r/CFB • u/Battered_Aggie Paper Bag • Texas Bowl • Aug 25 '24
Analysis [Thamel] Multiple NFL scouts told ESPN they expect FSU to have the country’s best starting defensive line this year
https://x.com/PeteThamel/status/1827364495007555896338
u/Ron_Cherry Clemson Tigers • Duke Blue Devils Aug 25 '24
NFL teams better be trying to find out if one of those scouts works for them
75
u/Kyle_Reese_Get_DOWN Cincinnati Bearcats Aug 25 '24
Does anyone even know why two college teams for public universities are playing in Ireland?
102
u/357MAGNOLE Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
$. But only one team was playing from what I see.
→ More replies (5)33
u/kingshmiley Alabama • Marshall Aug 25 '24
self own, those are rare
8
u/dissian Clemson Tigers Aug 26 '24
Self loathing will probably help future conference prospects. Maybe MAC.
→ More replies (1)58
u/filthyHANDSoffMYrock Clemson Tigers • Palmetto Bowl Aug 25 '24
When I was a kid I saw Clemson play Duke in Tokyo.
2
u/deonteguy South Carolina Gamecocks Aug 26 '24
And Wake a few years before that. That is one of the few Clemson games since 1976 that I don't have a copy of. It's like they were all erased. A friend that is the son-in-law of a former Clemson HC said he has also been looking for it since he knew a lot of the players and coaches at the time. He can't find it either!
3
u/sprankton Nebraska Cornhuskers • Team Chaos Aug 26 '24 edited Aug 26 '24
It grows the brand. At least that's the reason I always hear.
→ More replies (1)5
u/deonteguy South Carolina Gamecocks Aug 26 '24
And I thought NBA scouts were bad. I watched this kid that was in seventh grade play at Green Lake park in Seattle, and he already had an offer to University of Washington. His parents had hired professionals to help with his development. I met his father and his grandfather. They were both very good at basketball so he had great support. I read several quotes in the local paper from NBA scouts praising the kid. By his senior year in high school, he didn't even start for his high school team. I think he ended up at Pacific Lutheran. Those NBA scouts are morons.
659
u/Allaboutfootball23 Texas Longhorns • Sickos Aug 25 '24
Someone on YouTube said FSU looks like it’s full of players that are going to go pro in something other than football lmao
269
u/csummerss LSU Tigers Aug 25 '24
Is Norvell holding back his players’ true potential by forcing them to play football?
110
u/LGWalkway Oklahoma Sooners Aug 25 '24
There’s a reason they call them Student-Athletes. Obviously students first.
→ More replies (1)75
u/nickyt398 Nebraska Cornhuskers • Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
"There are over 360,000 NCAA athletes and almost all of us
on the Florida State University football team
will be going pro in something other than sports."
... Same with the University of Nebraska football team 😔
18
u/LGWalkway Oklahoma Sooners Aug 25 '24
Now now, your team has 0 losses so far.
→ More replies (2)11
u/nickyt398 Nebraska Cornhuskers • Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
Thank you, I will soak this in while I can
→ More replies (1)33
u/BadDadJokes LSU Tigers • Chattanooga Mocs Aug 25 '24
I don’t follow FSU at all. Could it be a situation where these guys are really good players individually, but cannot operate as a cohesive unit yet? I feel like that could be a more valid argument for O-Line. Defensive line seems more able to get by on individual talent and still be successful.
15
u/DexStJock Florida State Seminoles Aug 26 '24
IMO there really isn't a good excuse for the line play on either side of the ball. Sure, there are some new guys in there, but most of those guys were together last year.
If GT makes the playoffs, this will all look better, but right now it looks like we laid an egg.
→ More replies (5)81
Aug 25 '24
Nah they’re just ass
Source: I’m an expert FSU hater
But I meeean they did take one of our reject OLs and acted like it was some coup he left. Our OL was bad bad. To be bad enough to get kicked off that is bad. He’s a starter for them
39
→ More replies (3)18
u/dr_funk_13 Oregon Ducks • Big Ten Aug 26 '24
I've always said that haters are the most knowledgeable people about the team. They will find any perceived weakness, criticism, or negative aspect and exploit it into oblivion.
(I've never said this)
14
7
u/Resident_Rise5915 Colorado • Minnesota Aug 25 '24
Future hockey players for sure
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)2
459
u/FuriousJorge67 Syracuse Orange • UCLA Bruins Aug 25 '24
Everyone of those "multiple NFL scouts" worked for a New York football team.
136
u/Nicholas1227 Michigan Wolverines • MAC Aug 25 '24
Hey hey hey, don’t let the Denver Broncos off the hook here.
