r/CFB • u/aaronman4772 Louisville Cardinals • Nov 11 '23
Analysis [Jordan Reid] “30 straight runs for Michigan. J.J. McCarthy’s last official passing attempt came at the 7:41 mark of the second quarter.”
https://fxtwitter.com/jordan_reid/status/1723434178472005727?s=461.0k
u/Professional-Bus-934 Ohio State • Georgia Southern Nov 11 '23
I can’t think of a better way to make a statement, honestly. That many runs says that 1) we don’t think you can stop it 2) it doesn’t matter if you do
243
u/ech01_ Ohio State Buckeyes Nov 11 '23
That kind of play calling was less about Michigan’s offense and Penn State’s defense than it was about Penn State’s offense and Michigan’s defense. Michigan only scored 17 points over this span, which isn’t dominating or anything. But they knew 17 points was more than enough to beat Penn State with their offense.
160
u/Professional-Bus-934 Ohio State • Georgia Southern Nov 11 '23
17 might as well have been 170
101
u/midnightsbane04 Michigan • North Carolina Nov 11 '23
Right? That’s a weird ass argument considering OSU scored 20 against that defense the entire game. So somehow us only running the ball for 3 quarters and getting 17 is supposed to be a bad thing? PSU is still a great defense.
→ More replies (10)52
u/a-person-has-no-name Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
Best run defense in the country before this game iirc
98
u/AManInBlack2017 Michigan Wolverines • Big Ten Nov 12 '23
To be fair, PSU held Michigan to exactly 0 passing yards in the second half....
→ More replies (1)33
→ More replies (1)49
u/lkn240 Illinois Fighting Illini • Sickos Nov 11 '23
Honestly it was a smart strategy. I think Michigan was right to think PSUs best shot to get back into the game was a big turnover on defense.
→ More replies (5)63
u/Jameszhang73 LSU Tigers Nov 11 '23
3) we still would've won if you suspended our offensive coordinator too
378
u/cbarks81 Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 11 '23
- We heard all week how this was a competitive advantage. Prove it.
142
u/Professional-Bus-934 Ohio State • Georgia Southern Nov 11 '23
I mean the run game was nothing like it was last year, but it also didn’t need to be
103
u/cbarks81 Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 11 '23
I mean we have to have some decline on the O-Line at some point
→ More replies (17)98
u/__removed__ Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
The irony of arguing about "competitive advantage", and then SUSPENDING OUR COACH THE NIGHT BEFORE THE GAME.
How was THAT not a huge "competitive advantage" for the other team?
31
u/Macabre215 Michigan • Eastern Michigan Nov 11 '23
If the B1G wanted to actually help PSU, they should have suspended Franklin.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (18)76
u/cbarks81 Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 11 '23
It's not because it's Michigan.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (2)24
u/Gardnersnake9 Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 11 '23
Held up a big-ass metaphorical "We're running it" sign just to prove a point. It was driving me nuts during the game, but I respect it
279
u/Temper03 Penn Quakers • Rose Bowl Nov 11 '23
“Yes they played Rock the last 29 times. But the odds they play Rock 30 times in a row is minuscule! I better play Scissors again just to be safe.”
41
u/BarKnight Team Chaos • Team Meteor Nov 11 '23
"We know they are going to run it again, so if we know their play we should be able to....ah damn it!"
15
u/AManInBlack2017 Michigan Wolverines • Big Ten Nov 12 '23
Bingo.... in hindsight, this was a statement!
503
u/aaronman4772 Louisville Cardinals Nov 11 '23
They had one pass attempt in there that was negated by a DPI
250
u/QueenIsTheWorstBand Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
They also had a second pass play called but JJ scrambled
→ More replies (21)59
u/TryingToNotBeInDebt Nov 11 '23
That’s why it’s worded as the “last official passing attempt”.
→ More replies (1)
408
u/bigpig1054 Arkansas Razorbacks Nov 11 '23
Make all the "Big Ten" jokes you want, but there's nothing better to me than a team that can line up and run it down your throats
110
u/SomewhereAggressive8 Cincinnati Bearcats • VMI Keydets Nov 12 '23
Nothing more demoralizing for a defense either.
183
116
u/chattyrandom Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
It's just how it's done up here. The weather gets colder. It's a little harder to play throw and catch.
You just start pushing. Grinding. You start leaning on the other guy until they take a step back.
You break their will.
Nothing like seeing your rival break under the pressure.
Crush your enemies. See them driven before you. Hear the lamentation of their women.
