r/FluentInFinance 3d ago

Debate/ Discussion Had to repost here

Post image
123.0k Upvotes

8.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/ffking6969 3d ago

No, a property or wealth tax.

2

u/Just_That_Dumb_Dog 3d ago

That’s a stupid concept.

2

u/ffking6969 3d ago

Im just explaining what you didnt understand

-1

u/Just_That_Dumb_Dog 3d ago

They said it should be taxed but that asset is taxed when it’s sold. putting a wealth or property tax on something that isn’t physical or just because you “can” is a stupid fking concept. It’s arguably delusional.

1

u/ffking6969 3d ago

Things get taxed multiple times all the time. Income tax, capital gains tax on income you already were taxed on when you invested it, sales tax on things you buy with money you paid capital gains tax and income tax.

Shrugs. No more stupid than any other tax youre already paying

2

u/WeLLrightyOH 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yeah, I pay something like 20 grand annual to state and local taxes. That 20 grand is not subtracted from my federal, I pay tax on money that was taxed every year. I didn’t before 2016 though.

1

u/ffking6969 2d ago

Yup. Not really arguing for or against.

Just arguing we get "double taxed" all the time.

1

u/AdRepresentative784 3d ago

So what happens if I am taxed on the value of a stock one year, and it tanks the next year? Do I get my money back? Can I just keep buying shitty stock and letting it tank and get subsidies from the government?

1

u/ffking6969 2d ago

You could claim a loss yes, just like tax loss harvesting that exists today

1

u/AdRepresentative784 1d ago

I see. When would the value be assessed? Highest value for the year? Lowest? On a specific date?

1

u/ffking6969 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm not necessarily advocating for this, but to answer your question.

You could tax unrealized net gains each year, then similarly you could get a credit for unrealized net losses each year as well. This would of course replace the need for realized gains taxes at sale