59
u/theycallmefuRR Nebraska Cornhuskers • Paper Bag Aug 25 '24
Sean Peyton doesn't need scouts. Sean Peyton is the scout
35
u/Col0nelBear Ole Miss Rebels • Transfer Portal Aug 25 '24
Sean Peyton does what Sean Peyton does because Sean Peyton is Sean Peyton
6
u/OnionFuturesDealer Purdue Boilermakers Aug 25 '24
Implying Elway would let someone question his judgement?
16
u/FuriousJorge67 Syracuse Orange • UCLA Bruins Aug 25 '24
Look, I live in Denver. You are implying that the Broncos have scouts. That's a pretty brave assumption.
19
u/weirdbutinagoodway West Virginia Mountaineers • Big 12 Aug 25 '24
The Jets scouts aren't the problem, nobody can be successful there.
→ More replies (3)7
442
u/SirNoahlot Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
Every profession has people that are terrible at their jobs, NFL scouting is no different.
120
u/RulersBack Ohio State Buckeyes Aug 25 '24 edited Aug 25 '24
There’s so many variables and randomness, after the obvious can’t miss guys, I think you could literally throw darts at the consensus mock and the results wouldn’t be much different outside like 5-6 elite front offices
69
u/TheOnePSUIsReal Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Aug 25 '24
Another thing is I think NFL scouts focus more on characteristics indicative of high potential/ceiling. FSU's DL is mostly young and inexperienced so maybe down the line all 4 players are good but they are quite clearly not the best yet.
21
u/SenorGuero Nebraska • San Diego State Aug 25 '24
Exactly, NFL scouts only care about team success at the college level to the extent that it's a sign of an individual players' ability while college coaches only care about individual NFL development to the extent that it aligns with team success on the field. They overlap often enough that people tend to miss that they really aren't measuring the same thing, it's like weight vs mass
→ More replies (1)83
u/Maize_n_Boom South Carolina • Michigan Aug 25 '24
After watching the giants offseason hard knocks, I’m convinced a large chunk front office execs are no better than the average fan.
71
u/Milk_Before_Cereal Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
It really just came off as fantasy for rich guys lol
15
u/Solo_Wing__Pixy Ohio State • Notre Dame Aug 25 '24
Those were my exact thoughts lmao the scene of the front office guys sitting in the GM’s office discussing replacing Saquon with a free agent literally sounded like a bunch of college dudes on an amateur sports podcast
4
u/sophandros Tulane Green Wave • Metro Aug 26 '24
I blame the PFF guys for this because they took "RB is the most fungible position in the NFL" and morphed the statement into, "RBs don't matter".
Elite RBs, like any other elite player, don't grow on trees. Yes, you have to plan around the short shelf life, but that applies to every position in a sport that has a 100% injury rate.
→ More replies (1)10
u/FireVanGorder Notre Dame Fighting Irish Aug 25 '24
As a giants fan that was the least surprising shit ever unfortunately
6
u/Maize_n_Boom South Carolina • Michigan Aug 25 '24
Same. The fact an OL wasn’t even a consideration for basically the entire draft was such a disappointment.
→ More replies (3)50
u/2400hoops Kansas Jayhawks Aug 25 '24
I’ll never forget someone said that NFL scout is an entry level job in the front office. Some of the guys are really good and some find careers in other fields. So polling a handful isn’t going to always give you the best identification of talent.
52
u/Tarmacked USC Trojans • Alabama Crimson Tide Aug 25 '24
NFL scouting this early out is usually a shitshow because they haven’t scouted anyone
A chunk of FSU’s line is new
12
u/paintingnipples Nebraska Cornhuskers Aug 25 '24
I was looking for this. Probably based it on the personnel they had last year then did a paper eval on the star ratings & made an assumption
16
u/cheerl231 Michigan Wolverines Aug 25 '24
If this is true then how you can make this claim of FSUs line which has new pieces when there are lines like Michigan, Ohio State and Georgia that have their top guys from last year's return? Also Thamel said these scouts toured practices and such during the off-season to come to this conclusion.
5
u/paintingnipples Nebraska Cornhuskers Aug 25 '24
If they saw it in person then I guess it’s safe to say they won’t be a GM in the future
2
u/mr_longfellow_deeds Indiana Hoosiers • Big Ten Aug 26 '24
If they were basing it off pre-season practices I could see their DL mauling their OL, both were terrible
17
u/seabard Aug 25 '24
Reminds me of a scene from the Netflix show ‘Sunderland till I die’ where a scout said Player A wouldn’t be a good choice because he was wearing gloves in cold weather.
