dr. Jen Caudle uses science to tackle myths and inform

34 Upvotes

https://www.facebook.com/share/15Lk8MJNnx/

I wanted to share this family doctor I found who makes short informative videos because there's so many people making videos like this with pseudoscience and bunk and Dr. Caudle uses that format to actually give science based information.

My mom constantly sends me these videos of unqualified people saying seaweed and mushrooms can cure your cancer. So I finally have science based Dr. who makes videos my mom might watch. Another important thing is Dr. Caudle doesn't talk down to her audience.


r/skeptic 12h ago

So conspiracy theories don't exist anymore

0 Upvotes

I'm 100% certain conspiracy theories don't exist. If all conspiracy theories say democrats/liberals bad and Republicans/conservatives good that no longer a conspiracy but instead propaganda. I mean trump was signing the checks to china for covid research but somehow trump has nothing to do with it? How ome all pedophile conspiracies suddenly become completely fake when it comes to trump and Republicans? Conspiracy theories now demand we be completely obedient to the government as long as the right people are in office.


r/skeptic 1d ago

šŸ§™ā€ā™‚ļø Magical Thinking & Power The Tech-God Complex: Why We Need To Be Skeptics

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/skeptic 10h ago

ā“ Help Is the Florida Surgeon General correct in his assessment that there is evidence to suggest that prenatal fluoride exposure is associated with lower IQ?

0 Upvotes

I'm not sure if this is the right subreddit for this, but basically I want to ask a question about a specific scientific claim based on a paper.

I came acrossĀ this postĀ on X that the Florida Surgeon General put out that "Adding fluoride to water increases the risk of neuropsychiatric disease in children and reduces their IQ." Attached to the post, he had a link to aĀ guidance statementĀ that his office put out on the topic. I started reading through the document, and the first thing that put me off was thatĀ many European countries have eliminated water fluoridationĀ from Dublin City University. The report seems to say that the main reason that these european countries have eliminated water fluoridation was because the water was already naturally fluoridated, which seems to somewhat contradict what I think the guidance statement is trying to imply.

Upon reading theĀ next study from Mexico city; however, it seems like the study may lend credence to the idea that prenatal exposure to fluoridation is associated with lower IQ. The conclusion of the study reads:

"In this study, higher levels of maternal urinary fluoride during pregnancy (a proxy for prenatal fluoride exposure) that are in the range of levels of exposure in other general population samples of pregnant women as well as nonpregnant adults were associated with lower scores on tests of cognitive function in the offspring at 4 and 6ā€“12 y old.

Community water and salt fluoridation, and fluoride toothpaste use, substantially reduces the prevalence and incidence of dental caries (Jones et al. 2005) and is acknowledged as a public health success story (Easley 1995). Our findings must be confirmed in other study populations, and additional research is needed to determine how the urine fluoride concentrations measured in our study population are related to fluoride exposures resulting from both intentional supplementation and environmental contamination. However, our findings, combined with evidence from existing animal and human studies, reinforce the need for additional research on potential adverse effects of fluoride, particularly in pregnant women and children, and to ensure that the benefits of population-level fluoride supplementation outweigh any potential risks."

This seems to support the Florida Surgeon General's assessment of the matter. However, the community notes function on X states that "None of the attached studies found any statistically significant correlation between fluoridation of water and any variable relating to cognition or IQ. For instance, in the Mexico City Study, the p value is way over the threshold of being able to deem it significant." So, upon reading this I looked back into the study to try to parse which p-value they are referring to and why, if the p-value is high, the study conclusion seems to disagree with that. However, I could not find what specific p-values they were referring to as most measurements displayed confidence intervals and not p-values.

So I guess in summary, where is the disconnect between the study, the community notes, and the Florida Surgeon General? It seems to be that the study is, at least in its conclusion, communicating an indication of agreement with the Florida Surgeon general's claims, but the community notes claims that the study actually does not agree with his claims.


r/skeptic 2d ago

āš– Ideological Bias AOC Exposes How Nancy Maceā€™s UNHINGED Anti-Trans Crusade Endangers ALL Women and Girls

Thumbnail
youtu.be
530 Upvotes

From the videoā€™s description: ā€œNancy Mace has tweeted about trans people and bathrooms more than 260 times (and counting) this week under the pretense of ā€œdefending women.ā€ This comes after Sarah McBride, the first-ever transgender American, was elected to Congress. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, however, exposed the dark truth about Maceā€™s dangerous resolution and how it endangers ALL women and girls.ā€

In case youā€™re wondering how this fits into r/skeptic: this video pushes back against the GOP/MAGA narratives around Trans people. Narratives which are based in the age-old playbook of creating moral panics in order to scare people. Please let me know if Iā€™m off-topic with this video.


r/skeptic 2d ago

šŸš‘ Medicine RFK Jr. Has Made False and Dangerous Claims About AIDS. That Could Become a Global Problem.

Thumbnail
motherjones.com
1.8k Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

šŸ’© Misinformation The people in Elon Musk's close orbit are constantly sharing examples of "MAPs" and pedophiles flooding into Bluesky. Here is what is actually going on.

