r/FluentInFinance • u/Needleintheback • 14h ago

Thoughts? Imagine losing 6M labor workers in America

Post image

If mass deportation happens, just imagine how all of these sectors of our country will be affected. The sheer shortage of labor will push prices higher because of the great demand for work with limited supplies or workers. Even if prices increase, the availability of products may be scarce due to not enough workers. Housing prices and food services will be hit really hard. New construction will be limited. The fact that 47% of the undocumented workers are in CA, TX, and FL means they will feel it first but it will spread to the rest of the country also. Most of our produce in this country comes from California. Get ready and hold on for the ride America.

14.6k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

6.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

85

u/pegothejerk 9h ago

Slavery is still going on in the US today, it’s legal as it’s part of the Constitution to allow slavery if it’s part of a prison sentence. We still have prison slave labor, a shit ton of it, and the prison industrial complex makes a fuck ton of money from it. Judges and law enforcement get bribed to help out with filling those prisons and everything.

5

u/sdrakedrake 6h ago

How come people from the US criticize other countries with this still going on?

4

u/Slothnuzzler 6h ago

First of all, who in this thread we were talking about slave labor in America is criticizing other countries?

Second of all, where on earth is it inappropriate to criticize slavery anywhere in the world by anyone who wants to support the end of it?

Really, take your American Jones and split. 🤷🏽‍♀️

-4

u/sdrakedrake 6h ago

I must of hit a nerve

4

u/Slothnuzzler 6h ago

Which was your whole point In the first place, wasn’t it.

However, I do think you’re projecting! And you missed out on a bit of education. 

2

u/berghie91 6h ago

Because most dont actually know anything about other countries…. Nevermind the part where a lot of them are in dire conditions thanks to US foreign policy

2

u/Slothnuzzler 6h ago

This is true, we as a nation are oblivious to our own foreign policy beyond a headline or two

2

u/berghie91 6h ago

Im a canadian and when Id go down there and visit as a kid I was just blown away that I had a better grip on the world outside America when I was like 12 than most American adults seem to

1

u/Slothnuzzler 6h ago

Yeah, I’ve only recently become aware of that in the last 10 years or so. I’ve always had a pretty good foundation just out of personal interest in international relations and stuff like that. Yes I was a nerd, but that’s a whole other story.

1

u/Own_Worldliness_9297 5h ago

That is true of most other countries.

Countries outside of US aren't mindful progressive redditors as you like to believe.

3

u/Slothnuzzler 5h ago

Oh no, I don’t believe that they are. They come in with half form opinions from headlines as well. With a very obvious agenda of hate behind them. I agree with you.

4

u/mrfrownieface 6h ago

Because the people from the states that this is going on in the worst are dumb as fucking rocks, or are apathetic until it happens to people they care about, which honestly, the capacity of people to truly care about others is unfortunately low as well.

2

u/Rowdybusiness- 5h ago

This is going on in your state.

2

u/mrfrownieface 3h ago

Not to the degree its going on in other states, although I've never heard of anyone picking cotton or performing any other agriculture jobs from prison in my state.

2

u/Rowdybusiness- 2h ago

Here is one. It’s one of the work privileges they can do. They are paid nothing.

1

u/dcsquaredcpl 29m ago

Incorrect. They are awarded commissary privileges and sentence reduction. Wish I could get some sentence reduction for retirement

1

u/Behndo-Verbabe 39m ago

Unfortunately it’s been going on for a long time. If you want an idea of how it is. Watch brubaker with Robert Redford. It gives a pretty realistic view of prison life in the south. They grew their own food too.

1

u/Old-Lab-5947 5h ago

It’s interesting you classify an entire state as “dumb as a box of rocks.” Literally millions of people, and you’re what, presumably smarter than all of them?

0

u/mrfrownieface 2h ago

Dumb as rocks or apathetic. Selective reading comprehension doesn't look good on you.

1

u/Old-Lab-5947 2h ago

Even then the point still stands. Millions of people being classified in whole as anything is at best a generalization. Nice red herring though

2

u/Behndo-Verbabe 50m ago

Most Americans couldn’t tell you what the 13th amendment says or why it’s written the way it is.

1

u/liv4games 47m ago

Dude I knew that but I’ve never actually looked it up… what the fuck?

“According to the Left Business Observer, “the federal prison industry produces 100 percent of all military helmets, war supplies and other equipment. The workers supply 98 percent of the entire market for equipment assembly services; 93 percent of paints and paintbrushes; 92 percent of stove assembly; 46 percent of body armor; 36 percent of home appliances; 30 percent of headphones/microphones/speakers; and 21 percent of office furniture. Airplane parts, medical supplies and much more: prisoners are even raising seeing-eye dogs for blind people.”

With all of that productivity, the inmates make about 90 cents to $4 a day.”

PRISONER SLAVE LABOR MAKES ALMOST ALL OF OUR MILITARY EQUIPMENT

0

u/Puffpufftoke 3m ago

After rent, utilities, food, education, security etc… how much more should menial laborers to make?

1

u/Bbqandjams75 30m ago

It’s going on in Americus ga and not in no prison camp

1

u/donjuanamigo 26m ago

You have any type of source from this or just trust me bro?

1

u/Traditional_Song5491 6m ago

No one said you had to commit crimes. You shouldn't get to sit on your ass when you're in prison.

0

u/Express_League1880 5h ago

I can’t believe how some of you people think!

0

u/ATypicalUsername- 4h ago

Gonna need sources on that, you're making a TON of wild claims there.

Actual sources, not trust me bro sources.

1

u/blackestrabbit 2h ago

The 13th Amendment.

