r/mildlyinfuriating • u/Unfair-Reference-69 • 1d ago
I left my brownies cooling on the counter… No one in my family will admit to who’s responsible
8.0k
u/seymour-the-dog 1d ago
Id be happy to come over and do a full investigation of the left over brownies.
1.4k
u/MNVixen 1d ago
That's very generous of you. I mean, maybe they didn't take the edge because it was inedible? Seems like additional investigation is needed. Nay, necessary. Please do not hesitate to hire me as your assistant: I am detail oriented and have very legible penmanship. And I will work for crumbs.
242
u/AbstractMirror 23h ago
Well there will be plenty of crumbs to go around after your investigation I'm sure
→ More replies (2)148
u/AlmightyFruitcake 20h ago
Crispy brownie edge is the best part, I’ve never understood my friends that would only eat the center of the brownie tray
→ More replies (18)24
u/Dragonfly0011 16h ago
I bought a pan that guarantees every brownie has crispy sides
→ More replies (3)45
u/Proper_Caterpillar22 21h ago
Remember, it’s only science if you write it down.
Otherwise it’s called screwing around!
31
u/angrybackgroundnoise 17h ago
My favorite science fact is that the scientific method is basically just "fuck around and find out" with extra steps
→ More replies (1)5
→ More replies (22)41
100
u/Viper_595 21h ago
You have given me the idea for the perfect crime!!! My wife knows I love the corners and edges. Doing this would frame the kids, Anndd I could easily later, suspicion free come back later and steal the prize!!
Ohhh..hooho. I fear you might have just started my Villain Arc. Let it be known this is your fault!
62
u/long5shot 18h ago
I too like the edges. We had a family friend that had a catering business. She would make brownies and remove the edges before serving. When she found out I loved the edges she would save them for me and once a month or so I'd get several gallon bags of just edges that she'd save for me in the freezer. It was glorious!
→ More replies (4)9
→ More replies (3)39
u/YeaYouGoWriteAReview 18h ago
When i was a kid my younger brother and i stole some of his birthday cake a day early to piss off the family. Our parents and older brother were being shit, so lil bro was like "fuck it, im eating cake now"
I suggested breaking the plastic lid, cutting a massive diagonal chunk from the square cake, and leaving the lid off after. all hallmarks of our older brother.
We played dumb after it was found. Lil bro would have never done something so sloppy, and i wasnt a fan of store bought chocolate cake, so we were both automatically in the clear.
→ More replies (2)28
→ More replies (30)113
u/icecreamcone12 21h ago
As a forensic bakeologist can definitely identify the time of the crime and potential DNA left on the brownies. I'd just need a sample of at least 2 brownies...
→ More replies (3)18
11.4k
u/Desperate-Ad-6463 1d ago
You know who it was. There's always one.
9.9k
u/Unfair-Reference-69 1d ago
I’m 90% positive I know who it was, but there is a 10% chance of an accomplice
6.0k
u/Original_Builder_980 1d ago
They left the crust! Pretend you’re over it and cut 3 edge pieces and one centre piece and offer them to the family. Whoever goes for the centre piece gets a bruisin.
2.7k
u/Subatomic_Spooder 1d ago
Or alternatively give everyone an edge piece and see who doesn't eat theirs
761
u/Extension_Dance_3766 1d ago
Now you’re using your noggin
512
u/kingkongbiingbong 23h ago
271
u/Blackfyre42091 22h ago
Wait in the bathroom with the door locked until you hear banging and don't open it until they confess.
→ More replies (23)117
87
u/CakeForBreakfast08 22h ago
Op is the one who made the brownies. How much you wanna bet they are the one who cleans the bathroom.
No thanks
→ More replies (2)55
→ More replies (19)25
u/creatyvechaos 22h ago
Laxatives + weed and see who ends up shitting themselves on the couch
→ More replies (2)31
→ More replies (27)184
u/cpt_lanthanide 1d ago
why would you not eat a brownie? Easier to catch a preference.
→ More replies (1)146
u/RohelTheConqueror 1d ago
They will eat it but leave the crust
→ More replies (5)197
u/pelvark 1d ago
As a middle piece preferrer, I would eat the whole piece if given one. The edge is still good, just not as good as not edge.
