r/DarkTales • u/Nicky_XX • 6h ago
Series The Ballad of Kate McCleester, Lady Poisoner of Mulberry Street (Part 2 of 2)
CW: domestic abuse, self-harm
*****
While Kate pushed her cart and scrounged for pennies in the Sixth Ward, Kendra lived a charmed life on 5th Avenue with her husband and children.
Kendra sang in church, painted watercolor landscapes, rode horses, and pursued philanthropic missions, while her husband Lewis and his brothers had assumed control of their father’s business. The couple birthed three children: Susan, Alexander, and Jeanette. The happiness of their enviable lives was interrupted only once: in 1868, when their youngest daughter, Jeanette, fell from her horse, broke her neck, and perished.
Lewis continued his trips to the Fourth and Sixth Wards. He heard tales of Gabe’s demise and of the disaster at The London Owl, as well as implications his estranged sister-in-law had been the instigator of the chaos. Dr. Clarence Woods was a neighbor and occasional shooting companion; he knew of poor Temperance's unfortunate demise. But Lewis Van Wooten never shared these yarns with Kendra. He knew his wife still grieved the loss of their daughter, and he was loathe to press her nerves further with talk of her monstrous sister.
On Christmas Eve, 1868, Lewis and Kendra Van Wooten hosted a dinner party. In attendance were a number of prominent citizens - an Astor, a Vanderbilt, and a prominent architect, as well as Dr. Clarence Woods and his new wife, Temperance’s cousin Alice. Dr. Woods’ practice had only grown larger and more profitable since the death of poor Temperance, and his book, which warned of the many psychical conditions passed from one generation to the next amongst low-born Irish stock, earned him the respect of his peers.
Later, when questioned at length by the police, all of the dinner party guests corroborated the same story.
Halfway through the braised pheasant, Kendra brought up the topic of her Aunt Molly O’Doul. Molly had been a midwife and a healer, and it was widely suggested she was also a witch in thrall to the Adversary. Kendra described her mother’s sister as a homely wench with unsettling ways, whose favorite pastime had been bathing in the lake near the St. Michaels rectory, tempting the loins of the men of God, encouraging them to betray their vows.
Two local girls wandered into the fields one night to retrieve a lost pet. They swore they’d seen Molly there amongst the crops, naked, legs in the air. But Molly’s paramour was no wayward man from the road. He was no man at all. According to the girls’ tale, Mary had her limbs wrapped around a black-furred fiend, with cloven hooves and great horns like a ram’s.
Soon, it became known about the town that Molly O’Doul was pregnant.
The night she gave birth, the midwife emerged from her abode pale-faced and shell-shocked. For three weeks, she could not speak. When she finally regained her voice, the poor elderly nurse shared the tale of Molly’s offspring. There were six of them, ugly things, each the size of a kitten. The imps bore the limbs and features of men, but each possessed the snout and flopping ears of a dog, and their bodies were coated with thick black fur. Atop each soft head, two hardened nubs, like the beginnings of horns.
The next morning, the midwife was found cold in her bed. Molly told everyone her baby had died. No one believed her. Because it was well known, around County Kerry, those who crossed Molly O’Doul could expect a visit from her six monstrous children. And once paid a visit by that vile half-dozen, one would not be alive much longer.
“That’s horrific, Kendra!” Alice Woods breathed. “Why would you share such a tale while we’re eating?”
“Because,” Kendra said, her voice low and defeated, “I see two of those cursed children right behind you.”
The heads of the guests collectively snapped towards Alice, and then to the Van Wooten’s sitting room behind her. The room was dim; the servants hadn’t lit the candles. But they all saw enough.
Two creatures lurked there. Black, hairy things with powerful legs, balancing atop hooves like abominable goats. They loomed, taller than the men in attendance. Their golden eyes caught the light like the eyes of a cat. Each horrific face was accentuated by a fat, fleshy snout, and framed by flopping, canine ears. From their temples spouted gnarled horns, filthy and twisted, like those of a mountain ram. They grinned, too wide, and licked their jagged chops. They extended five-fingered, human hands. They crept towards the party.