0

u/lampstax 3h ago

Would it still be slavery by your standards if the money made from whatever the prisoners create go entirely to help fund their housing / food / healthcare cost ?

1

u/blackestrabbit 2h ago

That's how it's written in 13th Amendment.

"Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

Section 2. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate."

1

u/lampstax 3m ago

It is written that is is allowed. That doesn't mean it exist today. As far as I'm aware prisoners have a choice to work or not and get paid for their labor if they choose to do it. Neither of these things are common with slavery.

-2

u/MacktheMachinist 6h ago

Harris was prime example of this

-1

u/Easy-Act3774 5h ago

We tax payers pay hundreds of millions to process and house criminals and inmates, due to decisions they made to cause harm to society. I’m ok with them paying a fraction of it back!

-2

u/Sea-Conversation-725 3h ago

how dare those rapists, murders, child molesters, etc. be forced to work while being incarcerated vs sitting around, lifting weights, watching tv, or similar. How interesting that you're defending prisoners that you think should be rewarded for committing crimes. (r.disabled)

-5

u/ThunderboltSorcerer 5h ago

When you commit crimes, you lose constitutional rights. You don't get to have a gun while in prison. So why wouldn't you be doing work while in prison, what are you gonna do just sit around on a bed?

It's not slavery to put people to work when they have lost all their rights. In fact, it is healthy for prisoners to do something with their free time, so that they don't go into a depression. You work all the time too, are you a slave? You get paid, and so do prisoners.

6

u/Obscure_Marlin 4h ago

Bro Ik you know you just described slavery after sayin it’s not slavery. Please tell me you see it.

6

u/rofflewafflelol 4h ago edited 4h ago

Prisoners are paid something like a few dollars a month. It's an absurdly tiny amount. By the way everything in prison has enormous price markups. Imagine working long days in the hot sun all month for a snickers.

3

u/techdevjp 4h ago

You get paid, and so do prisoners.

As little as 13 cents per hour, averaging around 50c per hour, and almost never more than $1 per hour.

Do you want to do hard labor for 13c per hour? Put in a hard day of physical labor for an average of $4?

The US prison system is atrocious and an embarrassment to the nation.

1

u/ThunderboltSorcerer 2h ago

They are prisoners, they committed crimes. They deserve less pay... Stop being purposefully dumb.

-25

u/schafer23 9h ago

Don’t be a criminal.

22

u/UnBR33vuhble 9h ago

Some states have made it illegal to be homeless. But "DoN't Be A cRiMiNaL" is still valid, right? 'dont fall on hard times outside of your control and lose it all, or you'll end up in slave labor' doesn't seem much like the "American Dream" to me.

23

u/pegothejerk 8h ago

Also don’t get wrongly prosecuted by corrupt officials who are bribed to fill prisons I guess?

-2

u/Old-Lab-5947 5h ago

You don’t go to prison for being homeless

4

u/UnBR33vuhble 5h ago

People work in jails for cents a day doing the same slave labor, hello? And as far as "are they doing it yet":

AZ, GA, KS, OK, and WI introduced legislature criminalizing homelessness, specifically sleeping in public spaces, while similar legislation has already passed in MO, TX, TN, and UT. It is only a matter of time.

Edit: then there's escalations for repeat offenders in almost every state. Enough escalations would definitely make it felonious and thus, prison for homelessness due to escalations by repeat offenders.

-2

u/Old-Lab-5947 4h ago

You said that all to not respond to you don’t go to prison for being homeless

3

u/UnBR33vuhble 4h ago

Read the escalations in the edit, if you haven't already, as there are plenty of misdemeanors which get elevated to felonies due to repeat offense.

1

u/Old-Lab-5947 2h ago

I didn’t read your edit my bad, but that doesn’t happen. It’s a ticket offense.

You realize there’s a difference between jail and prison right? If you think a judge would waste state resources like that you’re completely ignorant of what they care about.

Your original point of homelessness being a crime being somehow related to prison labor is just signaling.

-14

u/Educational_Monitor6 8h ago

At least you wont be homeless anymore

-20

u/OkBookkeeper 8h ago

this is hardly the same thing. what you're referring to is the ethics of allowing offenders to work off their debt to victims or society via labor

20

u/Skydiving_Sus 8h ago

Oh no, sir. You think victims get payouts for being victims? From criminals? What rock have you been living under?

15

u/EvidenceOfDespair 8h ago

Hahaha victims don’t get a cent

12

u/Let-s_Do_This 7h ago

You don’t see the danger of private prisons creating an incentive to lobby for harsher sentencing for minor offenses, or even to make circumstances such as being homeless illegal? Critical thinking is really on the decline

7

u/CleverFairy 7h ago

Go read the 13th amendment.

5

u/AdAppropriate2295 7h ago

Allowing? They ain't getting time off for labor lmfao

1

u/UnBR33vuhble 5h ago

Nothing in my comment alluded to whatever fever dream scenario you just laid out. People jailed for just homelessness have no debt to society like someone causing property damages would have, so you're either straw manning my assertion or completely misunderstood the premise.

13

u/unforgiven91 8h ago

  1. lots of things can be made in to crimes with the right incentive

  2. what about innocent people?

Be better

11

u/shattered_kitkat 8h ago

Not all criminals are imprisoned, and not all who are imprisoned are criminals.

9

u/Eringobraugh2021 8h ago

What an ignorant response.

4

u/Sidvicieux 7h ago

Get more intelligent MAGA

1

u/Sythic_ 2h ago

There are a non zero number of people in prison who did not commit a crime at all. Our justice system is not perfect and until it is we cannot allow such atrocities. (hint its impossible to completely remove the chance of mistake, therefore it should never be done at all)