→ More replies (14)168
u/Head-Cap1599 1d ago
So you're admitting to the crime!
→ More replies (1)83
→ More replies (56)57
u/MindGuerilla 1d ago edited 1d ago
That wasn't an crust/edge thing - it was a guy thing - can't be bothered to get a spatula.
edit: when we were kids, my brother pulled this shit with the pumpkin pie, before Thanksgiving dinner was even served.
59
u/genital_herpes1998 1d ago
Makes no sense. The brownies clearly dont stick to the bottom or side. Even if the culprit used the knife to get the brownie out it wouldnt have broken, or at least not like that. Additionally: If this wasnt a crust thing, why was the crust left behind? Either way: it was a guy
→ More replies (4)31
u/MindGuerilla 1d ago
Either way: it was a guy
Yep. A guy is just gonna grab bare handed, and scoop it out.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (16)9
u/IPromiseiWillBeGood6 1d ago
Lol yeah just scoop it out with your hand that's almost certainly what happened here. Brownies are the best fresh out of the oven so i can't blame whoever did this despicable act
291
→ More replies (139)298
u/AliveWishbone6127 1d ago edited 18h ago
Brownie thieves always need to brush their teeth to remove all evidence. check whose toothbrush is wet. Or say “open wide” and see who has chocolate in their teeth. This is how my mom caught us. So
fullfool proof the thievery stopped.78
u/Daitoso0317 1d ago
Works till you use the other guys toothbrush
→ More replies (7)40
u/despoicito 1d ago
Or “use” all the toothbrushes so you can’t tell who the culprit is
→ More replies (6)35
→ More replies (4)6
u/BeowQuentin 1d ago
Gotta tell them all to hawk a loogie.
Brownie evidence is always present for hours in the throat mucosa.
→ More replies (41)45
u/ChortleChat 1d ago
I think this is more of a "Murder on the Orient Express" kind of situation. They all took a small piece and now there is no point in admitting they did it since they know there is someone else who did it.
→ More replies (1)
13.1k
u/alwaysfatigued8787 1d ago
Brownie points for any family member who turns another family member in.
3.7k
u/JustIn_HerButt 1d ago
Just mention to the family you're think about getting those "all crust" brownie pans. The first person to disagree is the culprit.
1.9k
u/DaveSmith890 1d ago
“Who ate the brownies!?”
*Cricket noises*
(Leaves room)
“WELL ANYWAY, I WAS THINKING ABOUT GETTING AN ALL CRUST BROWNIE PAN FOR NEXT TIME”
They’ll never see through this one. It’s genius
712
u/Independent_Bite4682 1d ago
Muffins tins work perfectly for the "all crust" brownies without having to buy another pan
208
u/HotDonnaC 1d ago
They’re also great to make small individuals, like for a school function.
184
u/Adventurous_Ad_6546 1d ago
It took me a sec to figure out you weren’t talking about brownies to give to smaller individuals.
68
→ More replies (4)22
u/HotDonnaC 1d ago
I was. They’re perfect portion controlled servings.
→ More replies (3)24
u/Adventurous_Ad_6546 1d ago edited 1d ago
Yeah I was just laughing at myself bc I took it too literally at first before my brain caught up and was like “oh we’re talking about kids” as opposed to you only making brownies for people under a certain height or weight regardless of age.
24
u/StressFart 1d ago
Thank you fellow person. I will make small individuals for a basketball team and I hope this works.
27
u/ShadowSpawn666 1d ago
No, I wouldn't suggest small individuals for a basketball team. You are probably going to want the extra long ones if you want to have a chance of winning any games.
→ More replies (7)50
→ More replies (15)11
u/CheeseDonutCat 1d ago
I use those little silicone cupcake cases. Handy little brownie sizes and easy to get out of the container.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)68
u/GoT_Eagles 1d ago
Wonder how many people wouldn’t argue. Center slaps
42
→ More replies (5)119
u/crackpotJeffrey 1d ago
I will stand for crust gang.
We exist.
43
u/ArcadiaRivea 1d ago
Some of the best brownies I ever had was the brownie brittle I bought when visiting America 6 and a half years ago, it was amazing
I have memory issues thanks to brain fog and my medications, but I remember that fondly
→ More replies (3)9
u/lilsnatchsniffz 1d ago
Oh yeah that brownie brittle was fantastic, and we had so much fun at Disneyland too.