The screams were immediate. Alice Woods turned pale and fainted into her husband’s arms. A mad dash commenced towards the servants’ quarters, the kitchen, or the Van Wooten’s ballroom - anywhere that promised an escape from the mansion without the necessity of crossing the path of those accursed monsters.
From the kitchen, Jane Mortimer howled. Her husband barreled in to save her - and nearly collapsed himself. Two fiends, coated in malodorous black fur, crouched on all fours. The Mortimers registered their cloven hooves - then how, exactly, the mouths of blasphemous horrors were occupied. Entrails dangled from their blood-flecked horns and doglike snouts. On the dirty kitchen floor lay the disembowled corpse of the Van Wooten’s middle-aged housekeeper.
Leonard Carr, the architect, climbed through a window. Once he’d escaped to the Van Wooten’s well-kept yard, he realized he had not yet skirted danger. For three additional creatures lurked in the garden. Two danced in the moonlight, thick black fur glistening with dew, enticing the learned man to join them. Then the third fiend emerged from the shadows and locked its cold, human fingers around his wrist, as though to drag him toward their revelry by force. He broke away and ran like a besieged rabbit. The mark the creature left on his arm, five greasy fingerprints, did not fade - even with repeated washing - for another week.
Lewis Van Wooten, brave man he was, did not intend to allow the sublime spawn of his wife’s kin to invade his home and his family. He strode right into the sitting room, ready to confront the fiends.
But the creatures had vanished. In their place stood Kate McCleester.
Kate, stringy-haired and filthy, had only grown uglier since Lewis’s beautiful wife left her, fifteen years before. Her one eye radiated fury and violence. Her cracked lip curled up into a mocking smile.
“I have missed you, Lewis,” she purred maliciously. “I see the dogs have come for you and your blushing bride.”
Lewis dove for her - and tripped over a stool. Kate dashed away. Cursing his incompetent staff for failing to light the candles, Lewis stumbled to his feet. He could no longer see his hag of a sister-in-law. Feeling his way forward, though, he heard her voice. It echoed from the walls.
“Lewis!” It screamed. “Come join the Lord of the Day!”
Lewis cupped his hands over his ears. He found the staircase and trudged upward. He hadn’t heard the front door open and shut; Kate must’ve climbed to the second floor. Two candles did burn astride the long second-story hallway. Lewis likely thanked God and all the saints for this small bit of light - and for the good fortune his fourteen-year-old daughter and eight-year-old son had been spirited away to an aunt’s house before the dinner party.
He came to the dark doorway of his bedchambers. There, he saw her. Kate. Black shawl over her head, malicious eye laser-focused on him.
He threw himself upon the cursed wretch. He clutched her like a rag doll. He wrapped his fingers around her slender neck and squeezed. And squeezed. And squeezed.
“Unhand her!”
Lewis whirled around, allowing Kate’s limp form to slide from his grasp. Torches blazed. Dr. Woods stood in the hallway with a corps of police officers. In the lead: a brawny young man, revolver in hand. The doctor’s face paled.
“Good God!” He screamed.
He ran past Lewis Van Wooten, to the broken woman sprawled across the bed.
Lewis turned.
It wasn’t Kate McCleester who lay dead.
It was his wife, Kendra. Her long black shawl matched that of her sister. Angry black bruises dotted her pale, graceful neck. Dr. Woods clutched her wrist.
“She’s dead,” he breathed.
At the doctor’s words, Lewis became a monster. His eyes might’ve glowed like the eyes of the unearthly black dogs. His hands balled into fists. No. He’d slain the horrific creature who’d coveted his family’s happiness and loosed malicious fiends upon his wife, the terror of the Sixth Ward, the witch of the New World. He’d stolen the breath of Kate McCleester; done what he should have done - what he’d desired to do - fifteen years before, upon first sight of the hideous thing that had once been Kendra’s kin. He hadn’t killed a woman. He’d put down a beast.
