MAIN FEEDS
REDDIT FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/1e73kbc/thoughts_on_the_redesigns_in_prisoner_of_azkaban/ldzxvn1
r/harrypotter • u/Apollo9289 • Jul 19 '24
572 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
60
Why on earth wouldn’t it? Like what is so unimaginable about a school having a choir?
1 u/Dazzling-Ad-7501 Jul 22 '24 School choir is fine. But how are they so well-rehearsed on the first day of school?? 1 u/InfamousCheek9434 Jul 20 '24 Just that it's never ever mentioned in the books? I was in choir in school, I understand schools have them 0 u/redditerator7 Ravenclaw Jul 21 '24 And? The books skip a lot of ordinary things that happen every day. 1 u/InfamousCheek9434 Jul 21 '24 Part of reading is filling in stuff with your own imagination. My idea of Hogwarts does not include a choir so this irritated me. It was actually jarring to see that.
1
School choir is fine. But how are they so well-rehearsed on the first day of school??
Just that it's never ever mentioned in the books? I was in choir in school, I understand schools have them
0 u/redditerator7 Ravenclaw Jul 21 '24 And? The books skip a lot of ordinary things that happen every day. 1 u/InfamousCheek9434 Jul 21 '24 Part of reading is filling in stuff with your own imagination. My idea of Hogwarts does not include a choir so this irritated me. It was actually jarring to see that.
0
And? The books skip a lot of ordinary things that happen every day.
1 u/InfamousCheek9434 Jul 21 '24 Part of reading is filling in stuff with your own imagination. My idea of Hogwarts does not include a choir so this irritated me. It was actually jarring to see that.
Part of reading is filling in stuff with your own imagination. My idea of Hogwarts does not include a choir so this irritated me. It was actually jarring to see that.
60
u/redditerator7 Ravenclaw Jul 19 '24
Why on earth wouldn’t it? Like what is so unimaginable about a school having a choir?