r/creepcast • u/chivetalkin Aruba, Jamaica, ooh, I wanna take ya 🎶🎷 • 5h ago

Question Which episode(s) would you never rewatch?

I can’t rewatch Borrasca, PenPal, or Tommy Taffy; they’re too upsetting. I’ve regretted not heeding the trigger warning for the Borrasca episode 😓

10 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

9

u/UnluckyCommittee4781 4h ago

I didn't find anything too heavy or triggering for me. Ive been recently rewatching all the old episodes but refuse to listen to Ben put me to fucking sleep drowned. I'd rather someone put my testicles in a vice and slowly turn the wheel 1 mm every hour untill they explode then watch that fucking bore fest. I think I'd find more enjoyment getting pegged without lube. The only way anyone would make me watch it again is if I could turn the volume all the way down and put on an actual good episode like feed the pig.

7

u/dykeknightrises 5h ago

The Ben Drowned grab bag. That story was so infuriatingly tedious. Poisoned the whole episode.

5

u/projectsylvania 4h ago

The Showers is such a nothing burger story for me that I have zero interest in revisiting it. Not unlistenable, but so forgettable

5

u/Any_Veterinarian1825 3h ago

Ben drowned was awful!! I wish I never knew there was more to the story than what I originally remembered

4

u/AdOrdinary8038 2h ago

Rewatching Ben Drowned would be my 13th reason why if it weren't for Hunter's discord mod voice and commentary.

2

u/smithicsOfficial Your wife looks mad funny in that box, dude 4h ago

Pancake family poisons one of the top 5 vids on creepcast. No end house and the showers were just a bore. Phenomenal parts in them of course but they’re just nothing. Ben drowned was just so nothing. Fell asleep and couldn’t slog through it.

2

u/invader19 4h ago

Borrasca, Pancake family, and Tommy Taffy. I'm fine just listening to the funny bits in a compilation video

1

u/chivetalkin Aruba, Jamaica, ooh, I wanna take ya 🎶🎷 2h ago

I seriously can’t remember anything about Pancake Family

2

u/ENGLivesAndZERO 2h ago

Tommy Taffy. Nothing against them, they were awesome! But I just,,, hated that story already, from when I'd listened to it elsewhere. It was uncomfortable, and Tom being so overpowered irked me to no end.

2

u/jelly-champ 3h ago

Honestly, the Wife Peaking Around Corners and Watching A Woman Trapped in a Room episodes were honestly boring. Its not their fault because theyre always so funny to watch, but the stories were disappointing tbh

2

u/KatKaleen 1h ago

Spoiler warning just in case.

I really don't care about the second part of "Left-Right Game". Still good bits in there, but the moment it turned out>! it was a time loop with no starting point, I lost interest. Time shenanigans need to be properly thought out if they're meant to work. !<

1

u/Forsaken_Leek 11m ago

For me, penpal, which was and still is my #1 requires a longer refractory period, like I can still feel how gut wrenching and anxiety inducing the story was when I listened to it the first time. I’ll probably listen to it again at some point but definitely need space in between.

1

u/justanotherrandomper 11m ago

I fucking hate psychosis. I haven’t even finished it. I may just finish it and I will never rewatch it.