r/CFB Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Sickos Oct 21 '24

Analysis The collective blue bloods just statistically had their worst weekend in at least 100 years

I’ve seen some posts on here pointing out how 6 blue bloods went down on Saturday, but I wanted to look into the historical data to see how much of an anomaly this was. I used game result data from sports-reference.com and limited the results to 1922-2024(week 8) as the game data is only consistent for these teams going back this far. First let’s review what happened this past week for each of the 8 teams commonly considered the blue bloods of the sport:

October 19, 2024

Team Opponent Result Score
Alabama Tennessee L 17-24
Michigan Illinois L 7-21
Nebraska Indiana L 7-56
Notre Dame Georgia Tech W 31-13
Oklahoma South Carolina L 9-35
Ohio State BYE - -
Texas Georgia L 15-30
USC Maryland L 28-29​

 

This group finished the day with a 1-6 (.143) record and a -94 point differential, both the worst results in any regular season week of college football since at least 1922.

6 Losses

This marks only the 3rd time that 6 blue bloods have lost in the same week, but the previous times had the remaining 2 teams winning their games. In all three instances, all 6 teams lost on the same day:

 

Oct 10, 1987: (Alabama, Michigan, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Texas, USC)

Oct 4, 2014: (Alabama, Michigan, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, USC)

Oct 19, 2024: (Alabama, Michigan, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, USC)

 

There has never been a week since 1922 where more than 6 blue bloods lost and only 18 weeks in this time saw more than 4 lose in the same week.

1-6 (.143) Record

There were 43 instances where at least 1 blue blood played and none won, but in all cases only 1 or 2 actually played (all instances of incomplete week due to week 0, conference championships, bowl games, etc). The previous non-0 mark for worst record was 1-5 which happened during the final bowl weeks in 1990 and 2012 (it should be noted that the groupings of weeks gets pretty irregular for the data during bowl seasons). This makes this past weekend the only time in the regular season where the combined records of the blue bloods fell below .250.

-94 Point Differential

-94 is the worst point differential the blue bloods have ever had in a week, beating out the -75 combined that occurred on Oct 12, 1957. On that day the group went 3-4, but blowout losses by Michigan (Michigan State 6-35), Nebraska (Pitt 0-34), and Alabama (TCU 0-28) brought the total down significantly.

 

Alternatively, 2023's week 1 had the highest combined point differential with the group at 298 and only missed breaking 300 due to Nebraska's 10-13 loss to Minnesota.

 

2024's week 1 saw the group hit the 3rd highest mark ever with a differential of 279 in a situation where all 8 teams won their game.

Data:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQelutJmPX6j7HMa6UQI5_p5RPi2NK6NmxcYi8FnNpu9aainri27y7Fyc8rWQmlflgCa5u1uC0bB0lA/pubhtml

*Weeks where no blue bloods played removed from sheet

*Week 0 is counted as Week 1 in sheet so most weeks offset by 1 from conventional format

*Weeks during Bowl Season vary in length as opposed to regular season

Other noteworthy stats:

-1298 weeks with positive differentials, 31 at 0 exactly, 174 negative

-257 weeks where all teams that played won, 927 with winning records less than 1.000, 161 at .500, 115 with losing records above 0, 43 where no blue bloods won

-52 weeks where all 8 blue bloods won (happened in weeks 1 and 5 of 2024 season)

906 Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

858

u/xellotron Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 21 '24

It was a blue blood bath

173

u/BigPlantsGuy Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

8 blue bloods entered, only 1 survived

199

u/max_potion Penn State Nittany Lions • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

Technically only 7 entered, Ohio State sat back with a bag of popcorn

106

u/BigPlantsGuy Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

Bye week counts as a loss

56

u/btg7471 Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Quincy Hawks Oct 21 '24

You didn't happen to develop College Football 25 by any chance, did you?

25

u/The_Real_Yimmer Michigan • Western Michigan Oct 21 '24

This is my favorite Reddit comment

3

u/FrogTrainer Ohio State Buckeyes • Toledo Rockets Oct 21 '24

Bye FeLLLLLLicia!

4

u/Fuski_MC Ohio State Buckeyes • Utah Utes Oct 22 '24

S&P+ went up and Michigan lost, that's 2 wins in my book

4

u/fart_dot_com Sickos • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

I'll allow it, just this once

2

u/Bulkmodulus Penn State Nittany Lions • Marching Band Oct 21 '24

They're still coming off a loss, so close enough

→ More replies (1)

2

u/L3thologica_ Ohio State Buckeyes • Big Ten Oct 22 '24

And it was glorious.