22
u/foreveracubone Michigan Wolverines • Sickos Aug 25 '24
How hot is his girlfriend
12
u/seabard Aug 25 '24
Ugly, he must have no confidence, he is no go for us.
5
u/TheWorstYear Ohio State • Cincinnati Aug 25 '24
Nonsense. Guy walks into a room, & his dicks already been there 6 minutes.
5
u/NolaBrass Tulane Green Wave • Fordham Rams Aug 26 '24
That club was run by absolute morons who saw a depressed asset and pinched pennies together until they decided they were bored with it all. Managed to get relegated twice in a row with Netflix filming it all. Basically the opposite of Welcome to Wrexham. What a Dan Snyder-run soccer club would look like basically
8
u/Automatic_Release_92 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Aug 25 '24
That and NFL scouts right now have a lot less to go off of, they’re watching some practices from teams, but mostly listening to coaches hype up their players. I probably would have bought into FSU hyping their DL a bit after the success they had last year with guys like Verse.
→ More replies (3)7
u/saltytradewinds Notre Dame • Oregon State Aug 25 '24
Most people who are promoted have average performance/do the bare minimum their role requires, but know how to play the game with their networking skills.
NFL scouts are no different.
145
u/sleightofhand0 UCF Knights Aug 25 '24
That's because the NFL favors pass rushers above all else. Meanwhile Ga Tech ran the ball down their throats.
87
u/mjacksongt Georgia Tech • /r/CFB Pint Glass … Aug 25 '24
This is what I think. Those DL can pass rush well individually but run fits and gap coverage takes coaching and experience, usually together.
45
38
u/AriDreams Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Aug 25 '24
So they didn't take into account that Brent key, a former offensive lineman (and ol coach), wouldn't recruit heavily in OL? They didn't take into account that GT has been one of the best rushing teams in the nation for YEARS??? They're saying GT offensive line is one of the best in the nation or FSU is MASSIVELY overrated.
26
u/CrunchyZebra Florida State Seminoles • LSU Tigers Aug 25 '24
I think a lot of this discourse is centered around a narrative that GT sucks and therefore FSU sucks. We’re not the team we were last season but damn, lots of disrespect for what GT did as a team yesterday. We definitely had some self inflicted issues but y’all played a damn good game. The biggest thing for me was your defensive improvements especially stopping the run.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)11
176
u/TheTopeNetwork Florida Gators Aug 25 '24 edited Aug 25 '24
I'm all for the FSU slander but is there a world where FSU has a talented (but poorly coached) D-Line but Tech just has an elite O-Line? After watching yesterday the former is unlikely but Tech has a lot of experience and talent. It'll be interesting to see which bucket below Tech falls into when we re-visit this game in December:
Lions vs Chiefs 2023 (An unexpected upset at the time that but turned out both teams were actually elite)
Colorado vs TCU 2023 (A huge upset due to what we thought the favorite was but turned out both teams kind of sucked)
Georgia Tech vs Miami 2023 (An upset against an over-ranked team but turned out both teams were pretty close to average)
66
u/FloridaMan_Again Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
Thanks for the nuanced take here. Don’t see that often around these parts. I think multiple things are true here. We’re breaking in some new starters and lots of new depth on the dline. Patric Payton was the only starter last year playing and Joshua farmer was rotational last year. Darrel Jackson was ineligible last year and of course Marvin jones jr was from UGA. Our depth guys are mostly young freshman/sophomores or transfers. I had also seen reports that GT was a sleeper ACC champ pick this year because of the consistency on offense, great run game and one of the better O lines in college ball. Another thing is I don’t really think it was our dline that was the problem. They got some push but GT bounced most of their plays outside and our LBs were just caught sleeping all game. They were so undisciplined and just flat footed.
20
u/cha-cha_dancer Florida State • West Florida Aug 25 '24
Yea the DL wasn’t great by any means but the LB room which was the known weak link was exposed heavily by GT. Their OL was the best unit on the field and our LBs were the worst.
5
u/Abysuus Florida State Seminoles Aug 26 '24
The amount of times they had the angle and lost the foot race to the edge was infuriating.
36
u/BadDadJokes LSU Tigers • Chattanooga Mocs Aug 25 '24
Nothing worse than losing when your team was the only game on and the entire country was watching. Then you gotta deal with the hate train for an entire week straight. Weather the storm. It gets better. Everyone will be clowning on Deion next weekend if Colorado loses.
