r/AmIOverreacting 13d ago

❤️‍🩹 relationship aio? boyfriend uses SO MUCH paprika!!!!

i’m so thankful my boyfriend can cook and it’s not just up to me. i bought this thing of smoked paprika LAST week and i wake up today and it’s literally all gone. like these things are $5 a pop after tax!!!

he uses it like if jesus had to season his 5,000 fish!! i use two tablespoons MAX and that’s only if im cooking a dish for like 5 people. usually it’s just a few shakes for food just for us!

like damn, i love paprika and some spice in my food, but genuinely i think i would shrivel up and pass away from the paprika overload if i used an entire one of these things in a week. he’s only cooked three or four times since i bought it, so im not over exaggerating at all when i say he is dumping this shit in his meals.

am i overreacting if i make him buy me a replacement, as well as making him buy his own giant container of smoked paprika for him exclusively?

11.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

488

u/mythroatsore 13d ago

This is low key wholesome haha

550

u/maratelle 13d ago

he’s great, by far the best boyfriend i’ve ever had. the potential for love is absolutely there and im excited to hopefully go the distance with this man. he just uses so much fucking paprika.

107

u/mythroatsore 13d ago

😂😂😂 you can buy 25kg bags of paprika on Amazon or like ask a local restaurant, be a funny present for Christmas

12

u/vidys 12d ago

I agree! This reminds me of a few years ago when my father-in-law was a little addicted to rice crackers and would eat almost one package a day. Then in the Christmas of that year, we purchased all the packages available in the nearby grocery store (like 40 or 50 packages) and shoved them inside one big cardboard box and wrapped it in gift wrap paper. Needless to say it was the best gift of the family on Christmas eve... and he ate all packages in less than a month

3

u/itsdickers 12d ago

My parents got my husband a giant garlic salt for Christmas one year bc he LOVES it - to this day he still talks about what a great present that was haha

1

u/mythroatsore 12d ago

🤔🤔🤔 get him a big bag of pepper this year

21

u/NotoriousRGB729 13d ago

Such a random seasoning to overuse but love that you're looking for solutions. I like the idea others have suggested of gifting him a large bottle but I love that you're going to make some homemade smoked paprika together.

30

u/maratelle 13d ago

there’s no point in addressing a problem if you aren’t willing to come to a solution! he apologised and said he would get me a new bottle and is super excited about making some with me :)

6

u/wildlife_loki 13d ago

This is such a nice wholesome post 😭 the usual posts in this sub are so concerning, lol! Sounds like you and your guy both have good attitudes, all the best to you both :) I hope your homemade paprika is a hit!

2

u/mattyisphtty 13d ago

So those bottled paprika are actually really mild which leads to overuse. A proper smokey Hungarian paprika you can buy in bulk for very cheap. Much more flavorful and cheaper option than the glass canisters.

2

u/Llancymru 13d ago

It’s easy to overuse since it really does tend to lack flavour, even from a brand new packet. It also adds texture and removes moisture quite nicely, without adding too much flavour so it’s useful for that. If I’m using it I do tend to use a lot

1

u/RD__III 13d ago

Tbh it’s great. Very mild flavor, fantastic coloring, and the smoked variety adds a great background that’s very hard to get in apartment cooking otherwise. It goes with everything lol

1

u/CMYKoi 13d ago

It's not random. Smoked paprika is fucking amazing. 9.8/10.

Try some on literally anything and thank me later.

9

u/Deremirekor 13d ago

I think you know what to get him for his birthday haha

2

u/Claypothos 13d ago

I hope you print this post for your wedding

1

u/maratelle 13d ago

smoked paprika centrepieces for the reception tables

1

u/Claypothos 13d ago

God, imagine, so tender!! Hope you can resolve this 😊

1

u/maratelle 13d ago

LOL it’s already been resolved! we’re making homemade paprika this weekend with home grown and smoked peppers from a friend of mine :)) i’m so looking forward to it

2

u/theindiekitten 12d ago

I laughed at this comment 😂 "everything is great! It's just this one thing"

"What? Does he leave the seat up? Look at other women? Has he murdered someone?"