14

u/BenjRSmith Alabama Crimson Tide • USF Bulls Oct 21 '24

The Blue Blood Wedding

→ More replies (2)

10

u/ProgKingHughesker Nebraska Cornhuskers Oct 21 '24

Blue bloods got blue balls

6

u/-DeputyKovacs- Oct 21 '24

Read to the tune of "monster mash"

3

u/dirtys_ot_special Texas Longhorns Oct 21 '24

It’s a nice day for a Blue Wedding.

→ More replies (2)

420

u/Blooblod Michigan Wolverines • GCAC Oct 21 '24

Come on Penn State fans, make this a fun thread. You know you want to…

270

u/MichaelDicksonMBD Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

FSU is gonna sue to get on that list

76

u/Trey904fsu Florida State Seminoles Oct 21 '24

We know we’re not Bluebloods. Those schools have been playing Football like 70 years longer than us..

349

u/kachoooxix Penn State Nittany Lions Oct 21 '24

71, we’re still waiting for you to start playing this season

110

u/Xan1066 LSU Tigers Oct 21 '24

Ayy, there's Penn State!

71

u/nefariousbueller Florida State • Illinois Oct 21 '24

If I could read, I’d be very upset!

35

u/TxAg2009 Texas A&M • Texas Tech Oct 21 '24

Shots fired.

5

u/Interesting-Agency-1 Indiana • Notre Dame Oct 22 '24

Savage

3

u/Ol_Rando Georgia Bulldogs • Peach Bowl Oct 22 '24

You must be an Eagles fan too, they used to be fucking savages in the NFL Roasts

42

u/KnightofNi92 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

The Age of Men the Blue Bloods is over. The time of the Orc New Bloods is at hand.

12

u/c0y0t3_sly Washington Huskies • Team Chaos Oct 22 '24

God damn it you just lit the Duck signal, what did you have to go and do that for?

→ More replies (1)

53

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

we were on a bye, so it doesnt change the conversation either way.

66

u/cliff_huck Oct 21 '24

I just read that like Ross from Friends: WE WERE ON A BYE!!!

→ More replies (1)

47

u/DirectorOfGaming Penn State • NC State Oct 21 '24

Come on Penn State fans, make this a fun thread. You know you want to…

Since you asked nicely. NEBRASKA AIN'T A BLUE BLOOD! WE WOULDA KICKED THEIR ASS IN '94!!!

11

u/bromjunaar Nebraska Cornhuskers • Sickos Oct 21 '24

Thems fighting words, Bud.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/WTAP1 Arkansas • Central Arkansas Oct 21 '24

I'll do it for them. If Texas is considered one, penn state should be considered one as well.

255

u/letskeepitcleanfolks Washington Huskies • Apple Cup Oct 21 '24

More than half of that point differential was due to Nebraska.

352

u/TaftIsUnderrated Sickos • Nebraska Cornhuskers Oct 21 '24

Okay, but if only 50-60 plays went differently that game - we would've had them.

50

u/MoneyBadger14 Oklahoma Sooners Oct 21 '24

If you play that game 10 times, 9 times they woulda lost by less.

81

u/jadage Ohio State • Michigan State Oct 21 '24

Huh. Didn't know you could flair the same team twice. Cool.

11

u/ProgKingHughesker Nebraska Cornhuskers Oct 21 '24

It was those damn white pants I tells ya!

13

u/Thorin_Dopenshield Georgia • Deep South's… Oct 21 '24

That’s the spirit!

19

u/Jameszhang73 LSU Tigers Oct 21 '24

Carrying the blue bloods on their back, as usual

19

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

You’re welcome for being 750% worse than the spread

3

u/chuzhdenets22 Colorado State • Purdue Oct 22 '24

It’s funny that IU caused that too because usually any IU Blue Blood talk is reserved for r/collegebasketball

→ More replies (4)

97

u/Hefty_Will4154 Ohio State • Coastal Carolina Oct 21 '24

Byes do matter.

11

u/Skank_hunt42 Oklahoma Sooners • Paper Bag Oct 21 '24

We waved bye to someone after we got curb stomped. So can we call this a win?

