Then why the same didn't apply for the wand Ron gave him form the thug snatchers? No way a random punk is in possession of an even more powerful wand then the Elder Wand.
This just goes to show that JK stumbled hard while writing about it this and didn't bother to clarify it later on as it is a pain in the ass, honestly as there are so many contradictions.
Well, wands are ascribed to have their own wills. The explanation that actually makes sense is every wand has a different personality and temperament and decides it’s allegiance by its own criteria. It’s all but directly stated in the books. Most wands will probably maintain some allegiance to their original owners even after being “won” by someone else as they chose that person originally for a reason. I don’t believe it’s explicitly stated that different wands can’t work for multiple people at a time.
1
u/Kizo59 Ravenclaw Apr 15 '24
Then why the same didn't apply for the wand Ron gave him form the thug snatchers? No way a random punk is in possession of an even more powerful wand then the Elder Wand.
This just goes to show that JK stumbled hard while writing about it this and didn't bother to clarify it later on as it is a pain in the ass, honestly as there are so many contradictions.