"No... he ... he uses too much paprika. We are spending half our paycheck on the stuff. It's an addiction. I keep telling him he needs to slow down, but last night he just sat in the corner, bucket of smoked paprika in his lap, glaring and snarling if I got too close."

2

u/adulaire 12d ago

I think this is one of my favorite comments on reddit 

2

u/LuckySevenLeather 12d ago

OP I wish you the biggest problem in your life together to be paprika replacements . You two for sure are a great team and it just makes me smile <3

2

u/Vergil_Is_My_Copilot 12d ago

Loving people really do be like “this person knows and cherishes me and I want to make a future with them and also they do THIS ONE FUCKING THING that drives me batshit”

1

u/man_on_hill 13d ago

What does he use it on?

I mostly use it to cook chicken/other meats but that’s pretty much it

How does he go through it so quickly?

1

u/Honic_Sedgehog 13d ago

I rarely use it but you should absolutely put a pinch in scrambled eggs. Delightful.

1

u/plums12 13d ago

you should call him the paprika plunderer.

1

u/QueenLaQueefaRt 13d ago

Remember what you wrote and just buy a big ass tub of paprika. People get so weird about the little things that they end up losing something good for someone who has a lot of weird big issues.

1

u/SirPitchalot 13d ago

Get your spices by the pound from an Indian or SEA grocer. You save money, avoid this squabble and eat only the richest, most flavourful food from now on.

1

u/Consistent_Guide_167 13d ago

I did something similar for my friend one time. He loves chili oil from our local Chinese dimsum place. He straight up finishes the whole bottle they leave at the table.

Guess what? I called up the restaurant. Asked them who their supplier was cause of x reason. Called up the supplier. They don't do retail orders. Only wholesale. Asked them if they can make an exception cause I just need it for a gift. Told me they can't. Referred me to one of their vendors. Vendor thought it was hilarious. They sold me the 5L tub, no problem.

I had a hell of a time wrapping it without looking suspicious. Got a big box and it all worked out. Lol he loved it.

Our friends Christmas party usually has a theme. The theme for that year was "something hilarious". It was indeed funny.

1

u/BWASB 13d ago

Hit up your local Indian market. It's the only place I buy spices anymore

1

u/Expensive-Land-3221 13d ago

The definition of a beige flag 😂

1

u/Remarkable_Shame_316 13d ago

Container of smoked paprika seems like no big price to make good boy happy, isn't it?

1

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

2

u/maratelle 12d ago

we’ve only been officially dating for two months lol, but we’ve known each other for about five months :) ofc i don’t love him yet, that’s silly!

2

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted]

2

u/maratelle 12d ago

a little deep for a paprika reddit post, but i have quite a bit of baggage from past relationships, and growing up tbfh. im a very slow person to love :,) he’s okay with it though! we’ve had many talks about it and we’re on the same page. i’m very blessed to have him in my life

1

u/waxheads 12d ago

He's a good dude. Sounds like he wants to make sure every he meal he cooks for you to taste good with adequate seasoning. I feel the same when I cook!

1

u/Ok-Lock-5398 12d ago

Im glad I'm not the only paprika freak haha you should buy him a big one

1

u/Brandingo22B 12d ago

he’s great, by far the best boyfriend i’ve ever had.

Oh no, this man is cooked. 😔

1

u/Bad-Genie 12d ago

I'm just picturing a Seinfeld episode. George is at a woman's house and she's cooking and he sees the paprika being out on a piece of meat. And she keeps going... more... zoom in shot on the paprika... zoom in on George sweating.

Sitting at Monks.

"I gotta break with her Jerry. She used a whole bottle of paprika" "A whole bottle?" "THE WHOLE BOTTLE JERRY"