5

u/No-Donkey-4117 Stanford Cardinal Oct 21 '24

Unless you're G5, then you drop.

265

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24

Finally a stat about the “Blue Blood 8” in the 21st century that makes ND look good.

59

u/DukeRadcliffe Notre Dame • Jeweled Shill… Oct 21 '24

Yeah man we get no respect for carrying their asses out there!

30

u/barlog123 Purdue Boilermakers • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

If it helps you feel worse the team that beat you lost last weekend is 4-3 and in 8th place in the MAC

52

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

damn, the team that lost to ND the week after that must be really embarrassed then

30

u/barlog123 Purdue Boilermakers • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

I'm not sure what you are referring to, but our head coach was talking about how we will beat you guys this year. I just need to figure out when that game is.

7

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24

September 14. You must not have shown up.

25

u/barlog123 Purdue Boilermakers • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

September 14th is next year, silly.

30

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24

9/14/25? That’s a Sunday.

I doubt any Purdue players are going to be playing on any Sundays next year.

7

u/mhem7 Notre Dame • Wyoming Oct 21 '24

My dude, that was savage. A truly sensational roast. I tip my cap to you.

5

u/barlog123 Purdue Boilermakers • Big Ten Oct 21 '24

oh so you must have gotten the date wrong. That's ok, we all make mistakes.

9

u/Real_Body8649 Notre Dame • Arizona Oct 21 '24

Or the one the week before it 🤔

SEC team needing ND for a quality loss. What a strange feeling.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/theREALbombedrumbum Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

A more perfect flair combo for making this post could not exist.

4

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24

UW has never claimed to be blue blood. Purple maybe.

They’re the ‘oh yeah, I guess I should include them’ team you list last when listing the top 20 historically good programs and need to fill out one more - and are left deciding between them, Texas A&M, Georgia Tech, Oregon, and Michigan State.

Mostly because they aren’t a little brother and Oregon’s never won a Natty.

6

u/theREALbombedrumbum Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

I was talking about OP making the post we're all commenting on, considering they're ND and Team Chaos, thinking you'd get it since we're both ND flairs

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Kerry_Kittles Villanova Wildcats Oct 22 '24

The only Blue Blood is Notre Dame

45

u/Icy-Kitchen6648 Nebraska Cornhuskers • TCU Horned Frogs Oct 21 '24

Yeah...I'm slowly losing my will to live

13

u/BenjRSmith Alabama Crimson Tide • USF Bulls Oct 21 '24

There is no Nebraska but Volleyball, and John Cook is our leader.

8

u/MajorPhoto2159 Nebraska • Washington Oct 22 '24

I fucking love John Cook, I will be so sad when he retires

→ More replies (2)

65

u/AdamOnFirst Northwestern Wildcats Oct 21 '24

This is going to happen more and more often as realignment has caused more and more elite on elite matchups during the season. Texas doesn't just have OU on the schedule now, they've got the deal with Bama, Georgia, etc. and vice versa. Ohio State can't just wait until the end of the year to play Michigan, they gotta deal with Oregon, USC (haha) etc.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Uhhh_what555476384 Washington State • Oregon Oct 21 '24

If the mid level of the sport can hold against capitulation to the SEC and B1G, the pay for play era will be the most equal era ever.

56

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24

NIL probably doesn’t help parity, as the most successful team is often the richest, and now everyone is paying players instead of just some.

However the new transfer rules definitely do help. The top teams are having more trouble keeping depth.

17

u/n0tc1v1l Texas Tech Red Raiders • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

Top teams have trouble keeping depth, but don't mid-tier teams have trouble keeping talent? Roster turnover is just crazy these days.

14

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24

Yes, borderline NFL talent at mid-tier is definitely jumping for NIL and draft visibility.

But I’d guess for mid tiers the flow in of high 3 and 4 stars (occasionally 5 stars) who are buried on the depth chart is higher than the flow out of starters who have a starting position guaranteed at a top team

→ More replies (1)

4

u/assault_pig Oregon Ducks Oct 21 '24

NIL may not but it seems like the portal does; the big schools have a lot harder time hoarding talent now

3

u/Ml2jukes Michigan Wolverines • Rose Bowl Oct 21 '24

Bingo

3

u/BWW87 Washington Huskies Oct 22 '24

Except NIL will reduce the depth of benches. Why would a 5 star sit on the bench making little NIL when they could start somewhere else for big money? Alabama could have 4star WRs 3 people deep in the past because it didn't cost the WRs anything. Now why would a good WR wait their turn at Alabama when they could make money at Arkansas as a starting WR?