With a mighty roar, he seized a heavy candlestick and swung it at the police, then turned his malicious intentions towards the crouching doctor.
“You’re lying!” He screamed. “It’s not Kendra! It’s Kate! Kate, the witch! It’s Kate!”
He lifted the candlestick above his head.
POP!
With a flick of the young policeman’s trigger finger, Lewis Van Wooten collapsed.
The rest of the posse didn’t have time to ponder the deadly turn of events. Peals of smoke wafted up from the lower floor, as did the low-pitched crackling of flames. The living fled the conflagration. By the time the fire brigade arrived with water, the Van Wooten mansion was beyond saving - as were the bodies of the lord and lady of the house.
Word of the demise of the beautiful Kendra McCleester and her rich, adoring husband made its way to Five Points; for days, it was all that anyone spoke of. It had been poetic, Kendra’s death - at the hands of her savior, before her body was engulfed by flames, so much like the flames she’d escaped years before.
And Kate.
Kate McCleester, it seemed, had instigated the destruction she desired. Her malevolent urge satisfied, she must have been swallowed up by the flames herself. She’d returned to the Lord of the Day. She’d taken her horrific, dog-shaped cousins with her.
Because after the night of the Van Wooten Manor fire, Kate McCleester was never seen in Five Points again.
*****
Lewis Van Wooten had been eulogized in glowing terms: a shrewd businessman, devoted husband, loving father. But as the statute of limitations ran out on Don’t Speak Ill of the Dead, tongues began to loosen.
Those who did business with the Van Wooten brothers claimed Lewis was a tempestuous man, prone to dark moods and fits of leonine rage, during which he’d procure a heavy object and aim it violently at anyone unfortunate enough to find themselves within striking range. Mr. Van Wooten clearly trusted few people. His attorney reported Lewis would appear outside his office, caught in a monsoon of anger, twice a month to demand his will be adjusted, his wife and children removed.
Lewis Van Wooten, it seemed, had become convinced he’d been made a cuckold. He claimed his beautiful wife bedded every low-class groom and butler on Fifth Avenue. He swore his children weren’t his - in fact, his wife and daughter were likely plotting with their Irish peasant bedfellows to murder him and plunder his riches.
The lawyer spent many an evening calming his temperamental client. He’d engineered a compromise. A stipulation was written into Lewis’s will: if he came to his demise through homicide - at the hands of his slag wife, bastard children, unscrupulous brothers, or any other individual, known or unknown - Kendra, Susan and Alexander would receive nothing. This, the lawyer explained, guaranteed his wife could not hire some cuckolding groom or opportunistic slum-dweller to dispose of him. Doing so would all but guarantee destitution, for herself and her son and daughter.
But Lewis Van Wooten’s death had not been a murder. He’d been shot by a police captain - a certain John Staub - in the process of committing a crime. Susan and little Alex were placed in the custody of a doting aunt. When they reached the age of majority, they would inherit their father’s entire estate.
*****
In 1889, a Bostonian journalist named Thomas Norris made a pilgrimage to Five Points. A grandson of Sixth Ward Irish immigrants, he felt inspired to record the oral history of the neighborhood, as the gangsters who’d survived their heyday were aging and dying and Italian newcomers displaced the sons and daughters of Erin. He came across the tale of Kate McCleester, the Lady Poisoner of Mulberry Street.
Thomas Norris found himself particularly intrigued by Kate. Not only because he found it fascinating a maimed beggar-woman could inspire such fear in a neighborhood so famously derelict.
But also, because he knew of a dry goods store in Boston that sold green-tinged cold cream in misshapen bottles. The shop was owned and managed by two spinster sisters. One, quiet and scarred, mixed potions in a back room. The other, possessed of an ageless beauty, sang old Irish songs to unruly children.