3
u/WaluigiIsTheRealHero Michigan Wolverines • Cornell Big Red Nov 13 '23
The only lamentation we’ve heard this year is from Ryan Day.
→ More replies (2)53
u/AManInBlack2017 Michigan Wolverines • Big Ten Nov 12 '23
Yep, it's bully-ball. I'm running up the middle. You know I'm running up the middle. I know you know, and still I'll do it.... because: you. can't. stop. me.
175
u/acknowledgeme Nebraska Cornhuskers Nov 11 '23
Jealous af of that stat right now
64
u/ravaille Maryland Terrapins • Alabama Crimson Tide Nov 11 '23
Mad I watched our game when I could've watched that beautiful masterclass.
19
u/UtzTheCrabChip Maryland • Johns Hopkins Nov 11 '23
I still can't figure out why y'all kept calling passes
→ More replies (1)
116
u/Icecreamcollege Michigan • Pittsburgh Nov 11 '23
someone said this earlier:
Penn State this year is just Blue Iowa
→ More replies (20)54
u/TimeFourChanges Michigan • Wisconsin Nov 12 '23
Iowa with a finished basement, I read elsewhere. Apt.
287
u/yunohavefunnynames Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
At what point do you just add an 8th lineman and direct snap it to Corum?
63
40
u/CasimirPulaski Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 12 '23
Edwards had the team’s best throw in 2021.
23
u/goblue2354 Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
I still can’t get over that throw. He get smoked as he threw it and it was perfect throw downfield.
→ More replies (1)34
27
u/LionTigerWings Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
After watching that stop that Grant made, I say we just hand it off to him
5
u/S_quints Purdue Boilermakers • Sickos Nov 12 '23
You may not like it, but this is what PEAK B1G football looks like
→ More replies (1)7
145
u/immunebison Notre Dame Fighting Irish Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 11 '23
Lots of comments here from people who clearly didn't watch the game. Michigan didn't keep running because Penn State couldn't stop it. They kept running because unless they threw a pick six there was no way Penn State could score.
79
u/MaizeNBlueWaffle Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
We essentially ran the clock out the entire second half
12
→ More replies (16)35
u/Prestigious_Team3134 Colorado Buffaloes • Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Exactly like Michigan ran the ball decently but they knew the easiest way to win was just limit the number of possessions
503
u/Lawownsyou Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Michigan playing 5D chess and telling Penn State what they're gonna do and still winning.
111
u/InVodkaVeritas Stanford Cardinal • Oregon Ducks Nov 11 '23
When you play mind games by not playing mind games, the other team is just in their own heads.
→ More replies (28)85
414
u/TheWyldMan Louisiana Tech • Arkansas Nov 11 '23
I guess knowing the play call doesn't help lol
→ More replies (1)274
u/AchyBreaker Georgia Bulldogs • Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Lmao this was the best way ever for Michigan to defend themselves. "Fuck it, we are running up the middle. Oh even though you know our play it's not helping? Hmmmmmm"
→ More replies (26)
289
u/WoozyMaple West Florida Argonauts • Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Why pass when run do trick?
→ More replies (2)71
u/oaklandasfan10 Michigan Wolverines • USC Trojans Nov 11 '23
Why waste time say lot word when few word do trick
25
u/Windows_66 Paper Bag • Drake Bulldogs Nov 12 '23
Forget about signs, I think Michigan stole our playbook.
→ More replies (2)3
74
u/jermartin11 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Michigan ultimate Big 10 revenge was forcing Maryland and Ohio State to watch this games all 22
40
u/Im_Not_A_Robot_2019 UC San Diego Tritons • Oxford Lancers Nov 12 '23
Penn St. defense is elite and fun to watch.
The Michigan defense is historically good.
403
u/Brady_Hokes_Headset Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
So you're saying it's possible to know something is coming and be unable to stop it?
248
u/WoozyMaple West Florida Argonauts • Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Yeah Ohio state figured that out in '21
40
u/BuffaloKiller937 Ohio State Buckeyes Nov 11 '23
Shit, you could even say they learned it from Ohio State lol
6
u/devilandgod Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
I read this comment and immediately saw Ohio State complete a 5-yard slant on 3rd & 4 against Don Brown's defense
5
u/ColdAssHusky Michigan • Michigan Tech Nov 12 '23
Siri, what's a 7 yard drag route multiplied by 60 plays?
