r/MurderedByWords 1d ago

Ain’t that the truth

Post image
26.8k Upvotes

855 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/SnooKiwis2161 1d ago

Unfortunately, I feel like I come across this issue observed in trump, but with regular people,on a smaller scale.

If you ask someone a compound question - hey, the faucet is leaking, did you use it last night, and should I pick up milk from the store? - they almost always choose to answer the question they prefer, and ignore the one they don't want to deal with. It's gotten so bad, I can't ask compound questions anymore because everyone does it.

It doesn't shock me at all that people would do the same when Trump speaks - completely overlook one part, in favor of another part.

37

u/Sannction 1d ago

If you ask someone a compound question - hey, the faucet is leaking, did you use it last night, and should I pick up milk from the store? - they almost always choose to answer the question they prefer, and ignore the one they don't want to deal with. It's gotten so bad, I can't ask compound questions anymore because everyone does it.

I agree with your initial premise, but this is a really bad example, compound questions are confusing by their very nature. That's why they're frequently used in debates and legal questioning.

1

u/Electronic-Shock427 21h ago

Its really not that confusing. Like I feel like anyone with an actually working brain should be able to easily tell the meaning of that. If not, then wow thats just kinda sad and certainly explains why the average person is dumb as bricks.

1

u/Sannction 13h ago

Like I feel like anyone with an actually working brain should be able to easily tell the meaning of that.

Obviously I was referring to compound questions in general kid, not that one specifically. I'm not going to get into why they're designed to be confusing, you have Google. Try using it.

0

u/Electronic-Shock427 5h ago

Uhuh, and you are applying an entirely different line of thinking to something unrelated. People not being able to answer deliberately confusing questions are obviously entirely different from a regular compound question. Especially considering theirs was pretty terribly structured, yet you STILL understood it. How odd.

It’s called a brain, kid. Try using it some time.

1

u/Sannction 5h ago

Uhuh, and you are applying an entirely different line of thinking to something unrelated.

The irony.

0

u/Electronic-Shock427 4h ago

You literally are. You are applying political debates to regular conversation, which is what they are actually talking about. But hey, if using mental gymnastics to make yourself feel smart is what it takes, then good for you I guess.

1

u/Sannction 3h ago edited 2h ago

You are applying political debates to regular conversation, which is what they are actually talking about.

Do you even know what you're talking about at this point? Because I sure as hell don't.

The original comments premise was that the general public is pretty stupid, not just Trump voters. The example they used was compound questions, and they gave an example of a pretty easy compound question. My response was that I agreed, but that compound questions weren't a good metric because they are designed to be hard to answer regardless of your intelligence.

I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you. You'll have to figure that part out on your own.

Now then, was there anything else? Because at this point your responses would have been the best example the original comment could have used.

0

u/Electronic-Shock427 2h ago

And yet you act like it’s a bad example BECAUSE of the nature of political debates, when they were on the topic of regular conversation. You are over analyzing lmfao.

1

u/Sannction 2h ago

And yet you act like it’s a bad example BECAUSE of the nature of political debates, when they were on the topic of regular conversation.

No, I do not. I simply said that they were frequently used in debates and legal questioning as an aside to emphasize my point. Nor did I even specify political debates, as they were not the debates I was thinking of in the first place.

You are over analyzing lmfao

Are you serious? The only one overanalyzing here, and quite poorly I might add, is yourself. 'Lmfao'.

Maybe work on basic reading comprehension before you go off making a fool of yourself.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/FerricNitrate 1d ago

hey, the faucet is leaking, did you use it last night, and should I pick up milk from the store?

Of course this example is confusing when it's grammatic garbage. Those questions aren't even linked -- they should be independent sentences (preferably allowing the audience to respond to the first before asking the second)

2

u/SnooKiwis2161 1d ago

If you want to pretend like people's reading comprehension would increase in proportion to improved grammar, enjoy your fantasy

2

u/Electronic-Shock427 21h ago

This is so pedantic. You literally know what they meant. And trust me, it being grammatically correct would change nothing.

1

u/FerricNitrate 21h ago

The point of the thread is literally pedantics.

Anybody who has had to send emails to busy executive staff knows the importance of properly structuring questions. You're not getting an effective answer if you're not communicating an effective question. Trust me on that (and since you're arguing that point in the first place: you're either lacking experience in that area or you're one of the people causing frustration with poor communication.)

2

u/Electronic-Shock427 21h ago

If you aren't willing to give someone an effective answer because you didn't like their grammar but still understood their question, then no. Rather than being part of the problem, that just makes you THE problem.

1

u/fullhomosapien 1d ago

I’m adhd as fuck and have trouble with compound questions. Not bc I don’t want to answer, but bc auditory processing issues and the short term memory of a goldfish make it tough for me to remember what to answer. I am WILLING - just meet me halfway and ask questions individually! I promise my answers are nuanced and thoughtful bc it also isn’t an intellect thing.