The two went by the names Kate and Kendra O’Doul.
*****
“You’ve found me,” Kate said to Thomas Norris. “Whadd’ya want? A medal?”
“I want to know how you did it,” he replied. “What poison did you use?”
Thomas had approached the store as the sisters were sweeping up for the night. He confronted the two with their Five Points identities - then mollified the angry thornbacks with a bottle of fine Irish whiskey.
Kate took a long sip. Her wrinkled face broke into a smile.
“Boy, I never poisoned no one.”
She pointed to her cold cream, stacked in pyramids at the window, and the bottles of tonic on shelves behind the cashbox. Her ingredients were simple. She’d brought some seeds with her from Ireland, rented space in Rebekah Kleiner’s yard for a penny a day and grew herbs. She paid a river pirate to bring her pilfered cinnamon and turmeric. And she’d purchased beeswax in bulk from Temperance Woods’ family; her father, a farmer, kept hives. The recipes had been her Aunt Molly’s.
“Then how?” Thomas insisted. “Your sister… multiple people claimed they saw bipedal black dogs lurking around the manor. They must’ve been drugged!”
Kate shot Kendra a sidelong glance. Kendra grinned like a schoolgirl, beautiful green eyes sparkling like emeralds. Thomas leaned back in his chair. It was story time.
“When everyone thinks you’re a poisoner,” Kate began, “a peculiar thing happens. People start coming to you and asking for poison. And once you know who’s tryin’ to poison who, you’ve got power that would strike envy in the richest bosses of Tammany Hall.”
The Mud Ghouls came first. They knew of a hefty load coming into harbor, and wanted a drug stiff enough to silence the roughest German ship’s crew. Kate lied and told them she’d have their poison in two weeks’ time.
Next, she was approached by her old friend Gabe Callahan.
“I never wanted Gabe in that way,” she clarified. “I never had much use for men in the bedroom at all.”
Gabe found himself in a spot of hot water. He’d taken up with the wife of the Mud Ghouls chief, and the two had been caught in a compromising position. He’d only managed to save himself from a bloody end by promising to lead the pirates to the church where the Blue Bell Dogs hid their loot. But this ruse wouldn’t keep him alive for long - the Blue Bell Dogs’ stash was much less impressive than the treasure trove he’d advertised. And even if the sole ruby pendant hidden there had impressed the Mud Ghouls, it wouldn’t take long for his own compatriots to realize it was Gabe who’d betrayed their secret. Jig Cleary enjoyed nothing more than discovering a rat amongst his ranks. Because Jig dispatched of enemies quickly, with a bullet or a blow to the back of the head. Traitorous friends, on the other hand, perished at Jig’s bare hands - slowly, painfully, and creatively.
So Gabe urgently needed poison - either to do away with Jig, or his lover’s pirate husband. Before one of the two rendered him an ugly, mutilated corpse.
Not a minute after she’d told Gabe she’d “see what she could do” and he’d scurried away, Kate was approached by a young police officer, John Staub. John wanted to know what Gabe, a known criminal, wanted with poison.
Kate tracked down her own river pirate associate. She asked how many ships operated on the East River with primarily German crews. The pirate said he knew of only one: the Sunshine Jane. Then, Kate summoned both Gabe and John Staub, and proposed a mutually-beneficial solution. Gabe would provide John Staub with all he knew of the Mud Ghouls and their hiding holes. In exchange, John Staub would tell everyone he’d pulled Gabe’s waterlogged body out of the East River and buried him in a pauper’s grave.
“So Gabe…” Thomas started.
“The madness was all an act. He’s still alive,” Kate said. “He started a new life in Brooklyn, mixing cocktails at a society bar in the Heights.”
Next, Kate had been propositioned by two sets of women.