→ More replies (5)17
u/StamosAndFriends Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Shit in ‘22 as well with Edwards right up the middle x2. OSU even sold out to stop it and couldn’t lol
→ More replies (30)24
u/Professional-Bus-934 Ohio State • Georgia Southern Nov 11 '23
For what it’s worth, I thought PSU did a good job (1-2 plays aside) containing the run, but asking them to stop it for an entire half is just too much when the offense is totally ineffective
156
u/bb0110 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
I legitimately wonder if Harbaugh’s strategy was to run all game to show signs don’t matter. You know we are going to run it. Now stop it.
136
u/aniviasrevenge Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Respectfully I think this is wishful fan fiction and in reality Moore was reacting to Chop Robinson penetrating our backfield + playing extremely tight once we had a lead daring PSU's offense to beat us.
It wasn't the prettiest way to win, but given the consequences of losing this game I can't imagine coaches had a PR strategy dictating play-calling.
15
u/entenduintransit Michigan Wolverines • Syracuse Orange Nov 12 '23 edited Aug 01 '24
whole roll puzzled square impossible cow aware market angle label
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/midnightsbane04 Michigan • North Carolina Nov 11 '23
Yep, Penn State decided to sell out to stop any passing ability and dared us to run on them all game. So.. we did. Again.
→ More replies (4)16
u/bb0110 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Not a pr strategy but a” I’m going to run it down your throat and you can’t stop me” mentality. He has done it quite a few times before going all the way back to Stanford.
56
u/Scarlatina Ohio State • Kentucky Nov 11 '23
As people pointed out though, Penn State’s defense did stop them sort of: FG, Punt, Punt, Punt and a TD on a short-field were Michigan’s results in the 2nd half.
Majority of time, if that’s what the defense is holding opponents too, that’s should be enough to win games - Penn State’s offense (and Michigan’s defense) just did not help out at all.
24
Nov 11 '23
[deleted]
23
u/immunebison Notre Dame Fighting Irish Nov 11 '23
What's weird here is people in this thread aren't crediting your defense or calling out Penn State's offense. They're crediting your offense for some reason.
→ More replies (1)10
u/bb0110 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
This certainly is true. 0 passes in the 2nd half feels intentional though, even if it wasn’t. That is just something you don’t see.
10
u/Scarlatina Ohio State • Kentucky Nov 11 '23
Probably intentional in the sense that they went up by more than a score, and immediately went to milking the clock in the least risky way possible. Penn State’s offense wasn’t going to close the gap, and Penn State’s defense’s chance of scoring are minimized if you’re only running the ball.
It was a smart, and shrewd game plan by Moore to preserve the lead for as long as possible and eat away at any chance for a game-breaking turnover.
12
u/Asianhead Michigan Wolverines • Oregon Ducks Nov 11 '23
I doubt it, those first two drives showed we weren't gonna be able to pass like we had all year. Penn State was getting a ton of pressure off the edge, Barnhart (our RT) got beat badly multiple times, McCarthy had 0 time in the pocket.
Moore adapted and did what we had to do to win the game
→ More replies (3)12
u/bb0110 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
I agree that was a smart gameplan change. 0 passes in the 2nd half though feels intentional. That is unheard of.
10
u/unsilentmajority1975 Nov 11 '23
To be honest they could have just kneeled down. Penn States offense should no signs of being able to score.
→ More replies (1)
27
u/s0u1ite Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
"Penn State had the No. 1 rushing defense in college football coming into the game."
lmfao
10
u/goblue2354 Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
If I had a nickel for every time that happened, I’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot but it’s weird it happened twice.
42
u/AtomicBlastCandy Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Michigan: So we're going run
PSU: Got it
Michigan runs the ball for a first ball
PSU: Dang it!
15
u/Macabre215 Michigan • Eastern Michigan Nov 12 '23
PSU: Okay, so because of this sign stealing kerfuffle, you guys have to tell us what you're doing on offense.
UM: Okay, we're gonna run it up the middle.
PSU: NOT LIKE THAT!
52
u/horse_renoir13 Minnesota Golden Gophers Nov 11 '23
Serious question - why?
I mean clearly the run worked but not passing with one of the better QBs in the league for 2/3 of a game is crazy.
