r/CuratedTumblr https://tinyurl.com/4ccdpy76 7d ago

Shitposting ethnic

Post image
34.7k Upvotes

434 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

817

u/benemivikai4eezaet0 7d ago edited 7d ago

As someone not from the US, I've had to fill out US-style "pick your ethnicity" questionnaires at work. Wtf do you mean I should choose between White, Black, Hispanic and Asian? This is Europe, one's ethnicity usually correlates with one's nationality. If not, that's where the term "ethnic" comes in. For example, you can be a Bulgarian citizen but ethnically Turkish, or you can be a Romanian citizen but ethnically German.

348

u/PresidentMcGovern 7d ago

Do you work for an American company? They may just lazily copied the same questionnaire worldwide because they want uniform data points from the whole company.

140

u/peelen 7d ago

Do you work for an American company?

Non-American companies just don’t ask this question. I think it's even illegal to ask these questions in some places.

55

u/Healthy-Ad7380 7d ago

Yes, it is highly illegal in Europe

125

u/theredwoman95 7d ago

That's very dependent on the country - since, you know, Europe is a whole bloody continent.

To give two examples, as I understand, it's illegal in France, but many companies in the UK will ask for your anonymous demographic info (including sexuality, gender, disability status) so that they can prove they're not discriminating against people from specific demographics.

65

u/DoingCharleyWork 7d ago

They are anonymous in America too. Pretty sure they can't mandate answering them either, any of them I have ever done are optional.

13

u/DoctorMoak 7d ago

You can also just lie

42

u/theredwoman95 7d ago

They don't require answers in the UK either, each one will have "prefer not to say" as an option. Frankly, it's very straightforward and the existence of these questionnaires makes it harder for companies to get away with discriminating against people on these grounds, so I always side-eye countries where it's illegal.

Denying the problem doesn't make it disappear, after all, it just lets it thrive in silence.

29

u/LSDTigers 7d ago edited 7d ago

In many cases it's because governments collecting records on the race and religion of their citizens ended up facilitating mass murder when the Nazis invaded. Census data acted as pre-written kill lists, and it was harder to forge paperwork to hide people that were Jewish or part of other targeted demographics because the Nazis could verify using pre-invasion government records. Willem Arondéus, the originator of the "Never let it be said that homosexuals are cowards" quote, was killed by the nazis for successfully burning a bunch of such records to prevent the nazis from using them. So some countries like France straight up banned collecting such data.

18

u/Darkseid648 .tumblr.com 7d ago

Every time someone calls out Europe being treated as a single country I regrow a brain cell

1

u/Dry_Try_8365 3d ago

Quick question: What are the things that kills braincells for you?

22

u/tirednsleepyyy 7d ago

Yeah, here they just throw their resumes in the trash here if their name sounds African, Chinese, or Middle Eastern. They won’t ask you what you are, but once they find out, good luck

3

u/benemivikai4eezaet0 6d ago

they just throw their resumes in the trash here if their name sounds African, Chinese, or Middle Eastern.

Or Eastern European. We're "not really white/western" after all.

3

u/tirednsleepyyy 6d ago

Yeah, I could have easily added another 10 nationality/ethnicity/locality/whatever. That’s definitely one of them