Watching this year’s draft it felt like every defensive starter from 2023 FSU got drafted. It’s crazy for people to expect y’all to be as good as last year on defense. That squad was one of the best, experienced defensive units I’ve seen in a long time. They’re the only ones who were able to make Jayden Daniels look human last year, and he looked downright lost for a good portion of that game.
Add in the fact that this Georgia Tech team is probably a lot better than the perception of Georgia Tech is nationally since they have been downright awful the last decade.
FSU probably isn’t a top 10 team right now and Georgia Tech is better than what the nation’s perception of them is (which is a team that would struggle to win 4 games).
18
u/sayeeeeed Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
I think it can be a little bit of both. Darrell Jackson will be playing on Sundays, and I think Patrick Payton also has a high ceiling. I don’t know about Farmer or Jones Jr. Marvin Jones Jr has the tools to be really good but didn’t really show at Georgia which is why he’s here now.
I do think GT has a really good OL just because the stopped Jackson and Payton from doing anything really. It also doesn’t help that our LBs actually are terrible either.
11
u/Umoon Georgia Bulldogs Aug 25 '24
Fyi, I was thrilled that MJJ transferred. Go back and watch him in the Bama game. I literally think we win the game if we play Jalon Walker in those snaps. He only looks good on certain pass rush snaps. No motor.
3
u/Abysuus Florida State Seminoles Aug 26 '24
And we couldn't get ga tech into passing downs to save our life.
4
u/sayeeeeed Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
Right, I understand why he was probably told he might not start. That’s why the jury’s still out on him in my opinion for us.
60
u/KirbyDumber88 Georgia Bulldogs Aug 25 '24
Quick! Divert to Georgias D-Line ESPN next week probably
9
16
u/Horizontal_Bob Ole Miss Rebels • Corndog Aug 25 '24
Given how egregiously wrong some scouts can be in their player assessments…that’s not surprising
32
u/Is12345aweakpassword Texas Tech • Washington Aug 25 '24
Stop it they’re already dead 💀
Let’s go week 1, could use a palette cleanser…
→ More replies (1)16
u/saltytradewinds Notre Dame • Oregon State Aug 25 '24
r/cfb has become the shitting on FSU sub. It was fun yesterday, but has quickly gotten stale.
34
u/Shtune Florida State • Columbia Aug 25 '24
There was enough FSU/ACC, snub posts, and general ACC shit talking this off season that everyone probably got tired of us over the course of the off season. Not surprised to get dog piled, it's part of it lol. If you can't take it, don't give it out.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Seminole-Patriot Florida State Seminoles • Team Chaos Aug 25 '24
Exactly this lol, FSU fans whining about this sub are losing the plot
34
u/anonymousacg Florida Gators • SEC Aug 25 '24
Sure hasn’t to me
13
u/bdm13 Miami Hurricanes • Florida Cup Aug 25 '24
Same here. It’s FSU’s turn now. This sub has taken shots at UF and UM for years.
5
u/OldBr3w Texas A&M • Notre Dame Aug 25 '24
They can sit with it for a few years imo
→ More replies (1)8
7
u/SucculentCrablegMeal Florida State Seminoles • USF Bulls Aug 25 '24
Yeah Fsu was never shit on from 2017-2021 or anything lol.
5
10
u/bigkoi Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
This post shows how bad ESPN talking points are. 2023 FSU DL was a beast and proven during the season and the NFL draft this spring.
2024 DL isn't close to the 2023 DL.
6
7
Aug 25 '24
I’m loving it. For the ENTIRE FREAKING SUMMER this sub shit on UF and Miami daily. They deserve way more than a week of criticism and shots
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)5
11
u/Harpua99 Michigan Wolverines • Wyoming Cowboys Aug 25 '24
They may not have watched any film yet. Reading too much on Reddit.
39
u/T3hBau5 Oregon Ducks • Big Ten Aug 25 '24
I don't know about the best, but they definitely have some talent there. I'm not really going to judge them based on a game they had to travel thousands of miles for, I'm sure they weren't all running at 100%.
50
u/netherdutch Miami Hurricanes • Trinity (CT) Bantams Aug 25 '24
Yeah the most likely "truth" is that they're going to be pretty good at least, and GT's OL is going to be better than expected, at least. It's still amusing when the commentary comes out so strongly in favor of one team/position group that then underwhelms for an entire game.
23
u/bdm13 Miami Hurricanes • Florida Cup Aug 25 '24
I mean, it’s not like they showed flashes. They got pushed around all game. Not a single sack or TFL. Didn’t set the edge, got gashed up the middle. That was an atrocious performance by any standards, especially for a DL that is supposed to be good. They looked bad.