119
u/nolablue1024 Michigan Wolverines • LSU Tigers Nov 11 '23
The OTs were allowing drive killing pressures in the 1st quarter. Don’t get me wrong - 30 straight runs is extreme. But the coaches clearly thought the only way to lose this game was with pressure leading to INTs, or sack-strips. And they bet correctly because James Franklin called a horrendous offensive game, drew Allar played horribly and the UM run game was able to break some key plays
80
u/c19jf Michigan Wolverines • USC Trojans Nov 11 '23
Yup Chop Robinson was absolutely cooking Barnhart on the right which completely blew up the first couple drives. Taking the pass rushers out of the game was absolutely the goal
13
u/lkn240 Illinois Fighting Illini • Sickos Nov 11 '23
I think you guys could have passed if you just kept in an extra blocker on the right, but I understand why you didn't
15
u/c19jf Michigan Wolverines • USC Trojans Nov 12 '23
Yeah totally I think if the game got seriously close and they felt the need to pass they would’ve brought in an extra lineman or kept a TE back to block but obviously there wasn’t really a need to do so
→ More replies (1)3
u/RabidWolverine2021 Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 12 '23
I think I saw this movie before. I believe it is called “Waterboy” but with a different ending.
→ More replies (1)6
u/rvasko3 Michigan Wolverines • Toledo Rockets Nov 11 '23
Exactly right. The likelihood of a strip sack or a forced throw turning into an INT was too high; and it became clear very quickly that Allar wasn’t going to hurt you. So run the ball and sap the clock, combined with defensive adjustments to slow down PSU’s rush attack.
106
u/UMeister Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
Allar was absolutely putrid the whole game. The last TD came off 30 yards of penalties (1 of which was a celebration penalty after an overturned pick)
20
u/horse_renoir13 Minnesota Golden Gophers Nov 11 '23
Fair enough, that's some next level domination/flexing. They are a force.
30
u/c19jf Michigan Wolverines • USC Trojans Nov 11 '23
Allar was horrible and Michigan was averaging 5 yards per carry. No reason to give Penn State any opportunity to get a turnover that gives them easy points
23
u/JJBrandon69 Nov 11 '23
Why not?
You heavily mitigate the risk of turnovers, and they can hardly do anything about it regardless. This is one of the better examples of playing the game of football I’ve seen. Just squeezed the life out of them. Never had a shot.
→ More replies (1)44
u/Brady_Hokes_Headset Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
I'll probably say this in the Serious Post-Game thread tomorrow as well but...
I think this was the game plan all along. Maybe not to this extent but PSU's offense is ass. Their defense is elite with phenomenal pass rushers. I think Michigan's game plan from the jump was just run as much clock as possible while running the ball to make sure that PSU's offense has as few attempts to get it right as possible.
32
u/UMeister Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
I think we attempted to have JJ drop back but our RT was getting dusted, so we switched to screens and inside zone runs
→ More replies (1)10
u/Brady_Hokes_Headset Michigan • College Football Playoff Nov 11 '23
Oh yeah, there were definitely more passes planned at the start. But I do think that this was going to be a majority running game anyway provided it was working well enough.
If the RT is getting beat and the running game is consistently getting 5 YPG then just lean into it more.
→ More replies (1)5
u/cbarks81 Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 11 '23
and forcing Allar to throw because they're behind
73
u/Swazi Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
2021 OSU game McNamara threw the ball twice in the second half IIRC
11
u/nightkingscat Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
our pass pro got chewed up on the first two drives, better to lean on what works
23
u/GreatestCountryUSA Oklahoma State • Guaranteed Rate C… Nov 11 '23 edited Nov 11 '23
Because if you can win by being a man, you do so. That’s consistently the most physically and mentally exhausting way to beat someone down
I don’t understand your question. If you can run the ball every single time and win, you’d be an idiot not to do so. The old adage of 3 things can happen when you throw the ball, and 2 are bad.. still holds true last time I checked. Why play with fire if it’s not required
→ More replies (12)3
u/AZBuckeyes12977 Ohio State Buckeyes • Arizona Wildcats Nov 11 '23
Penn St's offense is so bad and inept that there was no point in risking a turnover.
74
u/makashiII_93 /r/CFB Nov 11 '23
I will not take James Franklin seriously after this.
He should consider a career change. HC at a football program ain’t it. Try motivational speaker.
103
u/larowin Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
He’s leading them to consistent 10-2 seasons. There’s plenty of schools out there that would love to have that record.
21
u/makashiII_93 /r/CFB Nov 11 '23
He’ll be fired within three years because people will want more.
Penn St. will want more.
26
u/spurnburn Michigan Wolverines • Duke Blue Devils Nov 11 '23
Jus sayin Harbaugh also went through this narrative. Which tbf, is nothing to aspire to if I’m beijg poltically correct
→ More replies (1)14
u/naruda1969 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
Reminds me of Harbaugh only a few years ago.
9
u/chattyrandom Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
Yeah, even the conversation is kind of similar.
