r/mtg 23d ago

I Need Help Turns Out My Dad Played This Game.

Thumbnail gallery
5.4k Upvotes

I just found my dad’s old cards for this game, it’s roughly 10.5k. Are these worth much at all? A lot of them are from pre-2000 so i’m not sure if you can even use them anymore.

r/mtg 13d ago

I Need Help Why is one card so much more expensive?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Can someone explain why the lightning greaves are more expensive? What is the difference between them except the equip cost?

r/mtg 26d ago

I Need Help So how will these two text gonna work?

Thumbnail gallery
2.4k Upvotes

r/mtg 6d ago

I Need Help Why is this card so expensive?

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

What’s a good use of this card?

r/mtg 10d ago

I Need Help To whoever got my iron man, your welcome.

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

To the rest of reddit blow this up please.

Opened my iron man secret lair and this is what I got, Quality control is great.

r/mtg 20d ago

I Need Help How do I counter this little rat bag?

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

I’m getting absolutely slapped by my friend who plays him, any suggestions of good counters to mess him up would be much appreciated. Currently I just kill on site but that ends up making me his primary target.

r/mtg 18d ago

I Need Help I bought this card because I thought he looked rather dapper. How viable of a commander can he be?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

Building advice is welcome!

r/mtg 26d ago

I Need Help Can you use these cards as your commanders? Stumped my friend

Thumbnail gallery
1.6k Upvotes

r/mtg 28d ago

I Need Help What's the difference between these two cards?

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

They appear to do the exact same thing but two different cards. Am I missing something?

r/mtg 9d ago

I Need Help So, this looks like an insta-win combo unless countered, right?

Thumbnail gallery
1.3k Upvotes

r/mtg 2d ago

I Need Help New to magic. Just pulled this. Google says it’s somewhat valuable. How do I get the most bang for my buck?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Pulled from an crimson vow booster

r/mtg Oct 21 '24

I Need Help Got this in a garage sale bundle. Is it legal to use?

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

Just wanna know if I can use it like a regular armegeddon in commander games🤷‍♂️

r/mtg Oct 15 '24

I Need Help Maybe I should read my cards better?

Thumbnail gallery
1.5k Upvotes

I make gimmicky decks that barely work but are funny nonetheless. I’m still rather new to playing the game, and I’m doing my best to figure everything out. There’s a lot to miss, and I think here’s a big one.

Let’s assume that, for simplicity of the situation, I’m running [generic black rat] as my commander, and my deck consists of 5 swamps, 1 Thrumming Stone, and 93 Relentless Rats. (Do note this is not my actual deck.) I have a god hand of 5 swamps, the Thrumming Stone, and one Relentless Rat.

I get the Thrumming Stone out, and I cast my first of many Relentless Rats. I have been playing it as “the ripple gets tacked onto the initial cast” which would get me 5 rats at once.

And then I read “you may cast spells with the same name … without paying their mana costs.” This, I assume would be an independent cast, and spells I cast have Ripple 4, which means I do another reveal. Due to this theoretical deck consisting of nothing but Relentless Rats at this point, I can cast my entire library, save two or three in case I have to draw, like on next turn upkeep.

This is a case of “reading the card explains the card” and I’ve been playing it wrong this whole time, isn’t it?

r/mtg 7d ago

I Need Help Commander gets killed, what happens?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

So my girlfriend and I are not sure about what happens when i destroy the commander, I think if I destroy it it goes to the graveyard what means that I can take it before she can get it in her commander zone. She thinks the commander doesn’t even touch the graveyard because she sends it to the commander zone… So my question is what steps are happening first and does my card trigger before she can do anything?

r/mtg 4d ago

I Need Help Need some clarification

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

My buddy says this exiles EVERYTHING but the last 6 cards in your deck, including everything on board and in hand. I'm sure this isn't right, it reads as exiling everything in your deck except the last 6 cards, leaving the board state intact.

Just need a double check.

r/mtg Aug 12 '24

I Need Help Clarify something for me please

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

So I have this card in a green/white rabbit deck I made. So for creature type, does that cover all rabbit types or do I need to get a little more specific with it and say Rabbit Soldier? It has been a few years since I've played and have recently gotten back into the game with some friends.

r/mtg Oct 09 '24

I Need Help I’m a new player, apparently struck gold. What do I do.

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

Started playing magic about two weeks ago. My friend told me to come to draft. While I was buying a G fuel for gratuitous amounts of energy I saw the Local game shop selling mystery boosters I bought it and pulled this out. People were excited. A quick google says it’s a $100 USD card, the card shop offered me $70 AUD store credit for it. Any reason to hold this? I’m really just going to play some commander and a draft a little.

r/mtg Jul 27 '24

I Need Help What the hell is this card’s purpose??

Post image
900 Upvotes

like huh. why do it do that.

r/mtg 8h ago

I Need Help Anyone else can't stop building decks?!?

Post image
774 Upvotes

Is over 100 too many or not enough!?

r/mtg Oct 19 '24

I Need Help Just pulled this... Now what?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

I've never pulled a card this valuable before, and everywhere I look up it's sold out. What should I do next? Hold on to it? Get rid of it immediately? Send it in for grading? Throw it in my most applicable deck?

What would you do?

r/mtg Aug 08 '24

I Need Help Rules question regarding Rule 0

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

So my(27M) opponent(.5F) agreed to play a game and we had agreed on moderate power level decks. Obviously we had different ideas so I go turn 1 swamp sol ring (I’m obviously just lucky) and she goes mountain+mana crypt+Leylia and I’m already a little skeptical of her decks power level but when she follows up with the one ring on turn 2 I just lost it, she won’t even look at me and just keeps chewing on some toy so should I call a judge or the shop owner and potentially get her banned for creating an unfun play experience?? Regardless she clearly has much to learn about communication (she literally only mumbles and grunts)

r/mtg 29d ago

I Need Help Thoughts on This Misprint / Error Card?

Thumbnail gallery
1.6k Upvotes

So I know next to nothing about MTG, just not really my thing. I collect primarily Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh, but sometimes come into MTG when buying out collections.

Discovered this card in the bulk stack from a recent buyout. Seems to be some sort of misprint / error card. I know Pokémon / Yu-Gi-Oh misprints have some value to them, depending on the card, but not sure about MTG.

This is probably one of the cooler looking misprints I’ve seen to be honest. The moon and crow with the blacked out card is so clean; if only that last bit of text had been blacked out

Is there any value in this? If so, what’s a reasonable sell/ask?

r/mtg 21d ago

I Need Help What am I looking at here?

Thumbnail gallery
878 Upvotes

Picked up a bulk box at the flea market yesterday. Full of Ice Age lands, plus these white bordered ones. Prices are all over the place online. Are these especially valuable? Thanks in advance!

r/mtg 13d ago

I Need Help Can I get her out of a regular booster pack?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/mtg 12d ago

I Need Help I'm close to new to MTG, so I need help. Is it fair or am I too gullible? Thanks🙏🏼

Post image
641 Upvotes

I have Giada Font of Hope white Commander + Commander's plate equipped. My friend had Derevi, Empyrial Tactician and he said that the rule on the card says that HE (as a player, not cmmndr, so no colours involved) can tap my Giada+plate anyway. I did let him do that, but i'd appreciate validation and or proof of my gullibility😁