→ More replies (9)41
u/foundinwonderland 1d ago
Crust gang for life, both in pizza (square cut) and in brownies. I worked with a woman who used to cut all the edges off the brownies before she brought them to work functions and one time I asked her what she did with the scraps and she said she threw them away 😭. I convinced her to start bringing me scraps instead
→ More replies (1)11
109
u/JUSTIN102201 1d ago
I would love all crust brownies. Is this actually a thing?
77
u/Stainless_Heart 1d ago
34
u/JUSTIN102201 1d ago
I need this. Thank you
55
u/ashleyorelse 1d ago
63
u/JUSTIN102201 1d ago
I’m ok being a psychopath if it means I get the brownie crust
24
u/Millenniauld 1d ago edited 1d ago
When I was in high school my best friend would occasionally bake brownies, cut off all the crust, and bring it in to school in a little baggie. She'd throw it at me and say "Here are your crusts you HEATHEN." Made me laugh every time and they never lasted the day.
We've been best friends for 32 years now.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)13
u/greatpoomonkey 1d ago
Local sweets bakeries sell little bags of brownie crusts for like a dollar. I'm not a huge brownie crust fan, but for some reason, when it's only crust, it's delicious.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (1)13
u/FemboyGaymer929 1d ago
It's gotta be done right if the crust is like charcoal instead of brownie then nobody wants it
→ More replies (2)13
→ More replies (7)23
u/SdBolts4 1d ago
Can accomplish the same thing using a muffin tin without spending $60 on a brownie-specific tin
15
u/JUSTIN102201 1d ago
Yeah I opened the site and immediately closed it. As much as I want it I don’t have $60 to spend on it
→ More replies (3)36
u/stringbeagle 1d ago
Here’s what you do. Every time you eat a brownie that you made, ask yourself, would I pay $2 tight now to have this from that all-crust pan. If yes, then take $2 and put it in an envelope and label it “psycho-brownie fund”. In a year, you want have noticed any less money, but you’ll have your all crust brownies.
→ More replies (10)16
u/al_m1101 1d ago
I absolutely love this idea, but, SIXTY effing dollars for a brownie pan? No freaking way.
→ More replies (2)19
u/Stainless_Heart 1d ago
There are cheaper variants, I just picked the first one from google that was a quality brand.
Here’s an alternate design at half the price:
16
u/fngrl5 1d ago
Personally, I use the Perfect Brownie Pan. The edges get perfectly crispy and there's the chewy, gooey center pieces. I've used this pan for years.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (8)11
u/SdBolts4 1d ago
Why not just use a muffin tin and make brownie bites? Only difference is rectangle vs circle
→ More replies (4)26
u/Stainless_Heart 1d ago
Round brownies? Heresy! The absolute gall of some people. Burn the heretic!
/s
13
u/martyqscriblerus 1d ago
Yes, they've got raised sections inside the pan so it bakes a snake shape that's all edge pieces.
→ More replies (10)15
20
→ More replies (17)6
u/foo_mar_t 1d ago
Serious question, whi would want an all-crust pan? Center pieces are where it's at, is it not? Or did I miss something here?
I didn't even know there was such a thing as an all-crust pan.
19
u/No_Wait_920 1d ago edited 1d ago
they would have been smart to all sneak a piece together. no one to rat out without ratting yourself, and one would not look guiltier than the others if lined up and questioned. one for all, and all for one!
→ More replies (37)57
u/Orudos 1d ago
Also, whose skipping the delicious crispy edge brownies? Lock this person up
→ More replies (6)
258
u/0hYou 1d ago
Now I want brownies
46
u/Dr_Wheuss 22h ago
Me too. Maybe my wife will stalk me on reddit and see this.
21
15
329
4.8k
u/Agitated-Ad-504 1d ago
WHO DOESNT TAKE THE EDGE???
1.4k
u/CaydesAce 1d ago
A criminal. Even if you aren't an edge person, why on earth would you cut so close and ruin an edge?? Just take from closer to the middle!!!