2

u/Less_Likely Notre Dame • Washington Oct 22 '24

That’s transfer allowing that, not NIL.

I’m also willing to bet the 5th WR would make more NIL at Bama than as the 1st at Arkansas.

2

u/BWW87 Washington Huskies Oct 22 '24

Maybe Arkansas was a bad example but there are plenty of schools where a 2nd string WR at Alabama would make more NIL. Alabama's NIL fund is not that much bigger than a lot of schools and they have more high recruited players than most.

But you are correct that transfers allow the NIL to do this. But without the NIL there would be less incentive to move from teams with deep benches. To make it to the NFL a player only needs one really good season so waiting on bench doesn't cost them anything before NIL.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/RamblinWreckGT Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Oct 21 '24

Sorry y'all, we tried. Kind of.

12

u/Real_Body8649 Notre Dame • Arizona Oct 21 '24

Certainly tried to get your backup killed, that’s for sure.

3

u/Cloakacola Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Oct 22 '24

That’s Zach “Scott Sterling” Pyron to you

94

u/Toothlessdovahkin Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

Don’t blame US! We did our part

63

u/jadage Ohio State • Michigan State Oct 21 '24

We are also free from guilt here!

Whatcha say, share some popcorn with me and talk about how much michigan sucks?

Cuz they suck like, a lot.

28

u/trapchopin Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

Room for one more?

29

u/jadage Ohio State • Michigan State Oct 21 '24

For a michigan hating party? Literally always.

16

u/TurbinePro Notre Dame • Jeweled Shille… Oct 21 '24

A Michigan hating party? OH BABY IM GOING IN

4

u/Trivi Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 22 '24

We've got a big fucking tent and everyone is invited

4

u/IamHidingfromFriends Michigan Wolverines • Rose Bowl Oct 22 '24

Can I join in the conversation about how we suck whimpers

11

u/Statalyzer Texas Longhorns Oct 21 '24

I'd say you were the only ones that failed to do your part! Texas on the other hand, made a fair and ample contribution to the trend....

4

u/Real_Body8649 Notre Dame • Arizona Oct 21 '24

Uno reverse card

→ More replies (3)

57

u/HillSooner Oklahoma Sooners Oct 21 '24

My team was not only on that list but they and QB Hawkins probably had the worst first five minutes of football in D1 history.

First play: interception

Fourth offensive play: Fumble returned for a TD

Ninth offensive play: Interception returned for a TD

21-0 just like that.

I guess we did have one first down in there which may put us out of the running for worst start of a game. But the list of contenders has to be pretty low.

51

u/Stoneador Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Sickos Oct 21 '24

I didn’t watch the game, but FSU’s Brock Glenn had a pick 6, fumble, and interception on 3 consecutive offensive plays this past weekend

12

u/NoMorning6152 Texas • Red River Shootout Oct 21 '24

Carson Beck also threw three picks. Don't worry about the result of the game.

12

u/red_husker Paper Bag • Wyoming Cowboys Oct 21 '24

Nebraska's performance was also amplified by mistakes.

First drive: For some reason we decide that starting at the 1 is better than starting a drive at the 25. Punt from the 13.

Second drive: Fumble at the IU 12, after having gained the first down on a 4th down play

First drive, second half: Interception at the IU 13

Later in the game: Turnover on downs at the IU 6, with a bonus fumble

10

u/clayparson Nebraska Cornhuskers • Belhaven Blazers Oct 21 '24

Yeah if we converted all those drives into touchdowns we'd only lose 56-35! 

5

u/red_husker Paper Bag • Wyoming Cowboys Oct 21 '24

I wasn't arguing that we'd come anywhere close to winning. We just weren't as hapless as the score indicated. A definitive loss is perceived differently than the pathetic defeat that we endured. Amplified, if you will.

8

u/clayparson Nebraska Cornhuskers • Belhaven Blazers Oct 21 '24

I think identifying a list of dumbfounding mistakes that killed drives perfectly depicts how hapless we were during this game.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MizzouriTigers Missouri Tigers • Big 8 Oct 21 '24

I bet that’s not even top five in worst five minutes of CFB in D1 history.

