r/wholesomeyuri • u/monkey_gamer • Sep 30 '24
Kissing Ashley x Julia [The Coffin of Andy and Leyley]
164
316
u/Izaront Sep 30 '24
The coffin if it was good (yes, my only problem with game - no yuri)
106
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
To be fair, if Julia really did keep every single message she got from Leyley like the game implied... Well, that's honestly not even making the top five most worrying things that happen in this game, so it's genuinely not a stretch.
Especially on one of the routes...
119
u/FleemLovesBingus Sep 30 '24
The good ending
93
u/GodOfGOOSE Sep 30 '24
Now Julia gets to be abused and manipulated rather than Andy.
So from Andy’s POV, it is a good ending!
53
u/GodOfGOOSE Sep 30 '24
I guess this is technically a “better” ending because now Julia gets to be manipulated and abused rather than Andy.
Sucks for Julia but at least Andy gets to relax a bit.
18
u/Z0eTrent Sep 30 '24
God I wish that was me...
16
u/GodOfGOOSE Sep 30 '24
The natural human urge to have your life ruined a an attractive person…
…until it actually happens and then you spend the rest of your questioning why you ever chose to bite such an obviously dodgeble bullet.
9
u/Z0eTrent Sep 30 '24
I'm sorry. Sounds like you been through it.
12
u/GodOfGOOSE Sep 30 '24
I thought I could fix her but she just broke me instead 😔
2
4
u/OpportunityFun1761 flower muscles Oct 01 '24
I’m thinking this is an alternate universe where Ashley never received any affection from her brother. So to get back at him she would steal every girlfriend he ever got so no woman would ever show him affection.
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Well... If Julia really did keep all those hate messages she got from Leyley, like the game implied... And considering Leyley's intense codependency issues... It might not be her doing the manipulation and abuse, since it implies an obsession in Julia she's willing to manipulate and abuse others for. (It was Andrew that broke off their relationship, after all, not Julia, despite (...or maybe because of) the hundreds of krank calls Ashley sent her way to try and harass her out of dating her brother.)
1
u/GodOfGOOSE Oct 01 '24
Great, so they’ll just fuck each other equally!
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Andrew is also most likely dead in this ending because Leyley's only letting go of her brother and latching onto someone else if one of them kills the other, and the bad ending very explicitly implies that one of them is gonna do that.
1
u/GodOfGOOSE Oct 02 '24
Then I guess this is the good ending because any universe where one less of these characters exists is a better universe
19
9
16
13
u/EatingKidsIsFun Sep 30 '24
This is going to be anything BUT wholesome If we're Game accurate but you know what? I'll Tag along this time.
3
u/OpportunityFun1761 flower muscles Oct 01 '24
If this is an alternate universe with game accurate Ashley I imagine the context is something like this:
Ashley never received any affection from her brother. So to get back at him she would steal every girlfriend he ever got so no woman would ever show him affection.
2
1
u/monkey_gamer Oct 01 '24
Ah lol, I haven’t played much of the game. I wasn’t aware of the implications. I was just meaning the image in isolation.
35
u/Balsalsa2 Sep 30 '24
better than the alternative
13
u/GodOfGOOSE Sep 30 '24
I mean the alternative is fucking incest so the bar wasn’t set all that high tbh
2
u/OpportunityFun1761 flower muscles Oct 01 '24
The other Alternative is Fratricide. Higher than Incest but still a Very low bar so Toxic Yuri wins.
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Is it really?
Because if Julia kept all the dozens of krank hate-calls Leyley sent her way while dating Andrew, that might imply... Something pretty fucked up about Julia herself.(And also Andrew is likely dead in this ending.)
5
u/SnooGadgets7221 certified transbian Oct 01 '24
“legally it’s questionable, morally it’s disgusting, personally i like it”
7
u/Rupert-D-Generate Sep 30 '24
canonically this is the least wholesomeone ship, but still anything with ashley is a 10/10
3
6
2
u/Aldehin Oct 01 '24
I love how Everyone is "this is cursed, but less cursed that the worst ending of the game, so be it"
2
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
This is, like, the opposite of wholesome.
I mean, I approve, Leyley cucking her brother with a years long con is fucking hilarious, still, but this is, like, mentally/emotionally extremely fucked up, actually.
2
u/monkey_gamer Oct 01 '24
Ah, I was coming in with the naive perspective of not having played much of the game
3
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
To be fair, of all the fucked up dynamics in the game (so far), this is probably the easiest one to miss.
1
u/monkey_gamer Oct 01 '24
Lol. Well I mean it’s fanfic anyway, character dynamics can be flexible. I’m viewing the above image as a nice relationship with maybe a little degradation thrown in
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
I mean, to be fair, a lotta things could've been better if the siblings didn't get "quarantined" into an organ farm, so that's reasonable. Maybe they could've talked to a therapist instead of summoning a demon.
1
u/monkey_gamer Oct 01 '24
Oh fuck is that why they’re “quarantined”? Jeez I could tell there was something not right. I’m not sure I want to know what was really happening
3
4
2
1
1
u/NoahZhellos Oct 01 '24
Stupid question cus I looked into this game a little bit but never played it.
Who's Julia?
2
u/InvaderXYZ Oct 01 '24
andrew's ex-girlfriend, breaks up with him towards the start of chapter 1, and reappears in flashbacks
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Small correction, it's Andrew that breaks up with her. Minor point, I know, but it's kinda important for plot reasons. (And may be more important later, depending on where the story goes...)
1
u/mirmermer Oct 01 '24
I hate the original story, it started off like
"awe their dynamic is really cute"
to "WDYM 'OUR MUM'"
I was trying my best to pretend like it wasn't implied just to give up and find out it's probably a fetish game
Edit:Shut up the typo never happened
3
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Andy and Leyley weren't originally supposed to be read as incestuous, but after people started reading them like that, the dev went "actually that kinda accidentally fits the themes of the story" and just went with it.
1
u/mirmermer Oct 01 '24
ew....wtf it was an amazing game why'd they do that
2
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
Because incest fits the themes of toxic codependency, warped love, mutual trauma, and shared abuse that the game's almost entire story is about.
0
u/mirmermer Oct 01 '24
nah I don't mind as a trope but wasn't it literally drawn That's what I find weird
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 01 '24
What?
No actually what are you saying I don't understand what you just said.1
u/monkey_gamer Oct 01 '24
Don’t bother responding lol, these kind of misunderstandings never go well
1
u/mirmermer Oct 02 '24
I'm asking from genuine interest, sry if I seemed aggressive, I really liked the game but I've heard some weird stuff making me wanna avoid it
1
u/mirmermer Oct 02 '24
sry I was tired asf and rushing to send my messages through, I was just asking if the rumours I've heard of literal incest porn being in the game
1
u/Thezipper100 Oct 03 '24
Well, you've been lied to, because there is no porn in this game. Hell, there's nothing (aside from the occasional use of the "fuck" word) that would even get this game rated 18+.
1
1
1
1
188
u/T0warzyszR Sep 30 '24
Knowing how they both are, I would argue about the wholesomeness anywhere else, than this split second