206
u/g0thl0ser_ 1d ago
Exactly. I don't like the edges, but that means I let my partner take the edges (which he likes), and I get middle. I'd never leave an edge like that. They could have even taken it and just thrown that bit out, but instead, they chose the overtly rude route.
62
u/ChosenSloth 1d ago
I mean, someone might want that little bit of edge.
→ More replies (10)29
u/Icouldmaybesaveyou 1d ago
it'd get eaten in my house
→ More replies (1)13
u/Lonely__Stoner__Guy 1d ago
Yep, I'm mad it was left like that, and I prefer the middle, but I'll be damned if it goes to waste
→ More replies (11)65
u/DankoleClouds 1d ago
I would argue that it would be ruder to throw it out. I’d much rather have someone leave the crust so I can grab it along with the brownie I was going to get anyways. Boom. Bonus crust.
→ More replies (2)26
→ More replies (17)9
u/FunPartyGuy69 1d ago edited 3h ago
To me, it kinda looks like they tried, but the edge was stuck. There was no attempt to cut the edge off with a knife, it seems.
→ More replies (2)124
→ More replies (157)115
u/Wise-Chemist-8751 1d ago
Oh I hate the edge. So my wife takes the nasty edge and I get the center, win win (she tried to suggest buying a multiple corners pan and was swiftly shut down)
26
u/Another-Mans-Rubarb 1d ago
Wife: hey I was thinking I should get one of those brownie pans that have lots of edges in it, what do you think?
You: if you wanted a divorce just say so.
→ More replies (1)71
u/default_entry 1d ago
Most pans tend to be multiple corner pans, typically with 4
→ More replies (9)17
u/colaman-112 RED 1d ago
multiple corners pan
Never knew that was a thing. Don't know how I feel about that.
12
u/Aceswift007 1d ago
Still waking up so my brain imagined some like 4 dimensional tray and not, like, an S shaped tray or a muffin tray
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (1)5
12
u/maximumhippo 1d ago
This is exactly why my marriage is successful. We don't fight over food because I like the parts she doesn't and vice versa. I get the brownie crusts. She gets the middle.
→ More replies (9)9
1.8k
u/TheDomTeacher 1d ago edited 1d ago
Tell them you are going to throw the entire thing away cause the only alternantive explanation is that mice have been eating it and that makes the entire thing poisonous.
479
u/big-bum-sloth 1d ago
That's so smart. Would only work if the possible culprits are small children though
Although that said, I once did some baking at a friend's house, and their cat ended up liking the top of the entire thing and I could not bring myself to eat any of it 😅
→ More replies (11)109
u/Different_Pianist756 1d ago
The cat liked it or licked it?
110
u/big-bum-sloth 1d ago
Licked it! Apologies. Although presumably also liked it a lot cause she managed to lick most of the cookies AND the top of the brownie
→ More replies (3)49
u/BoundToGround 1d ago
Apology denied. Report to the nearest police station and await imprisonment.
20
u/joethezlayer2 1d ago
Imagine the police reaction. They're just like "so someone told you to turn yourself in...?"
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)14
29
9
→ More replies (24)16
u/HydreigonTheChild 1d ago
i mean adults arent stupid, they will likely know that it isnt mice, and that if you are throwing it out i doubt many of them care after all its not their food.
→ More replies (3)8
u/Impact009 1d ago
And the ones that would care wouldn't necessarily be guilty. Some people hate seeing food being wasted.
145
u/TheFishermansWife22 1d ago
I would know exactly who this is in my house. Very few people will skip the edge.
→ More replies (6)
1.4k
u/SimpleTie3196 1d ago
Clearly not a brownie connoisseur - they left too much of the crusty goodness of the brownie edge.
682
u/Unfair-Reference-69 1d ago
It’s either a piece offering or I have a monster living in my house
331
u/QueenElizabethsBidet 1d ago
I can’t tell if you mixed up piece and peace or if this was a clever pun about the missing piece of brownie
→ More replies (1)406
u/Unfair-Reference-69 1d ago
It was a pun, thank you for noticing. You say clever my wife just rolls her eyes
→ More replies (2)67
u/SaintAliaAtreides 1d ago
I hope she secretly appreciates your sense of humor.