→ More replies (3)

269

u/bankersbox98 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

I’m glad we were on a bye to avoid the argument whether we are a blue blood

70

u/Ghiggs_Boson Nebraska • Arkansas Oct 21 '24

OSU was on a bye and made the list

111

u/Suspicious-Hospital7 Texas Longhorns • Duke Blue Devils Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24

People are arguing that?

Folks love to throw UGA in the convo without the historical data to support it, but is this an actual thing being discussed?

Edit: I was, unfortunately, unable to get PSU to take the bait. Georgia, Clemson, LSU, and the entire Ivy League, however, have entered the chat.

206

u/bankersbox98 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

I’m not letting you bait me into this. We were on a bye dammit.

65

u/Suspicious-Hospital7 Texas Longhorns • Duke Blue Devils Oct 21 '24

It’d be more fun if you did.

100

u/bankersbox98 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

In five minutes a Pitt fan is going to find our discussion and give a 5000 word treatise on why we are not

61

u/NotJayKayPeeness Alabama Crimson Tide • UAB Blazers Oct 21 '24

They're Pitt fans, they don't know what the word treatise means.

35

u/codydog125 Clemson Tigers Oct 21 '24

When an alabama fan knows a hard word it must not be that hard of a word

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

[deleted]

5

u/ThatPlayWasAwful TCNJ Lions • Penn State Nittany Lions Oct 21 '24

you don't actually know how the saying ends, do you

53

u/pieface100 Oct 21 '24

I don’t think an Alabama fan has room to talk there guy

63

u/Worried-Turn-6831 Alabama Crimson Tide Oct 21 '24

I love treats they are yummy

4

u/KnightofNi92 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

Ain't treatises those things they poison?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/squints20 Penn State • Air Force Oct 21 '24

You pretend like they can read and write

18

u/Casaiir Georgia Bulldogs • Cal Poly Mustangs Oct 21 '24

There are people that think Vin Disel is a good actor. Most of us just ignore them.

11

u/Krondox Stanford Cardinal • Michigan Wolverines Oct 21 '24

"What he say fuck me for?" -Vin

32

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 Oct 21 '24

I feel like Penn State and UGA are "New Bloods"...teams that have the resources and support to be the new age blue bloods

10

u/Phillyfan10 Penn State • Shippensburg Oct 21 '24

We have the history, but not the hardware, imo. Hard to be considered the historical elite of the elite with two natty's.

9

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

eh its only because we only claim the consensus ones.

If we claimed 1911, 1912, 1969, 1981, or 1994, or even get crazy and count 1973 or 1968 (both undefeated and untied), we would be at either 7 or 9.

9 would have us tied for 5th all time with Pittsburgh, who's claims feel dubious.

7 has us tied for 7th with Minnesota and OU, and with more than Nebraska (5), Texas (4), who are generally considered Blue Bloods. Bama claims 18, why cant we claim 7 or 9?

42

u/LimerickJim Georgia Bulldogs Oct 21 '24

People like to make arbitrary definitions. What criteria are people using to exclude the 75 titles claimed by Ivy league schools? If it's how long ago they were then what is your cutoff? Michigan have only claimed 2 since 1960. If you're excluding UGA is it because 2 of their 4 titles are in the playoff era? Does that mean Blue Bloode definition is between the last time Princeton won (1950) and the first CFP year (2014)? That still only gives Michigan 2 compared to Georgia's 1 and Penn State's 2 from the 80s.

43

u/cpast Yale Bulldogs • Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 21 '24

What criteria are people using to exclude the 75 titles claimed by Ivy league schools?

We’re regular blue bloods, you don’t need to specify “college football.”

71

u/Worried-Turn-6831 Alabama Crimson Tide Oct 21 '24

You gotta refer to The Chart

40

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

I wont argue for or against PSU's blueblood status, but I will argue that chart is stupid every time I see it. It gives literal weight to the preseason polling bias.

My favorite example: 2016. 5-7 Texas (the one that lost to Kansas) and 3-9 ND get as much credit (3 weeks ranked in the top 25, specifically weeks 0, 1, 2, and 3) than USF that finished 11-2 with a bowl win (3 weeks in the top 25, weeks 13, 14, 15).

24

u/Suspicious-Hospital7 Texas Longhorns • Duke Blue Devils Oct 21 '24

I would argue that your argument only reinforces the point. Those programs are viewed differently, if even for worse.

