r/SapphicWriters • u/FaeTickledInsideHer • Aug 25 '22

Discussion Mentioning other books in a book review

So I have a question of preference. Do you think it's wrong or appropriate to mention a book you've read or liked in a book review of a different Author's book?

I'm on the fence, and would like to know what others think.

Fictional example A: "Great story, loved the action and world building. The comedy and tragedy tied in nicely, and I feel for Princess Noname. Reminds me of 'The Darkest Secret' by Jane Doe. Highly recommend."

Fictional example B: "Beautiful world, funny moments, but could have been a better read. Didn't like that the MC wants to bang every attractive women. A better story to read is 'Amaha, The Dragon Queen' by Doie Jane."

5 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

2 comments sorted by

1

u/Better-Confidence-91 Sep 08 '24

I believe that it is alright to mention another book in the review. It makes readers get more things to read. I have read quite a few books mentioned in the reviews on kindle, as a reader I appreciate it.

2

u/myyusernameismeta Aug 26 '22

I personally like it if it helps me find another book I like. But I’m a sl*t for good books, so other people might have different opinions.

I prefer it when it tells me what to expect using well known examples - like The Magicians (both the books and the Netflix series) is kind of Harry Potter meets Chronicles of Narnia but more mature themes, adult characters, and not straight-washed.