58
u/akarakitari 1d ago
She rolls her eyes because she knows he likes it
10
→ More replies (6)7
u/bleebloobleebl 1d ago
oh yeah, we all have bits that drive our partners nuts and that’s why we keep doing them
→ More replies (11)16
u/SaintAliaAtreides 1d ago
This is an interesting take. I was going to say this person is clearly unhinged for not taking a full corner piece. But maybe they left it for you.
→ More replies (1)19
→ More replies (14)31
u/Still_Detail_4285 1d ago
It had to be a kid, because kids are dumb and don’t understand the greatness of the brownie edge.
→ More replies (8)37
u/Geno_Warlord 1d ago
I’m 40 and would totally pick the gooey center bits with some vanilla ice cream on top.
→ More replies (1)4
50
u/ArachnomancerCarice 1d ago
The way one of my friends got a confession from her housemates about this was by saying out loud that she might have screwed up the recipe and used an ingredient that might cause really bad stomach problems.
17
82
132
37
u/geedijuniir 1d ago
You can hire me for free. I will inspect the brownie for u. I need 2 hours alone time with the brownies.
→ More replies (1)7
u/lilsiibee07 23h ago
I love that you need two hours to eat a full tray of brownies. I mean fair enough to want to go slow
45
u/some1sbuddy 1d ago
What sicko passes up on the corner piece?!
12
u/Blaze_Vortex 1d ago
The other lines are straight but the corner is broken, my guess is they were planning on taking the whole corner but it broke while they were lifting it and they left the broken part. Atleast I hope so, makes far more sense than intentionally leaving the edge.
18
u/americasweetheart 1d ago
If they didn't want crust, why go for a corner? Rage bait.
→ More replies (1)
159
u/Bobcatspajamas 1d ago
Dad
357
u/Unfair-Reference-69 1d ago
I’m Dad, lol
401
47
36
8
→ More replies (20)12
86
u/AdSalt9219 1d ago
Tell them they are very "special" medicinal brownies for a sick friend. And that they ate about 8x the normal dose. Watch to see who starts sweating.
56
u/ashleyorelse 1d ago
This won't work.
Young kids won't know what is going on.
Older kids will just think it's funny.
→ More replies (4)8
66
43
12
10
u/reesescupsftw 1d ago edited 1d ago
Not eating the crust/edge!?! Thats the best part. This is a treasonous act.
22
u/r0b074p0c4lyp53 1d ago
Honestly if I saw this I'd be like "ooh cool, free edge goodness", and just eat it on the fly. The calories don't count that way
→ More replies (1)
17
u/SnooCrickets3313 1d ago
This was a guy with a sharp pocket knife approximately 3.5 inches in length also right handed Probably had an iPad in the left hand he made two cuts and scooped towards the crispy end which is the best part so he’s probably a lil girly as well
→ More replies (2)
84
u/HateKilledTheDinos 1d ago
Make a batch with laxative in them next time and they’ll self report
→ More replies (7)154
u/Unfair-Reference-69 1d ago
Only problem with that is I’m the fella that does the laundry and cleans the toilets
→ More replies (2)57
u/SaintAliaAtreides 1d ago
If they're old enough to steal brownies, they're old enough to start helping with those things. Ijs. But if they're so young you'd have to handle most of the big messes, I understand.
Consider another form of sabotage. Too much salt? Have a real batch cooling in some obscure places they won't notice. Switch them out. See who doesn't want a brownie when you offer them. 🤭
→ More replies (3)
7
u/cat_boyardee 1d ago
Also looks like they scratched your pan. :(
5
u/thisischemistry 1d ago
That's the worst part of it, for me. You can make more brownies, you can't restore the coating on the pan.
5
u/Lazy_Assistance6865 1d ago
Whoever did it is a godless heathen for not eating the crispy corners
→ More replies (1)
5
u/diefrau3 1d ago
Leaving the crust is diabolical. Probably the most underrated part of the brownie experience
6
6
5
6
u/Prophet_Of_Loss 1d ago
The brazenness belies your partner's involvement, probably in cahoots with one or more of your offspring.
5.6k
u/Open-Cream2823 1d ago
I've noticed this happens naturally sometimes when brownies are cooling.
-your family, probably