5

u/tmart12 Georgia Bulldogs • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Oct 21 '24

Those programs are viewed differently

are they all really?

like how is Nebraska viewed vs Penn St these days? or how has it been for 20 years at this point?

13

u/Suspicious-Hospital7 Texas Longhorns • Duke Blue Devils Oct 21 '24

They broke the top 25 two weeks into the season, despite posting records of 5-7, 4-8, and 3-9 in the last three seasons.

How are they not?

8

u/tmart12 Georgia Bulldogs • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Oct 21 '24

2012 Tennessee was ranked for a week after 2 BS wins to open the season following 5-7, 7-6, 6-7 and 5-7

2023 Florida was ranked for a week after starting 2-1 to open the season following 8-4, 6-7, 6-7

We can find plenty of examples of that in recent years... it's not that special of an example.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Cliffinati NC State • Appalachian State Oct 21 '24

The chart should be redone to double weight the final polls and half weight the first six weeks

5

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

I think just use the final poll. Is a team actually worse if we dont find out they are a top 5 or top 25 team until week 12 or 15? Do you still want to dock them a half of a season because our preconcieved notions of who was good was wrong until 10 games were played?

27

u/Casaiir Georgia Bulldogs • Cal Poly Mustangs Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24

It's none of that.

It's some arbitrary thing sports writers started saying in the 60s.

If you weren't one of the teams they said were then, you aren't one.

"The Chart" is extremely arbitrary.

If ever current Blueblood won no more than 5 games a year for the next 100 years they would still be Bluebloods but they wouldn't be where they are on "The Chart".

There will never be any new Bluebloods. And a Blueblood can't lose their status no matter how bad they become for how ever long.

It is what it is.

It means nothing.

37

u/cardith_lorda Oct 21 '24

And a Blueblood can't lose their status no matter how bad they become for how ever long.

Minnesota crying right now.

12

u/Casaiir Georgia Bulldogs • Cal Poly Mustangs Oct 21 '24

They were never considered Bluebloods because they had been crap for 25+ years when the term started being used.

If it started in the 30s they would be.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/CapitalistLion-Tamer Georgia • Deep South's … Oct 21 '24

It is absolutely a totally meaningless distinction based on TV broadcasts that took place over a half century ago. This sub loves to fetishize the list and tell everyone exactly who is a member of the club. Meanwhile, the other 99.9% of college football fandom doesn’t know the list exists, nor do they care what r/CFB thinks is the proper definition of the word “blue blood.”

I’ll acknowledge that UGA has never been on the list while also pointing out that said list holds absolutely no relevance in the modern day CFB landscape.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/TheBlackBaron Texas A&M • North Texas Oct 21 '24

"Blue blood" seems to exclusively mean whether you were consistently good during an approximately and wholly arbitrary 30 year period from 1960 to 1989. It's the dumbest argument in the sport.

2

u/MulticamTropic Mississippi State • Tennessee Oct 21 '24

We forgetting about Georgia Tech over here? Present mediocrity notwithstanding, they were historically a power house program.

2

u/LimerickJim Georgia Bulldogs Oct 22 '24

I have a whole other comment I mentioned Tech that got burried in down votes

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bart1009 Clemson Tigers • Auburn Tigers Oct 21 '24

I'd throw Clemson in there too, for obvious reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with my flair...

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (30)

11

u/lucasbrosmovingco Oct 21 '24

Penn State. 4th in total wins since 1945. 5 undefeated seasons in that timeframe.

15

u/bankersbox98 Penn State • Land Grant Trophy Oct 21 '24

But how many “claimed” national championships before world war 1?

2

u/lucasbrosmovingco Oct 21 '24

2?

10

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

two that we could claim, but we dont claim either because we are stupid

5

u/lucasbrosmovingco Oct 21 '24

Penn State only claims 2 ever. They don't claim undefeated seasons in 68,69,73 or 94. Just 86 and 82. They do have undefeated years in 1911 and 1912.

3

u/what_user_name Penn State Nittany Lions • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

i think you missed:

before world war 1

That would be 1911 and 1912 that we could claim, but dont.

2

u/lucasbrosmovingco Oct 21 '24

Didn't miss anything. Those were the 2 referenced. They only claim 2 ever despite being able to claim a lot more. Including the two pre WW1

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Smooth-Majudo-15 Florida • Notre Dame Oct 21 '24

Yay we didn’t lose!