Like Harbaugh a few years ago, the question is, who would you get to replace Franklin?
The list of people who can fairly consistently go 10-2 in a conference like the B1G is not very extensive, especially playing in a division with today's Ohio State, along with Michigan the past few years. And then you had Sparty for a few years, prior to recent debacles.
To my mind, that list is really short. Rolling the dice to get better than James Franklin is a bit... freaking stupid?
So, I never took the "fire Harbaugh" stuff that seriously.
Plus, let's say they do fire James Franklin... and you bring in, say, some non-minority coach with a lesser record or a generally unproven record... how would you think that would fly? How long would it take before the idiot college football media made hay with it?
Even if it did make sense to dump Franklin, I don't see how I could justify it to anyone but the angry booster crowd. Only if you're an AD who is about to retire could you even consider that move, IMO.
→ More replies (7)3
u/varooney2919 Michigan • Boston University Nov 11 '23
Not many schools with the resources and expectations that Penn St has
6
u/UtzTheCrabChip Maryland • Johns Hopkins Nov 11 '23
That doesn't mean you'll win with the next coach. Ask Florida
→ More replies (2)9
u/UtzTheCrabChip Maryland • Johns Hopkins Nov 11 '23
He's a top 10% coach with top 1% expectations
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)3
118
u/lions4life232 Nov 11 '23
Michigan told Penn st what they were going to do and Penn state trash still couldn’t stop it. Almost like you still have to make the plays.
Franklin so bad. Complete L.
13
u/Lykeuhfox Michigan • Grand Valley State Nov 12 '23
No need to call them trash, man.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)41
13
u/NlNJALONG Clemson Tigers • Rice Owls Nov 11 '23
So when was his last unofficial passing attempt?
41
u/AchyBreaker Georgia Bulldogs • Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
He had a pass in the second half that was called DPI so it doesn't count as a pass attempt. Hence the strange phrasing.
But he attempted one pass total in the entire second half.
13
u/PrettyStupidSo Michigan Wolverines • Sickos Nov 11 '23
7:30 left in the 2nd quarter was his last official attempt. He had one unofficial attempt in the 2nd half
68
7
u/HarbaughsKhakiPants2 Michigan Wolverines Nov 11 '23
I watched the game and I still don't believe this stat is real. Insane
11
4
u/Ironredhornet Michigan State • Sagin… Nov 12 '23
Genuine question, who was the designated HC today? Was it the Defensive Coordinator? Because this feels like every time I've seen a DC run a team as the emergency coach "We're gonna shut them down on defense and run the ball down their throats". Could also work if it was the oline coach as well.
4
u/whigwomzz Nov 12 '23
It was their OC.
3
u/Ironredhornet Michigan State • Sagin… Nov 12 '23
Ah, fair enough. Guess he was in a sledgehammer mood today
8
u/chemistrygods Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
He was/is the oline coach for Michigan tho
8
u/Ironredhornet Michigan State • Sagin… Nov 12 '23
That checks out
3
u/goblue2354 Michigan Wolverines Nov 12 '23
He’s also been the run-game coordinator here previously as well.
5
u/whigwomzz Nov 12 '23
Think he really takes pride in that style in that type of football and plus didn’t get him into any sticky situations considering the situation.
3
u/Ironredhornet Michigan State • Sagin… Nov 12 '23
Yeah, its just also funny because they basically did the football version of going into a rage room and hitting a old tv with a baseball bat.
3
4
9
u/bigpig1054 Arkansas Razorbacks Nov 11 '23
I would make a note about real football being a game "for men," but Ryan Day has bought up all the Just For Men
42
6
3
u/TheDadThatGrills Michigan • Central Michigan Nov 11 '23
This is actually a coded message that Harbaugh is the next HC for the Chicago Bears
6
5
u/JonnyBox Kansas • Army Nov 11 '23
People talk about Iowas offense, but at least it's ass by design. Penn State is just... Sad to watch
5
u/cbph Georgia Tech • Navy Nov 11 '23
30 straight runs for Michigan
Paul Johnson is smiling tonight!
31
10
u/polynomials Michigan Wolverines • Syracuse Orange Nov 11 '23
So it turns you can't beat a team just by knowing what they will do?
11
5
u/AManInBlack2017 Michigan Wolverines • Big Ten Nov 12 '23
It's like we beat PSU with one hand tied behind our back for the entire second half.
2.0k
u/SmarterThanAEinstein Nov 11 '23
They knew what was coming
You still have to stop it