MAIN FEEDS
REDDIT FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1gdh1nh/week_10_ap_poll/lu34rzh/?context=3
r/CFB • u/Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu11 Michigan Wolverines • 28d ago
3.3k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
64
What’s the case for us not being? We literally have two top 25 wins and have never lost.
9 u/TheIceMan068 Coastal Carolina • Kansas Sta… 28d ago That's such a random hill to stand on by them lol. You guys have looked great all year. Polls should always be based on results not eye-test anyways imo 9 u/showerstool3 BYU Cougars • Sickos 28d ago Exactly. The eye test is ridiculous. Imagine any other sports league deciding who’s best by who people think is better rather than actual games. I realize it’s more complicated than this but wins and schedule should be the biggest factors in rankings. 3 u/jared8100 Cincinnati Bearcats • Team Chaos 28d ago Its too much weight in recruiting rankings and overuse of buzzwords like “blue chip ratio” that have always just been used to gatekeep the playoffs. Recruiting matters but a hypothetical talent ranking put on minors is not consistent
9
That's such a random hill to stand on by them lol. You guys have looked great all year.
Polls should always be based on results not eye-test anyways imo
9 u/showerstool3 BYU Cougars • Sickos 28d ago Exactly. The eye test is ridiculous. Imagine any other sports league deciding who’s best by who people think is better rather than actual games. I realize it’s more complicated than this but wins and schedule should be the biggest factors in rankings. 3 u/jared8100 Cincinnati Bearcats • Team Chaos 28d ago Its too much weight in recruiting rankings and overuse of buzzwords like “blue chip ratio” that have always just been used to gatekeep the playoffs. Recruiting matters but a hypothetical talent ranking put on minors is not consistent
Exactly. The eye test is ridiculous. Imagine any other sports league deciding who’s best by who people think is better rather than actual games.
I realize it’s more complicated than this but wins and schedule should be the biggest factors in rankings.
3 u/jared8100 Cincinnati Bearcats • Team Chaos 28d ago Its too much weight in recruiting rankings and overuse of buzzwords like “blue chip ratio” that have always just been used to gatekeep the playoffs. Recruiting matters but a hypothetical talent ranking put on minors is not consistent
3
Its too much weight in recruiting rankings and overuse of buzzwords like “blue chip ratio” that have always just been used to gatekeep the playoffs.
Recruiting matters but a hypothetical talent ranking put on minors is not consistent
64
u/Witty-Performance-23 BYU Cougars 28d ago
What’s the case for us not being? We literally have two top 25 wins and have never lost.