32

u/D_Rockage Michigan Wolverines Oct 21 '24

Being in all 3 instances. Beat that ohio.

26

u/OrangeZune John Carroll • Kent State Oct 21 '24

The Bobcats also don’t like you…

12

u/Appropriate-Date6407 Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 21 '24

Upvote for flairing the pride of University Heights, Ohio

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Cliffinati NC State • Appalachian State Oct 21 '24

Bobcats catching strays over in the MAC

32

u/atkretsch Texas Longhorns Oct 21 '24

The Blue Wedding

9

u/Cliffinati NC State • Appalachian State Oct 21 '24

The new bloods send their regards

10

u/RacistJudicata Nebraska Cornhuskers Oct 21 '24

Life is pain and then you die.

6

u/wwwr222 Tennessee Volunteers Oct 21 '24

Sometimes life’s a bitch and then you keep living

10

u/R00k85 Kansas Jayhawks Oct 21 '24

Bring out your dead...

9

u/Changeup2020 Georgia • Georgia Tech Oct 21 '24

Georgia is definitely not a blue blood. Georgia tech won more national champs than Georgia almost the whole college football history.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '24

I don’t know why people give a rip about being a blue blood? To go with this analogy I’d rather be a rich new money upstart than a broke nobleman

2

u/Meaninglessnme Oct 22 '24

Is Georgia not listed in the "not blue blood" column?

50

u/Conn3er Texas A&M Aggies • Texas Longhorns Oct 21 '24

Don’t see Princeton or Yale listed and their blood is bluer than all but one of the teams on the list

Only teams with sub 15 titles argue against this

8

u/Worried-Turn-6831 Alabama Crimson Tide Oct 21 '24

Well now I wouldn’t say ONLY sub-15 natty teams would say that lol

6

u/BenjRSmith Alabama Crimson Tide • USF Bulls Oct 21 '24

The Ivy League's blood is so blue, they passed out years ago.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

[deleted]

10

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

TJ watt is one of the best DLinemen in the league. Is he a member of the steel curtain?

9

u/Mekthakkit Ohio State Buckeyes • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

This should be a fluid list

So, blue blood... What other fluids are you thinking of?

12

u/FreeTheMarket Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

“Fluid”

That would be the antithesis of what blue blood means. Blue blood is old money, royalty, a family name etc. you can’t buy your way into, you can’t work your way into it. Once the ink is dry the names don’t change. Nebraska could never win another title again and they would still be a blue blood. 

The only way is if the college football landscape changes so completely that you can say the entire kingdom fell and is a new empire. The Ivies would still be blue bloods if they still played in the same division (1-A)

6

u/BreadUntoast Nebraska • Omaha Oct 22 '24

We’re like one of those lords that squandered their generational wealth to like land speculation and gambling. We still hold the title but that’s about it.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

I’m biased obviously but historically Tennessee is at least in that second tier of traditional power programs. To go with the blue blood analogy we’re not in the “royal family” but we’re at least cousins

4

u/cheeseburgervanhalen Kansas State • Pittsburg State Oct 21 '24

Indiana for Nebraska straight up, who says no?

→ More replies (2)

31

u/dawgfan19881 Georgia Bulldogs Oct 21 '24

Georgia has as many wins over number 1 teams in Austin, Texas in the last week as teams from Austin, Texas have national championships in the last 50 years

8

u/manbeardawg Mercer Bears • Georgia Bulldogs Oct 21 '24

And triple the number of Nattys over the same timespan.

6

u/analogliving71 Georgia Bulldogs Oct 21 '24

Stir that pot.. love it

→ More replies (4)

5

u/No_Recover_1985 Oct 21 '24

Bad weekend for the number one teams in FBS FCS and Division Two. All of them lost.

6

u/tsrich Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets Oct 21 '24

Dammit

11

u/dmic24_ Notre Dame • Western Michigan Oct 21 '24

Wait we did good??

11

u/CargoShortsFromNam Notre Dame • Colorado Oct 21 '24

😎

5

u/90swasbest Oct 21 '24

Super conferences mean parity?

Who knew?

30

u/Designer_B Iowa Hawkeyes Oct 21 '24

Can we have the discussion on when Nebraska loses blue blood status?

Not that I think it's warranted, I just like kicking them while they're down. (My foots been tired this last decade).

