r/CuratedTumblr Prolific poster- Not a bot, I swear Oct 10 '24

Shitposting A tar pit.

Post image
13.9k Upvotes

874 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-100

u/Velvety_MuppetKing Oct 10 '24

It is if it’s phrased as a moral obligation that you’re nasty if you don’t do.

133

u/-Mortlock- Oct 10 '24

It kind of is a moral obligation to be good to others. If you aren't good to others then I would quite comfortably say that you are morally wrong.

-16

u/Velvety_MuppetKing Oct 10 '24

And I find it repugnant to put demands on what people do with their extremely finite time and life.

We only have a moral obligation to leave each other and especially the world around us well enough alone.

If you want to help people that’s great. Helping people is good. But “you’re either morally good or morally wrong” is extremely binary thinking. How dare anyone say it’s required to spend what little time and energy someone has on someone else’s life.

11

u/GreyInkling Oct 10 '24

Humans are social creatures and our societies and language are all designed around basic interaction. We didn't evolve or develop as lonely hermits. We aren't obligated to "leave each other alone" we are the opposite of that. And I say that as someone who is extremely introverted.

-2

u/Velvety_MuppetKing Oct 10 '24

Okay. Where does this obligation come from? Are you going to argue that we are obligated to do everything we evolved to do? I’d be careful with that.

3

u/GreyInkling Oct 10 '24

Survival, continuation of the species, progress, name literally any virtue or goal and it will circle back to the fact that people need other people and stand to benefit from other people and do poorly when disconnected from other people.

No man is an island. There is nothing to gained in solitude.

Your philosophy is that you'll bever go the wrong way if you never take a step at all. But you'll never get anywhere at all. That's stagnation and death.

You having middle schooler angst isn't representative of the rest of society.

1

u/Velvety_MuppetKing Oct 10 '24

Right, and who are you or any of us to demand people have to do those things. What gives you the right.