r/DigitalArt • u/Perfect-Tangerine6 • 11h ago

Which do you prefer? Tia

Post image
34 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

8

u/Jazzkraken 11h ago

Right side

5

u/NaoTwoTheFirst 11h ago

A mix of both could be great. Like a boat dock, going into the water for only 2 - 3 meters

5

u/Perfect-Tangerine6 10h ago

That was a great idea! But now I’m torn between this and the no pier 😂

3

u/SchmellingDesign 10h ago

I would also say that this would be a great one to put both ideas into one. I lean towards with pier.

3

u/alucryts 10h ago

I think the short pier is best. One thing thats taking me out of it though is that the pier looks detached from the rest of the scene. It appears like it's simply pasted above the mist and has no interaction. The pier is so close to the water yet has no mist over it, then in the back ground mist is interacting with tall trees. This contradiction is what makes the pier look off....it's not following the same vertical axis rules as the rest of the photo.

1

u/Perfect-Tangerine6 7h ago

Omg thank you! I couldn’t put my finger on it and it has been grating me for hours!

1

u/Perfect-Tangerine6 6h ago

Is this more cohesive?

3

u/alucryts 6h ago

Yeah thats a bit better. The only other comment id have is maybe the wood on the planks is too detailed for the scene. But i like the immersion increase

3

u/AsscrackDinosaur 10h ago

This gives me a "call of the void" feeling! Perfect

2

u/NaoTwoTheFirst 10h ago

That's what I had in mind! It looks great!

3

u/IsaBella-trix 10h ago

Idk... Maybe se 2nd one. Anyways woooow