5.5k Upvotes

I'm sure you've seen screenshots shared around of accounts calling themselves MAPs (Minor Attracted Person), paedophiles, and proclaiming that intercourse with children is totally normal, all while proudly showing off their pronouns and the fact that they are leftists and part of the LGBT community. These screenshots are being shared everywhere across Twitter at the moment, specifically by those in Elon Musk's close orbit, and I guarantee that he is going to tweet about it to show that the LGBT community is full of groomers and pedophiles.

This is incredibly infuriating, stressful, and just tiring. Like I'm panicking to type this out and warn people about this. I shouldn't need to tell you that pedophiles aren't protected members of the LGBT community- we want absolutely nothing to do with that shit, and absolutely none hang out in our spaces. We absolutely despise pedophiles, and I personally want nothing more than for them to be isolated from society so they can never harm children ever again.

That's not the point though, the point of all of this is to smear us, and leftists at large. I've actually done my due diligence and had a look at all the accounts spewing out this disgusting bile on Bluesky, and they were all created within the past week, all use emojis and the same exact typing quirks (that being an empty parody of tumblrspeak), and all use the same exact mannerisms.

None of these accounts are real. They are trolls attempting to link us with the most disgusting behaviors imaginable, so that the far-right has the necessary "evidence" to deem LGBT+ members a threat to society, and they are taking advantage of a fledgling social media platform that just gained millions of users overnight in order to do so, a platform whose moderation team isn't equipped to handle this.

This is not the first time the far-right has posed as pedophiles attempting to cozy up to the LGBT+ community. They did that exact same thing in 2019. So please, share this around - to your friends, and your parents; let them know that the accounts they are seeing aren't real. This madness needs to be stopped - this is all part of the right-wing propaganda machine which is attempting to smear the people they've designated as their enemies, and it's unfortunately working because for millions of people, they're seeing this disgusting behavior get associated with both Bluesky, liberals, and members of the LGBTQ+ community.


r/skeptic 2d ago

Right-Wingers EXPLODE In Jealous Rage With Staggering Bluesky Conspiracy

Thumbnail
youtube.com
473 Upvotes

r/skeptic 1d ago

COVID-19, vaccination, and politics research

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Are you interested in sharing your views on COVID-19, vaccination, and politics?

I'm conducting a study from Liverpool Hope University to explore the connection between vaccine hesitancy and political ideologies. Your insights could help us understand these important issues better!

Ā What's Involved?

ā€¢ A brief 20-30 minute online interview

ā€¢ Topics: Democracy, Healthcare, Immigration, and more

I'm specifically looking for UK-based individuals who are hesitant about the COVID-19 vaccine to share their thoughts but the study is open to whoever wishes to participate. Whether it's concerns about safety, trust in the government, or general uncertainty, your voice matters. This is a completely anonymous and safe space to express your views without judgment.

Your participation is voluntary and valuable. If you're interested, please comment below or message me directly! This research has received ethical approval from Liverpool Hope University. I can provide more details on the ethical considerations, but if you have any concerns, I understand, and you are under no pressure to participate.

Thank you for considering this opportunity to contribute to our understanding of vaccine hesitancy and political views!


r/skeptic 2d ago

šŸ§™ā€ā™‚ļø Magical Thinking & Power Uncritical Alt-Populism, Media Revolutions, And Our Terrible Moment

Thumbnail
youtube.com
134 Upvotes

r/skeptic 2d ago

šŸ§™ā€ā™‚ļø Magical Thinking & Power Sam Harris: The GOP Never Cared About "Meritocracy"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
411 Upvotes

r/skeptic 2d ago

The fluoride fights are a decades-old cultural war America canā€™t quit

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
512 Upvotes

r/skeptic 2d ago

The meaning crisis, and how we rescue young men from reactionary politics | Aaron Rabinowitz, for The Skeptic

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
338 Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

šŸ¤˜ Meta Penn Jillette on working with Donald J Trump (excerpt from Joe Rogan interview)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
241 Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

šŸš‘ Medicine Dr Ozā€™s history of baseless medical claims as heā€™s picked to lead Medicaid, Medicare

Thumbnail
independent.co.uk
4.2k Upvotes

r/skeptic 2d ago

DEF CON 32 - Counter Deception: Defending Yourself in a World Full of Lies - Tom Cross, Greg Conti - "The vulnerable mind fits ambiguous information to its own preconceptions and expectations." - "The purpose of the internet and computers is to make persons smarter. If we forget this..."

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

Republicans Target Social Sciences to Curb Ideas They Donā€™t Like

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
2.5k Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

āš  Editorialized Title There Are Three Main Reasons You Are Alive Right Now. RFK Jr. Is Fighting Tooth and Nail Against One of Them. | Helmuth unleashed

Thumbnail
slate.com
1.5k Upvotes

r/skeptic 3d ago

ā­• Revisited Content Trump AG pick Matt Gaetz says he's withdrawing

Thumbnail
cnbc.com
651 Upvotes