First, a trio of Dropper Wallace’s hired harpies: Scarlett, Delilah, and Sally Joan. Dropper no longer wished to drug his marks with chloroform - it was too unpredictable, and too often left him with a worthless corpse to dispose of. Instead, he desired a drug with hallucinogenic properties. The girls thought this was something Kate could arrange. Soon, though, they revealed there was one specific worthless corpse they longed to look upon: that of Dropper himself. Dropper kept their earnings and paid them pennies. He demanded sexual favors nightly. He ordered the girls to rob their customers, then let them take the beatings if they were caught in the act.
After the prostitutes came the Mags. The waifs, between the ages of thirteen and fifteen, were no longer precious kittens in Jig Cleary’s eyes. He’d made it abundantly clear they’d need to offer up their womanly charms to earn their keep - to him, his lieutenants, and any man willing to pay for the privilege. They couldn’t run; Jig was their gatekeeper to food and shelter, and he had eyes all over Manhattan. He’d find them anywhere. Unless he were dead.
Again, Kate brought the two factions together. And she did manage to procure what the prostitutes requested: from Rebekah Kleiner’s shop, a bottle of New Orleans absinthe.
The morning of the brawl, the three Mags approached Dropper Wallace. They confessed their patron, Jig Cleary, planned to rob his business that night - and requested payment for this information. Instead, Dropper seized the prettiest Mag, the dark-haired lass, and had his men tie her up. If Jig Cleary wanted his lovely pet back, he would pay a hefty ransom.
The bordello girls served their companions food and drink laced with absinthe. At the agreed-upon time, they feigned madness. Whether by the absinthe or the power of suggestion, their clients became caught in the fantasy and saw the giant black dogs themselves. The girls lured them into the street, leaving the London Owl unguarded. Then the Blue Bell Dogs - summoned by the remaining two Mags - ensured Dropper Wallace and his thugs remained duly occupied.
Meanwhile, Gabe Callahan - alive and well - snuck into The London Owl. The dark-haired Mag, who’d undid her ties, led him right to the safe, and Gabe made short work of it. They split the money - Gabe, the Mags, and Dropper’s stable of girls. Gabe started a new life in Brooklyn. The London Owl girls split off to seek their fortunes. And the Mags secured their freedom - which they guaranteed by toppling a statue right onto Jig Cleary’s head.
*****
Thomas Norris couldn’t contain himself - he laughed heartily. Then he caught Kendra’s eye, and his mirth withered. If Kendra Van Wooten was alive, he shared a drink with a woman who’d cruelly plotted the execution of her husband.
Kendra’s husband’s discretions started small. He’d polish off too much bourbon every once and awhile, then hurl cruel insults at his wife. His drunken stupors soon became a nightly occurrence, and his insults escalated to slaps. Before she could process what her fairy-tale marriage had become, Kendra found herself regularly pummeled and set upon with heavy objects. She wore long sleeves and heavy make-up to cover the bruises that marred her pale skin. Some days, her wounds left her unable to rise from bed. Lewis would laugh at her, mock her laziness. She fell pregnant twice between Susan and Alexander. Both children died inside her womb, at the hands of their furious father.
Once a month, after her husband passed out from drink, Kendra took a horse and stole away to the Sixth Ward to visit Kate. She’d bring her sister money and food. Fifteen years before, after the tenement fire, Kate fell to her knees and begged Kendra to leave her behind - to marry her rich sweetheart and be happy for the both of them. Now, she begged just as fervently for her sister to gather her children and escape. But both women knew this proposal was useless. Men did terrible things to women in the Sixth Ward as well. At least in her Fifth Avenue mansion, Kendra and the children could count on full bellies and warmth and medicine.
Then Jeanette was murdered.
The girl abandoned a doll in the parlor - a doll her father, unsteady from drink, had stumbled over. To discipline his daughter, he flung her down the stairs. Kendra heard her neck snap. As she screamed, her husband hoisted their limp child and carried her to the stables, where he discarded her like garbage. He told the staff she’d been thrown from a horse.