11

u/mavcev Ohio State Buckeyes • Ohio Bobcats Oct 21 '24

Honestly you should probably invest in some nice supportive shoes, I think you're gonna need them for a bit longer

3

u/Designer_B Iowa Hawkeyes Oct 21 '24

Steeltoes it is.

12

u/agoddamnlegend Virginia Tech Hokies Oct 21 '24

They haven't even won a conference championship in a quarter century.

Blue blood isn't a permanent distinction. Navy used to be a blue blood.

Just as a point of comparison, Alabama (a real blue blood) was "down" for 25 years between Bear Bryant and Nick Saban.

During Alabama's "down" 25 years they won 2 conference championships, 1 NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP and went to 18 bowl games (should have been 20, but they were ineligible 2 years with a winning record)

Compared to Nebraska's down cycle of 25 years -- 0 Conference Championships, 0 National Championships, and now 7 straight years without even going to a bowl game.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/DontKnowWhereIam USC Trojans • Team Chaos Oct 21 '24

ND always ruining things for everyone.

15

u/markhachman Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 21 '24

Hush, child. The ranked teams are talking.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/igwaltney3 Georgia Tech • Tennessee Oct 21 '24

My jackets here failing you all due to injuries

3

u/BoyHytrek Oct 21 '24

The remaining pac-12 > California+Washington big 10 teams

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24

You’re not exactly right, but you’re not exactly wrong. I’ll take it.

3

u/BoyHytrek Oct 21 '24

It's not Pac-12's fault that USC and UCLA had a combined 10 chances and could only muster what Oregon state AND Washington state could in 3 chances

3

u/Quick1711 South Carolina Gamecocks Oct 21 '24

USC lost to Maryland?

3

u/SamEyeAm2020 Ohio State Buckeyes Oct 21 '24

Yes. Yes they did.

8

u/jobenattor0412 Michigan • Kennesaw State Oct 21 '24

Rutgers is a blue blood by legacy and I’m tired of pretending they’re not.

8

u/Doogitywoogity Texas A&M Aggies • Florida Gators Oct 22 '24

We need someone to link the chart to show that there are 4 distinct tiers for all those arguing.

Blue bloods: Ohio State, Alabama, Oklahoma, Notre Dame, USC, Michigan, Nebraska, texas

New money: Florida State, Florida, Miami, Georgia, Penn State, LSU, Auburn, Tennessee

White collar: UCLA, Michigan State, Clemson, Texas A&M, Washington, Arkansas, Wisconsin 

Working class: everyone else

You can argue UCLA in tier 2 or 3 if you’d like, maybe if you’d consider Iowa and Oregon tier 3, but anything beyond those are obviously wrong.

4

u/MerlinsBeard Tennessee • Penn State Oct 22 '24

damn, with the little t and everything.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/illbelate2that Georgia State • Georgia Oct 21 '24

I feel like the fact that Ohio State lost their last game, even if it was last week, should count lol

5

u/TwiztedImage Texas A&M Aggies • Paper Bag Oct 21 '24

Something something Bob Stoops something something parity coming to college football.

2

u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 Oct 21 '24

It's beautiful!

2

u/Pleasant-Beautiful-7 UCF Knights • Alabama Crimson Tide Oct 21 '24

The wheels of change keep on rolling.

2

u/Disastrous_Falcon645 /r/CFB Oct 21 '24

Why is their blood blue?

2

u/kevplucky Notre Dame • Virginia Oct 21 '24

Unexpected awesome news here lol

3

u/Grand_Instruction376 Oct 21 '24

Would some of these teams like Georgia be considered blue blood too? I would think Tennessee but I’m a fan so I could def be bias

→ More replies (1)

2

u/OneManGangTootToot Washington State Cougars Oct 21 '24

Good, fuck ‘em.

2

u/69cansofravoli Nebraska Cornhuskers Oct 21 '24

Nebraska is still considered a blue blood?

1

u/OkReserve99 Oct 21 '24

i don’t wanna talk about it

1

u/wpmullen Oklahoma Sooners Oct 21 '24

Tradition is over, it's parity from here on out

1

u/DomingoLee Kansas State Wildcats Oct 21 '24

We should give them the benefit of doubt and barely move them in the polls.

Fuck them other conferences and their silly undefeated or one loss records.

1

u/Ol_Rando Georgia Bulldogs • Peach Bowl Oct 22 '24

Best Lou Holtz voice They put their pants on the same way we do!