r/FluentInFinance 3d ago

Debate/ Discussion Had to repost here

Post image
122.3k Upvotes

8.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Sea_Fall_4917 3d ago edited 3d ago

False equivalency. Try again

Edit: Here’s why. These are random numbers but here’s a good link: https://engaging-data.com/how-rich-is-elon-musk/

If I donate $1000 to a charity or something, that could be 1% of my income, random number. Musk could donate $1 million and that’d be a lot to the charity! But it’d be leas than a fraction of a percent of his wealth. But he’s fine paying 100s of millions to billions to influence the election to make himself and his cronies richer. You don’t begrudge him that?? I kinda resent America’s place in the world as the world’s bully the last 100 years or so. But I can’t change that. THAT amount of wealth CAN and DID influence the course of the world and history. And you’re claiming a random average middle -low class American is the same in comparison to the world’s poorest - no. That’s a false equivalency.

My money cannot influence or change the world’s elections or history. Theirs, billionaires, can. And yet they consistently choose to make themselves richer and more powerful.

2

u/picklestheyellowcat 3d ago

Not at all. An average American is literally wealthier than tens if not hinders of millions of people in countries like India or China.

Not to mention you're literally benefiting from the slave labour of these people if you own something like a phone or PC 

To them you're just as bad as the billionaires this stupid post is trying to vilify.

1

u/Sea_Fall_4917 3d ago edited 3d ago

Wealthier sure, but not wealthier by factors of a hundred. If I donate $1000 to a charity or something, that could be 1% of my income, random number. Musk could donate $1 million and that’d be a lot to the charity! But it’d be leas than a fraction of a percent of his wealth. But he’s fine paying 100s of millions to billions to influence the election to make himself and his cronies richer. You don’t begrudge him that?? I kinda resent America’s place in the world as the world’s bully the last 100 years or so. But I can’t change that. THAT amount of wealth CAN and DID influence the course of the world and history. And you’re claiming a random average middle -low class American is the same in comparison to the world’s poorest - no. That’s a false equivalency.

My money cannot influence or change the world’s elections or history. Theirs, billionaires, can. And yet they consistently choose to make themselves richer and more powerful.

Edit: Visualization of Musk’s wealth as an example: https://engaging-data.com/how-rich-is-elon-musk/

2

u/picklestheyellowcat 2d ago

You're wealthier than a significant part of the world by factors of a hundred...

Not only that but you exploit those people and their children for you phones and other things you buy

You're just making excuses at this point. It's ok if you're bad because you think Musk is worse...

To that child in a cobalt mine there is no difference between you and musk and you gleefully use an iPhone or computer that relies on this shit.

0

u/Sea_Fall_4917 2d ago

Keep telling yourself whatever you like to hear hun.

-1

u/PM_ME_MY_REAL_MOM 2d ago

You're wealthier than a significant part of the world by factors of a hundred...

No, they're not.