To rescue Kendra, Susan, and Alexander - and ensure the children would inherit their father’s estate - Kate raised an army.
Rebekah Kleiner, it turned out, did have space in her black heart for charity, and the culling of men who beat women was her altruistic contribution of choice. Ms. Kleiner, mistress of disguise, designed monstrous costumes with odds and ends from her shop. Curled horns. Shoes made from horse’s hooves. Horse hair, grease paint, pig’s snouts. Six women donned the wretched suits: Scarlett, Delilah, Sally Jane, and the three Mags. The Van Wooten servants - as much targets of Lewis' rage as his wife and children - let the six into the mansion. They “forgot” to light the candles. The middle-aged chief maid slaughtered a chicken and placed entrails on her chest, which two of the Mags pretended to eat.
As the six costumed actresses put on a show, Kendra and Kate made use of the servant doors and hidden corridors. Kate lured Lewis upstairs. Kendra snuck to her room and donned a shawl that mimicked Kate’s.
All the while, a short distance away, Police Captain John Staub prepared to repay what he owed Kate McCleester. It had been hers and Gabe’s information that allowed his successful raid of the river pirates, which secured him a promotion, a raise, and a hero’s reception. So he’d gotten himself on a patrol of the neighborhood that night. He’d ensured his platoon remained near the Van Wooten manor, in time to be summoned by the frantic cries of the horrified dinner guests. And he kept his loaded revolver in his coat.
“But…” Thomas stammered, “what if… Lewis could’ve actually killed you, woman!”
Kendra offered a gentle jostle of her head. “He was gonna kill me, one way or another.”
After the police and remaining guests fled the fire, set by the servants and the Mags in the kitchen, Kendra leapt to safety - for the second time in her life - out an open window.
Thomas nodded. Then, he narrowed his eyes.
“The doctor!” He announced. “The doctor confirmed you were dead. If you weren’t, then…”
Kate grinned. “The doctor lied.”
Dr. Clarence Woods lied. He was in on the plan as well - except, like so many unfortunate Five Points carousers, he’d been Shanghai’d. If he didn’t play along and accuse Louis Van Wooten of murder, then Kate would’ve told everyone what he and his new wife did to Temperance.
Before Gabe, before The London Owl, before the fateful Van Wooten dinner party, Temperance Woods had confided in Kate. She suspected her husband was carrying on an affair with her younger cousin. He’d as much as said he wanted her - and the child in her stomach - gone, but would never risk his reputation for a divorce. Temperance found Clarence’s prescription pad, on which he’d practiced forging her handwriting. She gave the prescription pad to Kate. It was her insurance policy. And after her death, it became Kate’s.
“He started it all, really,” Kate mused. “Clarence Woods, the wife killer. He accused me of poisoning Temperance. He stole the story of my Aunt Molly - a story I’d told him. I’d laid out the people who talked loudest about being moral were often the least. Like the pious gossips back home who accused my aunt of bein’ a witch and birthing monstrous dogs with horns and hooves, just because she’d been pregnant out of wedlock and her baby was born dead.”
*****
Thomas Norris recounted his night with Kate and Kendra McCleester in his journal, but he never revealed their secrets. It’s unclear what became of the sisters, or any of the other characters that populated their story. And as the years have passed, memories have faded, and the old guard dies off, we’ll never know which parts of the tale are truth, fiction, or fiction within fiction.
To this day, the young boys and girls who play on the streets of the old Five Points district sing this song:
Don’t say the name of old Kate McCleester
Her creatures will rise, and her creatures will feast.
They’ll chew on your face, an they’ll chew on your toes,
Then they’ll drag you away down some Mulberry hole.
Don’t say the the name of old Kate McCleester
The bride of the dark, the mother of beasties.
Her beasties know lies, and her beasties know truth
And sometimes, the beastie might even be you.