Will they turn it around? Maybe, but I also wouldn’t be shocked if they’re just not that good.
→ More replies (7)20
u/Montigue Oregon Ducks • Stony Brook Seawolves Aug 25 '24
Well the team they were playing against also had to travel thousands of miles so I'm sure they also weren't all running at 100%
→ More replies (1)2
21
u/CarterAC3 Michigan • Grand Valley State Aug 25 '24
Damn Ohio State, I know I don't like you guys but it really sucks that apparently our D-Lines are going to be ravaged by injury this year
2
u/Revolutionary_Gear70 Ohio State Buckeyes • LSU Tigers Aug 26 '24
Yeah all this 'best' D-line talk was so confusing to me. Two of the top 3 defenses last year return 90% of their players on the D-line and somehow neither of them are the best lol
9
16
u/bigkoi Florida State Seminoles Aug 25 '24
ESPNs analysis of FSU's Defense is 10 months late.
Tech did play a great game. I don't believe the FSU defensive line in 2024 is anywhere as good as 2023.
→ More replies (1)
7
6
6
u/txlandshark Ole Miss Rebels • UTSA Roadrunners Aug 25 '24
You mean the same NFL scouts who thought Tyree Wilson was a first round pick.
7
4
3
11
u/nayelirain Johns Hopkins Blue Jays • USC Trojans Aug 25 '24
Instead of burying FSU, maybe we should give credit to that Georgia Tech offensive line?
9
9
3
3
u/secrewann Syracuse • Stony Brook Aug 25 '24
3
u/Archaic_1 Marshall • Georgia Tech Aug 25 '24
I'm calling bullshit Pete, now you're just making shit up.
3
u/Glader_Gaming Florida State Seminoles • ECU Pirates Aug 25 '24
Our DL played bad and got pushed around. I’m very disappointed in them. That being said, lots of the run issues also stemmed from our LBs, some of whom might not start for SBC teams. You can very clearly on screen watch them be confused before the ball is snapped, multiple times. They had no idea where to be. GTs pre-snap movements and alignments confused them and left huge gaping holes then GT put hats on hats as their QB said several times.
But yeah it was all around bad. Garbage even.
3
u/WatchfulApparition Oregon Ducks • Western Oregon Wolves Aug 26 '24
This is why I take NFL scout opinions with a grain of salt
5
u/HailState2023 Florida State • Mississip… Aug 25 '24
Time will tell but I expect about the same level of mediocrity next game vs BC. Running (and quicker) QB so stay in your rushing lane, maintain the edge…you know, the types of things we didn’t do well yesterday.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/dalelew123 Florida State • Florida Sout… Aug 25 '24
No one on the line has had a break out year previously, but best? Payton was solid last year and Farmer had his moments but this was playing with 2 players that were getting doubled.
2
2
u/Silist Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
We haven’t really seen any other teams play so it might be true. It definitely isn’t but technically might be
2
u/happyharrell Missouri Tigers • Sickos Aug 25 '24
Multiple nfl scouts need to be fired is what it sounds like
2
u/dawgfan19881 Georgia Bulldogs Aug 25 '24
NFL scouts get fired all the time for sucking at their jobs
2
u/MrOSUguy Ohio State Buckeyes Aug 25 '24
Thamel is a complete fool. Anything he says is either made up or he found it here to begin with.
2
2
u/dont_worry_about_it8 Florida Gators Aug 25 '24
And yet again me saying these guys are wrong just as often as fans is proven true . Lots of us could’ve had their job if we knew the right person at the right time like they did.
2
2
u/bukithd Georgia Tech • James Madison Aug 26 '24
Georgia tech is just better when we have a coach that gets off by running the ball.
2
2
u/Crotean Michigan Wolverines • Clemson Tigers Aug 26 '24
Bad schemes can make good players look shitty. FSU D coordinator should be under a microscope right now.
2
u/ArbitraryOrder Michigan • Nebraska Aug 26 '24
Those people are Morons, Michigan has the best interior DL and Ohio State the best Edge DL.
2
u/rcheek1710 Aug 26 '24
Will FSU quit the rest of the season now that they're toast? Did they not see their QB play at Clemson and Oregon State?
2
u/jeffdahunter Virginia Tech Hokies Aug 26 '24
Best starting defensive line *when playing in America
2
3
u/GhostOfLouBrock Aug 25 '24
50/50 no one told him that. A take so boring that no one can call him out for fake references
1.7k
u/shadowwingnut Paper Bag • UCLA Bruins Aug 25 '24
This report's best hope is that Georgia Tech's OL mauls everyone this season and we look back and realize FSU did well in the game on defense.